1 / 52

Andrew McIntyre, CIH Managing Principal & Co-Founder

EHS & Sustainability Considerations in Alternative Energy (Photovoltaic) Market Areas “New Directions in EH&S Practice” 20th Annual CIHC Conference December 6-8, 2010. Andrew McIntyre, CIH Managing Principal & Co-Founder. Presentation Overview. Introduction What are Photovoltaics?

briana
Télécharger la présentation

Andrew McIntyre, CIH Managing Principal & Co-Founder

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. EHS & Sustainability Considerations in Alternative Energy (Photovoltaic) Market Areas“New Directions in EH&S Practice” 20th Annual CIHC ConferenceDecember 6-8, 2010 Andrew McIntyre, CIH Managing Principal & Co-Founder

  2. Presentation Overview • Introduction • What are Photovoltaics? • Example Manufacturing Processes • Chemical & Physical Hazard Overview • Driving DFESH into the Manufacturing Supply Chain • Key Manufacturing and Facility EHS & Sustainability Considerations • Feeding the Utility Grid • Solar Field Impacts and Considerations • Summary

  3. Introduction – What are Photovoltaics? • Devices (solar cells) that convert sunlight into direct current (DC) electricity • Consist of thin layers of semiconductor material placed on a silicon (or alternate material) substrate with a protective layer added and wiring integrated to conduct electricity • Very similar to transistors • Solar cells are assembled into modules • Modules are then assembled into larger collections of panels and arrays • Renewable energy source • Do not emit greenhouse gases during “use” phase of life • A means to offset the generation of energy from burning fossil fuels as fossil fuels create significant CO2 emissions • 1GW of PV electricity production will serve the needs of approximately 145,000 average U.S. homes and save roughly 1 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions annually

  4. Introduction – What are Photovoltaics? • Solar energy liberates excess electrons that then flow to produce electricity

  5. Introduction – Why Viewed as a Clean Industry? “A means to offset the generation of energy from burning fossil fuels” Source: “Solar Environmental Impacts”, World of Photovoltaics Magazine. www.worldofphotovoltaics.com

  6. Example Manufacturing Processes

  7. Introduction - PV Manufacturing Technologies & Related Efficiencies

  8. Introduction – PV Manufacturing Product Overview

  9. PV End Product Application • Photovoltaic Panel Configuration • Flat‐Plate Solar Panels • The most common type of solar panel • Absorb both direct sunlight and diffuse sunlight reflected from clouds and objects on the ground • Concentrating Photovoltaic (CPV) • A specialized type of solar panel which uses mirrors or lenses to focus high concentrations of direct sunlight onto high‐efficiency solar cells • Cannot absorb diffuse light, so are typically used only in areas with high levels of sunlight such as the Southwest United States. • In order to maintain focus, CPV employs tracking systems, allowing them to follow the sun’s path as it moves across the sky • Tracking systems • Can be single‐axis – which track the sun throughout the day – or dual‐axis, which also adjust to the sun’s elevation in the sky from season to season. • Tracking systems are also occasionally used for flat‐plate systems. • Depending on conditions, tracking systems can add 25 percent or more to the total electrical output of a solar energy system © 2010 EORM, Inc. 9

  10. Chemical & Physical Hazard Overview

  11. Crystalline Silicon (c-Si) Based PV Cells - Overview • Crystalline silicon-based PV Cells: • Most common of all solar cell types (~80%) • Rooftop applications • Large utility arrays • Crystalline silicon processes relatively simple – model semiconductor manufacturing steps • Crystal Growth • Doped with Phosphorous or Boron • Ingot slicing, lap and polish • Sandwiched between glass or layers of ethyl vinyl acetate and a polymer laminate • Metal grids and contacts added © 2010 EORM, Inc. 11

  12. Crystalline Silicon (c-Si) Based PV Cells – Chemical Hazards • Corrosives and Oxidizers • Used for cleaning and etching in open top tanks, baths, etc. • Corrosives • Hydrochloric acid • Hydrofluoric acid • Oxidizing Acids • Nitric acid • Sulfuric acid • Bases • Sodium hydroxide • Oxidizers • Hydrogen peroxide • Engineering Controls • Process enclosures of tanks and baths • LEV

  13. Crystalline Silicon (c-Si) Based PV Cells – Chemical Hazards • Metals • Used for electronics (connecting wires, contacts, etc.) • Lead • Zinc • Silver • Copper • Engineering Controls • Process enclosures • LEV

  14. Crystalline Silicon (c-Si) Based PV Cells – Chemical Hazards • Irritant Dust • Cutting, sawing, scribing PV Si cells • Production of silicon dust (known as “kerf”) • Engineering Controls • LEV

  15. Thin Film (Amorphous) Silicon-Based PV Cells - Overview • Thin film amorphous silicon-based PV Cells • Power low power consumer products • Solar panels • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMQfmUpurJM • Amorphous silicon processes more complex – similar to semiconductor manufacturing steps • Cleaning • Laser and Chemical Etching • Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) • Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD) • Ion Implant © 2010 EORM, Inc. 15

  16. Thin Film (Amorphous) Silicon-Based PV Cells – Chemical Hazards • Pyrophorics, Flammables, and Toxic Gases • Used for doping thin films • Silane - pyrophoric • Phosphine – toxic and pyrophoric • Arsine - toxic • Phosphorous chloride (POCl3) - toxic • Diborane - toxic • Engineering Controls • Use of sophisticated hazardous gas distribution systems • Used in sealed, pressurized chambers with LEV • Purge gases

  17. Illustration – PV Thin Film Fabrication Thin Film a-Si

  18. Illustration – PV Thin Film Fabrication Thin Film a-Si

  19. Overview – Thin Film PV Manufacturing Steps Potential Health and Environmental Impacts Associated with the Manufacture and Use of Photovoltaic Cells, EPRI, Palo Alto, CA, and California Energy Commission, Sacramento, CA: 2003. 1000095. http://mydocs.epri.com/docs/public/000000000001000095.pdf

  20. Thin Film CdTe and CdS-Based PV Cells - Overview • Cadmium Telluride (CdTe) and Cadmium Sulphide (CdS): • Thin film type • Fastest growing share of market (15-20%) • Similar in application and process to thin film amorphous Si PV cells • Can be used together or with other materials for multi-junction thin film PV cells © 2010 EORM, Inc. 20

  21. CdTe and CdS-PV Cells – Chemical Hazards • Metals • Used for electronics (connecting wires, contacts, etc.) • Deposition - spray pyrolysis, maintenance, cleaning • Cadmium and cadmium compounds such as CdCl2 • Recognized carcinogen • Nickel • Molybdenum • Engineering Controls • Process enclosures • Sealed, pressurized chambers with LEV • LEV

  22. CdTe and CdS-PV Cells – Chemical Hazards • Others • Thiourea (thiocarbamide) and ammonia • Used in electro-deposition (chemical bath) process • Engineering Controls • Process enclosures • LEV

  23. CIS and CIGS-Based PV Cells - Overview • Copper or Cadmium Indium Gallium and Selenium - (CIS) and (CIGS): • Thin film type • Small percent of market (~5%) • Processes vary, but usually involve some form of deposition step • Newer approaches involve application using pastes © 2010 EORM, Inc. 23

  24. CIS and CIGS-Based PV Cells – Chemical Hazards • Metals • Used for electronics (connecting wires, contacts, etc.) • Deposition, sputtering, etc. • Cadmium • Copper • Indium • Gallium • Selenium • Molybdenum • Engineering Controls • Process enclosures • Sealed, pressurized chambers with LEV • LEV

  25. High Efficiency PV Cells - Overview • High-efficiency multijunction cells • Consist of multiple thin films produced using Metal Organic Chemical Vapor Deposition (MOCVD) • Also called cascade or tandem cells • III-V Material (vs silicon) based substrate • Are the highest‐efficiency solar cells currently available, • Expensive to manufacture • Are used when weight and efficiency are at a premium • Satellites, • High‐performance solar‐powered vehicles • Military applications, and • For concentrating PV (CPV) © 2010 EORM, Inc. 25

  26. Illustration – Gallium Arsenide (GaAs) PV Concentrator Cell Mfg Metal Organic Chemical Vapor Deposition Process Exhaust Vent Arsine / Phosphine Gas Scrubber Delivery Hydrogen Detector & Fire Sprinkler Gas Handling system mfc N2/ H2 mfc MOCVD N2 Reactor mfc mfc Hydrogen Detector & Ammonia Detector © 2010 EORM, Inc. 26

  27. High Efficiency Based PV Cells – Chemical Hazards • Chemicals used • Metal Hydrides • Arsine • Phosphine • Metal Organic Precursors • i.e., Trimethyl Gallium, Trimethyl Indium • Engineering Controls • Process enclosures • Sealed, pressurized chambers with LEV • LEV

  28. Nanomaterial-based Cells – Chemical Hazards • Improved efficiencies • Sometimes applied as ink pastes • Nano-scale materials used: • Cadmium • Silicon • GaAs • CdTe • Carbon • Engineering Controls • Process enclosures • LEV • HEPA vacuums

  29. Physical Hazards - Ionizing Radiation Sources • Types and Applications: • X-ray machines (XRF, XRD) • Sealed sources • Used for calibration, measurement, inspection • Engineering Controls • Interlocked enclosures • Sealed sources

  30. Physical Hazards - Non-Ionizing Radiation Sources • Types and Applications: • Microwave generators • Radiofrequency (RF) generators • Used by some deposition tools • Engineering Controls • Shielding

  31. Physical Hazards - Laser Sources • Types and Applications: • Used at many PV facilities • Up to Class 4 lasers • Applications • Cutting, scribing processes • Measurement • Engineering Controls • Interlocked enclosures • Controlled access • Non-reflective surfaces

  32. Robot and Robotics Automation • Engineering Controls • Restricted Work Envelope • Safety interlocks • Interlocked barriers, light curtains, pressure sensitive mats, etc.), • Causes all robot motion to stop and removes power from the robot drive actuators • Teach pendant • Allows personnel to program the robot from within the safeguarded space around the robot • Robot speed is limited to 10 inches/sec in “teach mode”

  33. EHS&S Solutions – Driving DFESH into Supply Chain

  34. EHS&S Solutions – Driving DFESH into Supply Chain • Supply Chain Design for Environment, Safety and Health Program • Hold capital equipment suppliers building tools for the PV Industry accountable for safe design and delivery • Safer, more reliable process equipment with appropriate EHS control technology incorporated will: • Prevent injuries and minimize environmental impact • Increase speed of EHS start up approval and minimize expensive (EHS) retrofits • Reduce manufacturing downtime due to EHS concerns associated with maintenance activities © 2010 EORM, Inc. 34

  35. Recap - Manufacturing & Facility EHS&S Considerations

  36. Recap - Key EHS&S Considerations - Manufacturing • Physical Safety Considerations • Fall protection • Confined space entry • Cranes and hoists • Machine guarding • Robot and Robotic Systems • Industrial Hygiene • Robust Control of Carcinogens • Surface Contamination Control for Cadmium and Arsenic • Promotion of excellent housekeeping practices © 2010 EORM, Inc. 36

  37. Recap - Key EHS&S Considerations - Manufacturing • Hazardous Energy Control • Material handling • Conveyor safety • Manual Handling • Glass Industry experience leveraged • Preventive and Corrective Maintenance • Large subsystem components • Noise • Increase in noise from larger support equipment • Can it be attenuated? © 2010 EORM, Inc. 37

  38. Recap - Key EHS&S Considerations - Facility • Facility • Impact of Larger Equipment Footprint • Enough space? • Increased utility requirements such as power, exhaust (both LEV and heat) • Local Jurisdiction Permitting • Timely submission to avoid startup delays • Environmental • Abatement systems • New hazardous waste stream(s) • Product Recycling © 2010 EORM, Inc. 38

  39. Feeding the Utility Grid

  40. Feeding the Utility Grid - Background • PV arrays consist of groups of PV modules called “tables” • Each table consists of 45 modules and measures approximately six feet wide by 60 feet long • PV arrays are designed to withstand earthquakes and ground movement © 2010 EORM, Inc. 40 40

  41. Feeding the Utility Grid – Existing - DeSoto Energy Center - Florida • At 25 MW peak output, the DeSoto Next Generation Solar Energy Center in DeSoto County, FL is currently the largest PV installation in the United States • The facility came online in 2009 and generates over 42,000 megawatt‐hours of electricity each year (Photo—Florida Power & Light) © 2010 EORM, Inc. 41 41

  42. Feeding the Utility Grid – Current Project • Topaz Solar Farm • Location • Carrisa Plains, CA in San Luis Obispo County • Size • 4500 Acre site • Production Output • 550 Megawatts of Power • Will produce sufficient electricity to power 160,000 homes through delivery of approximately 1,100 gigawatt-hours (GW·h) annually of renewable energy © 2010 EORM, Inc. 42 42

  43. Feeding the Utility Grid – Current Project • Topaz Solar Farm • Displaces 290,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide annually which equals the removal of 55,000 cars off the road annually • Power will be sold to PG&E and will help PG&E customers meet the State’s Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS). • California strategic goal of >33% of power coming from renewable energy sources by Year 2020 © 2010 EORM, Inc. 43 43

  44. Solar Field EHS&S Impacts and Considerations

  45. Feeding the Utility Grid – EHS&S Impacts Requiring Consideration • Environmental and Safety Impacts • Agriculture • Air Quality • Biological Resources • Geology, Soils, and Seismicity • Hazards and Hazardous Materials • Hydrology and Water Quality • Land Use and Planning • Noise • Population and Housing • Public Health and Safety • Public Services • Traffic and Transportation • Utilities © 2010 EORM, Inc. 45 45

  46. Feeding the Utility Grid – Operational EHS Compliance • Monitoring and Maintenance • Focused on management of lighting, reflectivity, noise, heat, materials storage and cleanup, safety, and repair • Supported by small crew – Expect ~15 staff • Primary EHS Considerations • Safety • Heat stress, sunburn, appropriate EAP, contact with wildlife • Environmental • For this California project, a PV Module end-of-life program is in place - supported by a pre-funded module recycling program © 2010 EORM, Inc. 46 46

  47. Wrap Up and Summary Points • Continued demand for energy with distinct environmental benefits over traditional energy generating technologies • Essential that the PV industry fulfills the perception of being a green industry • Imperative that the PV industry learns from the past EHS&S pitfalls encountered during the expansion of similar high-technology industries • Experience with the semiconductor industry over the last three decades has provided a clear EHS&S roadmap for the PV industry to follow 47 47

  48. Wrap Up and Summary Points • Although EHS&S may fall down on the list of priorities during periods of rapid growth, experience demonstrates that small investments now will produce huge benefits later • Mitigation or avoidance of EHS issues can be addressed with the proper planning and implementation of DFESH into the PV Supply Chain • Given the PV industry’s green reputation, a strong commitment to world-class EHS&S management systems is a critical business priority 48 48

  49. Wrap Up and Summary Points In summary, the PV industry has both the opportunity and the business imperative to strive for world-class performance in implementing sustainable environmentally responsible controls and work practices 49 49

  50. EORM PV EHS&S Articles –Photovoltaic Times

More Related