1 / 8

Dealing with risks in modern institutions: the Hercules effort

Dealing with risks in modern institutions: the Hercules effort. John Grin University of Amsterdam Dept. Political Science Policy Sciences, esp. System Innovation j.g rin@uva.nl http://www.fmg.uva.nl/afdeling_pol http://www.fmg.uva.nl/perform. 1. Risk society.

hamish-walls
Télécharger la présentation

Dealing with risks in modern institutions: the Hercules effort

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Dealing with risks in modern institutions: the Hercules effort John Grin University of Amsterdam Dept. Political Science Policy Sciences, esp. System Innovation j.grin@uva.nl http://www.fmg.uva.nl/afdeling_pol http://www.fmg.uva.nl/perform First World Congress on Risk

  2. 1. Risk society • ‘Duality of structure’ (Giddens) • Institutions • Knowledge infrastructure • Governance system • Market • Have emerged from and are shaping dominant social processes • Risk society: • (potential) side effects of simple modernization can no longer be neglected • Risks cannot be adequately handled by current institutions First World Congress on Risk

  3. 2. Reflexive modernization • We are in need of a reflexive modernization, i.e. a coherent change in • Action • Structure (institutions) • Reflexive design: design for a strategy beyond existing institutions • But how to perform reflexive design within existing structures? First World Congress on Risk

  4. 3. Modernization of agriculture • 1890-1940: product -improvement; land saving • Since 1945: product improvement; intensive production; labour saving • Number of pigs remained growing; pig farmers: • 275,000 (1950) > 110,000 (1975) > 20,000 (1995) • Much longer, more differentiated economic chains consisting of many specialized players • Specialized knowledge infrastructure • OVO-tryad • Iron triangle First World Congress on Risk

  5. 4. The Hercules project • Started, as part of EET programme, in 1998, after Classical Swine Fever • Six firms, fundamental researchers, practice-oriented researchers • Core idea: • Convex manure belts, separating urine and faces so as to produce high quality fertilizer specialties through drying urine, using pig warmth + composting • Unlike traditional sewerage, Hercules could use much straw: animal welfare • Biomass composting + energy production • Integrated in P348 in 2000: stakeholder involvement First World Congress on Risk

  6. 5. How the manure belts went out • Manure belts: Originally promoted as a key asset • Later, concerns accumulated: • Market not used to integral housing systems • Post-war market: specialized chain actors • Culturally embedded; Investment patterns • Could it be solved? • Manure cheaper; no viable market introduction strategy • Plant and animal production had become separate worlds (both agricultural practice and knowledge generation) • Costs too high (€ 0,05) • Historically contingent assumptions • Specialized, long chains: primary producers have limited power; multiplicative effect of primary product costs • Infections?!? • Knowledge falling short for a quick fix First World Congress on Risk

  7. 6. Why it was so difficult to do better • As a EET programme, the project was very successful; the belts justifiably discarded • As an attempt at reflexive design, typical for the difficulties that may be encountered • Difficulties were discovered only late, since farmers were involved • only in P348 period • By practice oriented institutes First World Congress on Risk

  8. 7. Lessons that may be learned • It appeared difficult to define visions: • Short time horizons • Lack of commitment • Methodical lesson: • Connect to reverse salients, presumotive anomalies a.s.o. • Be very explicit about reflexive nature of envisaged changes • Lesson on governance: • Government needs to be: • Resolved to stop current problems and create future • Strategically coherent mix of openness, consistency First World Congress on Risk

More Related