1 / 18

Evangelical Universalism: Oxymoron?

Evangelical Universalism: Oxymoron?. Robin Parry. Can an evangelical be a universalist?. Universalists say that God will save all people Historically almost all evangelicals have denied this and evangelical statements of faith seek to exclude it

aretha
Télécharger la présentation

Evangelical Universalism: Oxymoron?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Evangelical Universalism:Oxymoron? Robin Parry

  2. Can an evangelical be a universalist? • Universalists say that God will save all people • Historically almost all evangelicals have denied this and evangelical statements of faith seek to exclude it • Surely “evangelical universalism” is an oxymoron! • My claim: Evangelical opposition to universalism is contingent and not an entailment of evangelical commitment

  3. What is “evangelical” universalism? • Aside from affirming orthodox Christian faith and holding a high view of Scripture an EU holds two beliefs: EU1 and EU2 • EU1: “in the end, God will reconcile all people to himself through Christ’s atoning work” • EU2: “EU1 is a biblical belief” • My version maintains most of the normal evangelical beliefs, with two adjustments: (a) a belief that people can be redeemed from hell, and (b) a belief that, in the end, all will be redeemed from hell

  4. Why think universalism is essentially unevangelical? • Most evangelicals think that the Bible contradicts universalism • But universalists believe that their view is biblical • Even if they are mistaken their mistake would only exclude them from evangelicalism if it involved them affirming something incompatible with a central evangelical beliefs • If it does not then it can be tolerated as an evangelical-compatible error (like Calvinism ) • So does universalism entail a denial of key evangelical belief?

  5. 1. Universalism undermines the seriousness of sin • “It does not matter what we do because God will save us all anyway” • EU has a strong view of human sin • But a high view of grace • “Where sin abounds grace abounds all the more”

  6. 2. Universalism undermines divine justice and wrath • Universalists sentimentalize God’s love and ignore God’s justice and wrath (“it’s God’s job to forgive us; he is too nice to damn anyone”) • EU seeks to have a biblical, Christ-shaped understanding of God’s love • EU does not ignore divine justice nor divine wrath and punishment • EU arguably has a more theologically satisfying understanding of the divine nature as holy love

  7. 3. Universalism undermines hell • The “hell” of universalists “ain’t a bad place to be” (the same objection is made to annihilationists) • If hell is only fearful if it maximally horrible then this objection stands . . . • But that something is not maximally horrible does not mean that it is not very horrible and to be avoided • (as an aside, the ECT vision of hell is riddled with problems so EU’s failure to affirm ECT is perhaps a strength)

  8. 4. Universalism undermines Christ’s role in salvation • Universalism says that “all roads lead to God—Christ is only a way to the Father but not the way” • EU maintains that Christ is the only way to the Father and that salvation is only through union with Christ • EU can be inclusivist or exclusivist

  9. 5. Universalism undermines the importance of faith in Christ • “Christ will save us all so it does not matter whether we believe in him or not”—the significance the NT attaches to faith is undermined • If one is an exclusivist EU then faith in Christ is a necessary condition for salvation • If one is an inclusivist EU then faith in Christ is relativised (though Christ’s role is not) but not unimportant (NOTE: the inclusivism, not the universalism, is the issue)

  10. 6. Universalism undermines evangelism • “Why proclaim the gospel to people if they will be saved anyway?” Universalism undermines evangelism • The gospel is God’s means for saving people—so we proclaim it (cf. Calvinism) • Arminian universalists do have fear of hell as a motivation for evangelism (hell is more of a motivation for them than for the Calvinist) • Fear of hell is not the only motive for gospel-proclamation (indeed universalism adds its own motivations)

  11. 7. Universalism undermines the doctrine of the Trinity • Universalism is often linked with Unitarianism: one heresy often leads to another • The link is partial: Trinitarian Universalism is older and longer-lasting • The link is historically contingent: nothing about universalism entails Unitarianism

  12. 8. Universalism was declared a “anathema” by the Church • Universalism was declared heresy by an ecumenical church council so universalists are “unorthodox” and hence “unevangelical” • Only a specific version of universalism (Origenism) was declared anathema by the church, not universalism per se

  13. 9. Historically evangelicalism has rejected universalism • True (almost) • But I claim that this rejection is contingent and not necessary so on its own it is not decisive • Evangelicalism is a living tradition with capacity for healthy development • Which central evangelical beliefs do “evangelical” universalists deny? • EU arises from evangelical convictions: the saving will of God, the redeeming power of the Christ’s atonement, the efficacious work of the Spirit, a belief that in the end Christ triumphs, etc.

  14. Elhanan Winchester (1751–1797) • Baptist—revivalist preacher in USA • Came to believe in “universal restoration” • Founded Universalist Baptist Church in Philadelphia and another in London • Remained evangelical in his theology of Trinity, atonement, Bible, evangelism, etc. • Remained active in gospel-preaching

  15. EU grows from common evangelical conviction • Arminian: God loves all people, wants to save all people, and sent Christ to die for all people to achieve this goal • Calvinist: God will achieve all his purposes in salvation; all for whom Christ died will be saved • Both A and C are evangelical so are EUs unevangelical for holding both belief-sets? • A & C combined entail universalism . . . • . . . or must evangelicals believe that either (a) cannot save all, or (b) does not want to save all?

  16. EU grows from the evangel • Our eschatology must be grounded in God’s revelation in Christ • At Calvary we see hell (which turns out to be neither annihilation nor eternal torment) • In the resurrection we see new creation • In the resurrection of the Second Adam, all humanity has already been saved • The eschaton—end of the story—is already revealed in Christ (this is why I am not just a “hopeful” universalist)

  17. EU and Bebbington’s Quadrilateral • EU is consistent with Bebbington’s quadrilateral: • Biblicism • Crucicentrism • Conversionism • Activism

  18. Evangelical Universalism • Creedal orthodoxy and high view of Scripture • Christocentric • Trinitarian • Evangel-focused • Missional • Biblically rooted • My Question: What else does one have to be to count as “evangelical”?

More Related