1 / 14

PROJECT MANAGEMENT 專案管理 Session 3

PROJECT MANAGEMENT 專案管理 Session 3. OUTLINE: Logistics Arrangements Reporting Assignments & schedule Oral report FB form S2: Engineering Economic Analysis time value of money; formula & applications methods to compare alternatives (NPV, IRR, pay-off period, utility theory)

osman
Télécharger la présentation

PROJECT MANAGEMENT 專案管理 Session 3

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. PROJECT MANAGEMENT專案管理 Session 3 OUTLINE: • Logistics • Arrangements • Reporting Assignments & schedule • Oral report FB form • S2: Engineering Economic Analysis • time value of money; formula & applications • methods to compare alternatives (NPV, IRR, pay-off period, utility theory) • sensitivity & break-even analysis • S3: Project Screening and Selection • evaluation processes factors • Focus on tools & examples of those tools: • checklists & scoring models; multidimensional (snow flake) diagram; benefit-cost analysis; cost-effectiveness analysis; risk-benefit analysis; decision trees Sheu

  2. Time Value of Money • Why Economic Analysis? • desire for max. profitability in PM • limited resources • Time value of money • money now can do thing for future • inflation • Discount rate; interest rate; MARR • differences & interchangeability • Compound interest vs simple interest • principal & previous interests generate new interest • only principal generate interest.

  3. ... ... Compound Interest Rate Symbols • Symbols: • i: effective interest rate (discount rate, MARR) • n: # of compound periods • P: present sum of money • F: future sum of money • A: annuity. (periodic end-of-period cash flow) • G: uniform increase/decrease in end-of-period cash flow A G Sheu

  4. Compound Interest Rate Formula • Present sum -> future Single-payment compound amount factor (F/P, i%, n) • F = P * (F/P, i%, n) • future sum -> single-payment present worth (P/F, i%, n) • Uniform series -> future compound amount factor (A/F, i%, n) • Arithmetic gradient -> present worth factor (P/G, i%, n) ... • Formula see p. 49, 50. • Chain rule applies • Risk premium - discount rate.

  5. Comparing alternatives • Equivalent worth methods • Present worth method (NPV) • variations: Present worth - cost; Present worth - benefit; • Eg. 2-4. P 58/59. • Annual worth method • Equivalent uniform annual cost (EUAC) or annual cost (AC) • Capital recovery cost. • Eg. 2-5. P60/61. • Future worth method (eg. 2-6) • Eg. 2-7 (error corrections) • Internal rate-of-return method (IRR) • The interest rate for which NPV = 0. (Eg. 2-8) • Incremental comparison: Fg. 2-9 • Names: profitability index, investor’s method return, discounted cash flow return • Payback-period method (p. 71 & Eg 2-11)

  6. Comparisons of the methods • NPV / AW / FW • Will there be consistent results? • NPV vs IRR vs Payback

  7. Other Issues • Sensitivity analysis • How sensitive is the result w.r.t. a particular parameter? • How big & @ where the change in a parameter can lead to a different result. • Break-even analysis • To analyze where is the point (of a parameter) where two alternative are indifferent. • Where is the point the result start to change. • Tax and depreciation should be factored into the “final” cash flow.

  8. Utility Theory • What: • Utility (效用) reflects one’s value -> choice. • Pleasure/displeasure one would derive from certain outcome. • Utility function: U = fn (outcome) • Why: Money is not everything. • Other factors do affect choices. (Previous methods concern only w/ money) • People’s value may not be linear w/ money. • Utility is all-inclusive. • Caveat w/ utility: • hard to measure. (Not as concrete as money) • Bernoulli’s principle (Utility axioms) (p86)

  9. Utility Theory • One way to find utility function: (fg 2-11) • Modified NM (Neumann-Morgenstern) method. p U(x1) + (1-p) U (x3) = U (x2) p = 0.5 => 0.5 U(x1) + 0.5 U (x3) = U (x3) • Given 50% chance of x1 and 50% chance of x3, what is the “certainty equivalent” of the gamble ? (i.e. what is that x2 which is indifferent to you?) • (fg 2-11) • Example on using utility for decision (Eg: 2-14) • A1: Rev. + 478,300 ; cost: 60,000 success: 70% • A2: Rev. + 150,000+121,000 ; cost: 100,000 success: 50% • A3 (=A1 & A2): add cost: 107,000 (= 267,000) • 3 general types of utility functions (fg 2-12)

  10. Selection/screening Methods (Technical) • Checklists & scoring models • Checklist (S3: tbl 3-1); • Scoring model & weights (S3: tbl 3-2, tbl 3-3) • Multidimensional (snow flake) diagram (S3: fg 3-2) • Sensitivity analysis. (applicable to all methods) • Benefit-cost analysis • MARR; PW/AW/FW/ IRR • Conventional B/C & Modified B/C; add TVM (S3: eg. 3-2 ~ 3-4) • Classes of benefits & costs: • Primary; (Secondary; External); Intangible • Shortcomings: (problems of scale <B/C & B-C>, non-quantifiables; judge & jury) Sheu

  11. Cost-effectiveness analysis • Why include effectiveness ? • Focus on performance not on “money terms” (as in B/C analysis) • What is effectiveness ? • measure of degree in achieving system requirements • capability (performance) / availability / dependability ... • weighting issues. (not weighing issue) • Single measure performance vs multiple measure • Efficient frontier (S3: fg 3-4) Sheu

  12. Risk-benefit analysis • Definitions related to Risk. (S3: tbl 3-6) • FMEA (Failure Mode, Effects and Analysis) (next pg) • Event tree analysis; Fault tree analysis • Risk-benefit analysis: • generic term: incl. eva of risks, costs, & benefits of alternative projects • system engineering approach (S3: fg 3-5) • Risk Profile (S3: fg 3-6) Sheu

  13. 1. Failure Mode -- What is the potential failure mode? (production issues, design trade-offs, etc.) 2. Failure Effect -- What effects will this failure have on the customer? 3. Criticality -- How severe is the effect of this failure mode on production or the customer? (1 - 5 scale) 4 . Probability of Occurrence -- How often will this failure mode occur? (1 - 5 scale) 5. Detection Capability -- How likely are we to detect this failure mode? (1 - 5 scale) 6. Risk Priority Number -- Order of test or analysis priority ? (criticality x frequency x detection) 7. Action Required -- What approach will we use to evaluate and resolve the Potential Failure Mode? FMEA Generalized Form Potential Risk Probability Failure Detection Critical- Action Priority Failure of Required ity Capability Effect Occurrence Number Mode 3 x 4 3 5 1 2 4 7 x = 5 6 (H-L) Sheu

  14. Decision Trees • Decision trees / Decision Flow Networks /Decision Diagrams • Decision Nodes / Chance Nodes / EMV(Expected Monetary Value) (fig 3-7) • Sub-optimal /Rollback step • Eg. 3-5 (fig 3-9): (deterministic) decision tree • Eg. 3-6 (tbl 3-8) (add TVM) • Eg. 3-7 (fig 3-11 & tbl 3-9) < impact of tech. study & probability) • Sec 3.7.3: • Add Bayesian Statistics (fig 3-12, 3-13) (tbl 3-10, 11, 12) • comp fgs 3-11 & 13: Later, you calculate prob., P(Si/X), based on tech study results instead of “guessing”. Sheu

More Related