1 / 10

Thanks for a Relevant Contribution !

Thanks for a Relevant Contribution !. Perception and functioning of scientific research and technological innovation (STI) in late modern society are precarious .

marciej
Télécharger la présentation

Thanks for a Relevant Contribution !

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Thanks for a Relevant Contribution ! • Perception and functioning of scientific research and technological innovation (STI) in late modern society are precarious. • Sandra Harding’s standpoint methodology and strong objectivity program can inspire the ongoing re-conceptualization of STI practice in society. • Highly relevant also for UT and her ambitions: • Technological and social engineering & co-design (rather than ‘pure’ science) • “High Tech Human Touch”: Setting standards in new technology and stimulating change, renewal and progress in society • “Technology for People” (BMS slogan) Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

  2. “Objectivity for Sciences from Below” (Harding) • Standpoint theory: actors’ own perspectives are shaped by their social and political experiences: standpoints are multifaceted rather than essentializing. • Strong objectivity: perspectives of marginalized/oppressed actors help to create more objective accounts (outsider-within). • Conceptualized in Marxian, feminist, post-colonial, and anti-racist contexts. Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

  3. Related Views in STS and CTA • Science and Technology Studies (STS) • Co-evolution of STI and society • Constructivist epistemology • Constructive Technology Assessment (CTA) • Inclusion of heterogeneous actors, also the marginalized • Anticipation and reflection • Intervention, experimental and flexible • Co-design Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

  4. Quest for Responsible Research & Innovation • European Commission’s H2020; Dutch NWO MVI; UT • RRI: “a transparent, interactive process in which societal actors and innovators become mutually responsive to each other with a view on the ethical acceptability, sustainability and societal desirability of the innovation process and its marketable products.” (von Schomberg 2011) • RRI: “anticipation, reflexivity, inclusion, responsiveness”(Stilgoe et al. 2013) But: Governance of STI has to face normative pluralism. • Polyvalent valuation; political contestation. Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

  5. Need for a Governance Frame for RRI • Res-AGorA (EU FP7, 2013-16) develops a governance framework for strategic reflection on RRI ambitions. • Most goals of RRI are not new, but already pursued through various governance instruments. • Overarching goals: • Institutional transformation towards responsibilisation • Enhancing legitimacy of RRI approaches and trust of actors involved Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

  6. Three KeyAreas of RRI Governance Quality of interactions Organisinggovernancemechanisms Developing supportive environments Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

  7. 1. Qualities of Interaction Broad inclusion (of diverse actors) Moderation (of discourse on ‘fora’) Deliberation (about various ‘knowledges’) Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

  8. 2. OrganisingGovernanceMechanisms Flexibility (of governance arrangements) Subsidiarity (of governance instruments) Resilience (vis-a-vis changing conditions) Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

  9. 3. SupportiveEnvironments Individuals, organisations (capability building) Networks, society (capacity building) Institutional entrepreneurship (towards transformation) Democratic standards (as underlying condition) Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

  10. Summing up • Shared perspectives, with different emphasis • Standpoint theory and strong objectivity approaches (S. Harding) • STS, in particular CTA • Institutionalization of governance towards RRI. • Post-modern polyvalent valuation and inevitable contestation require (meta-) governance frames for responsible STI • With principles and requirements inspired by the above approaches. • Inspiration for UT ambitions towards responsible co-design of STI with society. Stefan Kuhlmann | STePS | April 2015

More Related