1 / 33

SENIORS HOUSING PANEL

SENIORS HOUSING PANEL. Overview of Presentation. Industry overview and trends Types of Senior Facilities Valuation issues. Overview of Senior Facilities. Understanding of market and social objectives - costs vs services

chas
Télécharger la présentation

SENIORS HOUSING PANEL

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. SENIORS HOUSING PANEL

  2. Overview of Presentation • Industry overview and trends • Types of Senior Facilities • Valuation issues

  3. Overview of Senior Facilities • Understanding of market and social objectives - costs vs services • Understanding the interconnection of residential real estate, hospitality and health care industries • Legislative issues - depending on type of facility • How does demographics play a role • Economic factors impacting seniors

  4. Demand Factors

  5. How to Estimate Demand?

  6. Supply Factors • Barriers to Entry • Cost of Capital • location and diversifying risk • operational synergies that comes from management expertise

  7. How to Estimate Supply? • Competitive Analysis • Existing ownership and locations • Demographics and geographic targets • number, type, mix and size of units • rental rates and occupancy rates, waiting lists and turnover, resident profiles • Government subsidies

  8. Continuum of Care Independent Living Assisted Living Care Facility

  9. How does Aging in Place Affect Senior Housing? • Design of buildings • Appraisers will need to keep this concept in mind when appraising older facilities and assess their functionality • Services offered • Could impact demand and vacancy

  10. Types of Facilities Two Categories: • Independent Living • Facility Care

  11. Example of “Independent Living” facility

  12. Example of “Independent and Facility Care” facility

  13. Example of a small scale “Facility Care” facility

  14. Example of large scale “Facility Care” facility

  15. Valuation Issues • Premise of Value • Example of a Going Concern Definition: • “The value created by a proven property operation; considered as a separate entity to be valued with a specific business establishment”. • The Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal. Third Edition.

  16. Valuation Issues Continued • Extraordinary assumptions: • Licensing is in place to operate # of beds • Management of the operation is reasonable and competent • Comments on the FF&E

  17. Valuation Approaches • Cost Approach • Direct Comparison Approach • Income Approach

  18. Cost Approach • Can provide a supportive role • Investors do not place much weight on this approach unless new construction • May have validity among lenders, insurers, and assessors • More relevant for new facilities

  19. Cost Approach Advantages • Provides value estimates in the absence of other market evidence • Good tool to test financial feasibility on proposed projects • Good tool to test the economic benefits of a major upgrade/renovation

  20. Cost Approach Weaknesses • Depreciation estimating • No recognition of business value • Reflection of full fee simple ownership when property may be leased • May not account for absorption on new construction

  21. Direct Comparison Approach • Usually used to support income approach • Values are based on a per unit or per bed comparison • PCH may be based on per square foot • Comparisons should reflect whether the property is licensed or not • Properties vary significantly due to small number of transactions, and dissimilar properties

  22. Other issues with DCA • Varying components to these facilities - land, building, FF&E, business interests • Motivations of large players - value of individual property plus accretive value to overall portfolio • Variation in age, design, types of services, licensing, funding, staffing, location, size and suite mix. • Limited access to market information and the lack of an efficient market.

  23. Income Approach • Direct Capitalization • Discounted Cash Flow - more appropriate where an appraiser anticipates income fluctuations due to leasing or financing and/or where facility has not achieved full occupancy.

  24. Income • Examine market rates and existing rent schedule • Suite mix/size/design of unit • Licensed (care level) • Operating beds • Examine on a rate per bed, per square foot, per room or per month rate. • Examine government funded beds (if combo facility)

  25. Vacancy and Collection Loss Factors • Average age and care level of clients • Management • Proportion of funded beds vs private pay beds • Rental rates • Facility age, design, efficiency, and staffing attitudes/training • Food service • Social and activity programs

  26. Expenses

  27. Management • Three alternatives: • Direct management • Contract management • Partnership with service, care or amenity provider

  28. Wages and Benefits • Larges expense • Can be up to 75% • Non-union vs union facilities • Can include management

  29. Food and Medical • Include an allowance for dining room linen replacement and cleaning and tablecloth service • Calculate the # of meals and consider if single or double occupant • May also include an allowance for FF&E • Medical Costs

  30. Other Expenses • Pay attention if there has been a tax grant or exemption - may have to adjust sales when developing an OCR. • Bank charges - exclude mortgage interest; include operation charges • Do not include capital expenditures as part of R&M • Reserve Replacements • Other expenses - billed to client or the care facility?

  31. Capitalization Rates • Higher than multi-family or commercial properties • REITS and a more competitive market have drawn down cap rates more recently • One REIT makes acquisitions at 9% to 10% • Independent facilities range between 7.5% and 10% • Larger Facility Care facilities range between 8.5% and 11% • Some PCH in the Saskatoon region can range between 12-15%

  32. Risk Factors for OCR’s • Competitiveness • Demographic trends • Recession stability • Growth strategies of large players striving for market share • Government funding • Depth of market for non-funded units • Competent management and operational competency • Health care regulations

  33. CMHC Factors • CMHC may use a different cap rate than market derived cap rates • Usually higher (11% to 12%) • Due to their fiduciary responsibility to avoid mortgage loan default and foreclosure

More Related