1 / 23

Impact evaluation design for: PADYP Benin Jocelyne Delarue - AFD

Impact evaluation design for: PADYP Benin Jocelyne Delarue - AFD. NONIE design clinic 1 Cairo April, 2009 1 Original format and presentation developed by the World Bank SIEF. Section A : Presentation of project. Project background & context.

Sharon_Dale
Télécharger la présentation

Impact evaluation design for: PADYP Benin Jocelyne Delarue - AFD

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Impact evaluation design for: PADYP BeninJocelyne Delarue - AFD NONIE design clinic1 Cairo April, 2009 1Original format andpresentation developed by the World Bank SIEF Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  2. Section A: Presentation of project Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  3. Project background & context • Objective : Develop agricultural productivity through farming system management • Second phase of the project : scaling up • Expansion from 3 000 to 18 000 members • Expansion in new communes, new zones and new farming systems (12000 cotton farmers, 3000 non cotton farmers) • Activities (2009 – 2013) : • training of 75 new advisers and 525 key farmers (KF) • Every adviser supports 60 members and 140 more through KF (20 m/KF) • Prepare sustainability (participation of farmers to service payment) • Counterfactual situation : classical extension services recently extended by Benin government • The project is financed by AFD (10 M. €), cotton cooperatives (3.4 M.€) and Benin State (1.4 M.€) Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  4. RESULTS CHAIN Xxx Impact indicator Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  5. Key research questions • Is the farming system management (FSM) service more efficient than top-down extension service to enhance agricultural productivity ? (cf. the causal chain) • Who are the members ? • Are there spill over effects on non members ? (networks effects) • What are the effects at a more aggregated level (village, value chain)? • Operational questions • How to succeed the scaling up • How to involve durably the farmers cooperatives in this service provision Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  6. Outcome indicators • Number of farms which use farming system management tools/methods • Activity planning • Stock management • Cash management • Credit management • Number of farms who apply new cropping techniques • Number of farms who adopt new crops and activities Impact Indicators • Yields, Costs, Productivity for each crop • Prices obtained for crops sold • Food security in the family • Income Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  7. Identification strategy/method • Use the expansion of the program (pipeline method ? Instrumental variable ?) • Comparison with a counterfactual situation : top-down extension services, currently extended also • Combination of qualitative and quantitative methods Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  8. Sample and data (1) Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  9. Sample and data (2) Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  10. Sample and data (3) Monitoring system of the project (activities, number of advisers, key farmers, members, method use…) Members’ farming systems caracteristics and economic results Secondary data : census, market prices, … Probably : Available data on crop productivity without farming system management Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  11. Time frame/work plan • Impact evaluation : 2009 - 2012 Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  12. Sources and finances • AFD • CIRAD Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  13. Section B: Impact evaluation of project Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  14. Evaluation framework and context • [Insert text on framework and context here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  15. Evaluation questions • [Insert text on evaluation questions here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  16. Evaluation audience and policy it is trying to influence (if appl.) • [Insert text on audience and policy here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  17. Evaluation design • [Insert text on evaluation design here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  18. Challenges and risks • [Insert text on evaluation challenges risks here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  19. Methodology • [Insert text on evaluation methodology here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  20. Evaluation implementation • [Insert text on evaluation implementation here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  21. Management • [Insert text on evaluation management here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  22. Expected results • [Insert text on expected evaluation results here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

  23. Expected conclusions • [Insert text on expected evaluation conclusions here] Network of Networks on Impact Evaluation

More Related