1 / 68

Classifying Shabo

Classifying Shabo. Tyler Schnoebelen ACAL 40 10 Apr 2009. Shabo. Shabo. Lots of data. 242 languages of Central/East Africa 90 Nilo-Saharan languages 1213 data points on structural features (phonological, morphological, syntactic) Wordlists for 30+ languages. Handling complexity.

brilliant
Télécharger la présentation

Classifying Shabo

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Classifying Shabo Tyler Schnoebelen ACAL 40 10 Apr 2009

  2. Shabo

  3. Shabo

  4. Lots of data • 242 languages of Central/East Africa • 90 Nilo-Saharan languages • 1213 data points on structural features (phonological, morphological, syntactic) • Wordlists for 30+ languages

  5. Handling complexity

  6. Past classifications of Shabo • Bender • 1983: Nilo-Saharan? • 1995: Isolate? • Anbessa and Unseth (1989) • Nilo-Saharan>Eastern Sudanic • Fleming (1991) • Nilo-Saharan>Major branch (closest to Koman) • Ehret (1995) • Isolate • Ethnologue, WALS (current) • Nilo-Saharan>Unclassified

  7. Evidence for the NS hypothesis • Morphology • Plural morpheme (-k) • Accusative case suffix (-k) • Lexicon • Lots of NS look-alikes

  8. Plural problems • Shabo pluralizes by adding yero(‘many’) after the (singular) noun • Previous researchers also found a –k plural (common in NS) • Probably Majang interference • A –k strategy isn’t accepted by any of my consultants • Semantically plural words show no hidden –k

  9. Case conundrums • Accusative case –k • True, though the accusative case is sometimes –kak, sometimes,–ka, sometimes –k • It’s also used for location (much like Urdu ko) • No other case markers are similar

  10. Wobbly wordlists • My consultants reject about 12% of the lists people have used to classify Shabo • Mostly because of Majang interference • As for the remaining, as Ehret (1995) points out there seem to be too many resemblances, to too many different languages

  11. Bender (1996) on Nilo-Saharan characteristics • Singular N/plural K • Masculine R/feminine B/sometimes neuter n • Inclusive/exclusive pronouns • a or iin all pronouns • Near demonstrative i, far e • Perfect o (or a), imperfect e

  12. NS shared innovations • Bender has 80 of these • The only things that look close are: • bV negative • (Saharan, Fur, Koman) • Shabo’s is –be • T locative • (Berta, Kunama, part of Eastern Sudanic) • Ablative in Shabo is –ti • -(y)E genitive • (Saharan, part of Eastern Sudanic, Kuliak) • Shabo has two strategies that could be related: -ke genitive or –e/i suffix • ŋ interrogative formative • (Berta, Eastern Sudanic, Central Sudanic, Maban) • There may be an n formative in Shabo

  13. PostpositionsandPrepositions(Nichols 1995, Croft 1996) Stable

  14. Object-Subject-VerbandObject-Verb-Subject(Croft 1996) Unstable

  15. 50

  16. Bender (1996) (Complex group) (Complex group)

  17. Shabo

  18. Nara Nubian Nyima Shabo Taman • Bender • Bayesian

  19. Taman and Shabo vs. E. Sud Similarities Differences Adj N Shabo, but N Adj for Taman Taman has a more complicated tonal system (rising/falling) • Neither has pronominal possessive suffixes • SOV • Gen Noun

  20. Nubian and Shabo vs. E. Sud Similarities Differences No velar nasal in Nubian Gender distinction in Shabo pronouns • No grammatical gender • No inclusive/exclusive • SOV • postpositions • Gen Noun • Case marking on all types of nouns

  21. Moreover • We have long records of the Nubians and they’ve been doing hoe agriculture and trade for a long time • The Tamans also have had hoe agriculture and animal husbandry (they are also fishers, historically) • Nothing obvious in the lexicon

  22. “Nothing obvious in the lexicon”? • Looking for similarities in word form/meaning • Venerable tradition • Fundamental practice

  23. Problems with eyeballing • False positives • English much • Spanish mucho • False negatives • Albanian vayzë • Armenian k’oyr • (from IE *swesor, ‘sister’)

  24. Quick fixes • Use basic vocabulary • Watch for natural sound changes • Look for common semantic shifts

  25. Central Sudanic

  26. Shabo

  27. Bender (2000)

  28. Lendu/Ngiti (mostly Ngiti) Similarities Differences No initial velars (at least in Ngiti) Inclusive/exclusive distinction in Ngiti No gender distinctions in Ngiti pronouns Syllable structure simpler for Ngiti, tones more complex No cases in Ngiti • Much of word order is the same: • Postpositions • Gen Noun same • Adj Noun • etc

More Related