1 / 56

Qualitative Methods

Qualitative Methods. Chapter Topics. The nature of qualitative methods The qualitative research process The range of qualitative methods In-depth interviews Participant observation Analysis of texts Ethnography Biographical methods Grounded theory and qualitative research

ronny
Télécharger la présentation

Qualitative Methods

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Qualitative Methods

  2. Chapter Topics • The nature of qualitative methods • The qualitative research process • The range of qualitative methods • In-depth interviews • Participant observation • Analysis of texts • Ethnography • Biographical methods • Grounded theory and qualitative research • Management contexts for the use of qualitative methods

  3. The nature of qualitative methods • Use of qualitative rather than quantitative information: • a large amount of ‘rich’ information about a small number of subjects • Assumes that reality is socially and subjectively constructed • Researcher’s task is to uncover meanings rather than test pre-established hypotheses: usually inductive rather than deductive • Assumes people are best able to describe their own situation, beliefs, motivations etc.

  4. Some advantages of qualitative methods • Understanding/explaining personal experiences of individuals • Focus on subjects' own understanding and interpretations • Researcher experiences issues from a participant's perspective • Reports presented in a narrative rather than a statistical form – more interesting/understandable for non-experts • Useful in examining personal changes over time • Focus on human-interest issues that are meaningful to managers

  5. The qualitative research process

  6. Common qualitative methods • In-depth interviews • Small number of subjects • Checklist rather than a formal questionnaire • Tape-recording + verbatim transcript • 30 minutes to several hours; repeat interviews possible. • Group interviews/focus groups • Conducted with a group • Interaction between subjects + interaction between interviewer and subject. • Participant observation • Researcher is actual participant along with subjects • Researcher known as researcher, or incognito.

  7. In-depth interviews • Nature • Lengthy, probing interview • Encourages subject to talk • Often tape-recorded + verbatim transcript • Often uses checklist rather than questionnaire – see Fig. 7.2

  8. Checklist

  9. In-depth interviews: purpose For research where: • Number of subjects is small - quantitative research not appropriate; • Information from subjects expected to vary considerably; or • Exploratory/preliminary stage in planning a larger study, possibly quantitative.

  10. Interviewing • Whyte’s hierarchy of interviewer responses: • 'Uh-huh‘ • 'That's interesting‘ • Reflection - Repeating the last statement as a question • Probe - Inviting explanations of statements • Back tracking • New topic

  11. Focus groups/group interviews • Nature • Interviewer becomes a ‘facilitator’ of the discussion • Group members interact with each other as well as the facilitator

  12. Focus groups - Purposes • Used when: • an important group may be too small to be picked up in a sample survey • The interaction/discussion process among group members is of interest • Alternative to in-depth interview when multiple interviews not practicable

  13. Focus groups - methods • Group size: 5-12 members • Discussion typically tape-recorded • Written summary prepared from the tape • Facilitator role similar to interviewer in in-depth interview • Facilitator: • leads discussion through the range of topics of interest • ensures that all members ‘have their say’ – avoid domination by one or more group members

  14. Participant observation • Nature • Researcher participates in the social process being studied – eg. as employee • Purpose • To study situations where complex/detailed information required from a group: • Group dynamics • Inter-personal relationships/dealings

  15. Participant observation - methods • Gaining access to the group: • Known as a ‘researcher’ or • Incognito? (ethical issues) • Problem of selection of suitable informants in the research environment • Practicalities of taking notes

  16. Grounded theory • The idea that theory arises from examination of the data, rather than data being collected to test a pre-existing theory • Typically inductive approach • May involve any or all the methods discussed above

  17. Management contexts for qualitative research • Corporate culture – exploring the way groups or networks of individuals operate in the working environment • Consumer decision-making – exploring how customers actually interact with suppliers and products and services

  18. Summary • Qualitative research deals with non-numerical data - the collection of a large amount of ‘rich’ information concerning relatively few subjects. • Assumption: reality is socially and subjectively constructed rather than objectively determined. • Researchers and subjects seen as part of the research process seeking to uncover meanings and understandings of the issues • Involves a more fluid - recursive - relationship between the various elements of the research • Example qualitative methods includes: • in-depth interviews • focus groups • participant observation

  19. Qualitative Analysis

  20. Chapter Topics • This chapter builds on Ch. 7: Qualitative Methods • Methods will be demonstrated using interview transcripts • Data storage and confidentiality • Manual methods • Qualitative analysis using computer software - introduction • NVivo

  21. Data storage and confidentiality • Because qualitative data may include personal opinions and details: • Security of data storage is important • Ideally, pseudonyms/codes should be used even with stored data/transcripts etc. • Efforts should be made to protect confidentiality/ anonymity of informants when reporting results

  22. Manual methods • Topics • Introduction • Reading • Emergent themes • Mechanics • Analysis

  23. Introduction • Recall the idea of the ‘recursive’ approach – See Fig. 7.1 • The ‘circular model of the research process’ (Fig. 2.1) becomes more complex – see Fig. 15.1

  24. Recursive approach – Fig. 7.1

  25. Circular model – adapted – Fig. 15.1

  26. Reading + Emergent themes • Reading • The key activity in qualitative data analysis is reading and re-reading the material • Reading begins with initial research questions/models etc. in mind – but evolves • Emergent themes • Ideas/concepts which emerge are referred to as ‘emergent themes’ • For one scenario, see: • Fig. 15.2 – Initial outline conceptual framework • Fig. 15.3 – Annotated interview transcripts • Fig. 15.4 – Further developed conceptual framework

  27. Outline/Initial/Simple conceptual framework

  28. Interview transcript extract – annotated – Fig. 15.3 (p. 296)

  29. Partially developed conceptual framework – Fig. 15.4

  30. Mechanics • Annotate transcripts with ‘themes’ – as in Fig. 15.3 • Need to leave wide margins or use ‘columns’ • Colour coding may be helpful • Word-processor may be used to: • Add comments/block text in colour, underline or bold • Search for words/phrases • Code and cross-reference using indexing • Numbering paragraphs may be useful for cataloguing • Eg. Career attitude-strategic Mark: p. 2, para. 3; p. 7, para 4 Jennie: p. 7, para. 1

  31. Analysis • ‘Crosstabulation’ to identify groups – see Fig. 15.5

  32. ‘Crosstabulation’ of qualitative data – Fig. 15.5

  33. Using Computer Software • Computer-aided Qualitative Data Analysis Software (CAQDAS) packages now available • Package demonstrated here: • NVivo by QRS (Qualitative Solutions and Research Ltd)

  34. NVivo • Topics • Introduction • Running NVivo software • Starting up • Creating a Project • Creating documents • Document attributes • Coding documents • Analysis

  35. Starting up • Click on the NVivo icon - opens the Nvivo 'Launch Pad' - see Figure 15.6.

  36. NVivo Launch Pad

  37. Creating a ‘Project’ • Click on Create a Project to reveal New Project Wizard, add: • Name: ‘Careers’ • Description: ‘Careers and Training Project’ •  Switch to NVivo • NVivo Project Pad appears – see Fig. 15.6

  38. NVivo Project Pad – Fig. 15.7

  39. Creating documents • Documents must be saved in Rich Text Format (.rtf) • Example interview transcripts: save as: • Int_Mark.rtf • Int_Anna.rtf • Int_Ben.rtf • Load into NVivo by: • Click on Create a Document • In New Document Wizard: Creation select Locate and import readable external files •  Switch to NVivo – procedures pp. 302-303 • When all 3 files have been loaded, Explore Documents will reveal list as in Fig. 15.8

  40. NVivo Document Explorer

  41. Document attributes • Similar to ‘variables’ in quantitative analysis • In Project Pad, select Documents and Edit Document Attributes •  Switch to NVivo – procedures pp. 303-304 to produce Figure 15.9

  42. NVivo Document Attributes

  43. Coding documents – set-up • Fig. 15.4 provides the basis for a coding system • Coding system must be set up in NVivo before documents can be coded • Connected systems of concepts as in Fig. 15.4 = Tree Nodes • Free-floating concepts not linked with others = Free Nodes • In Project Pad, select Nodes, then Create a Node, then Tree tab – to produce Fig. 15.10 •  Switch to NVivo – procedures p. 305 to produce Figure 15.11

  44. Fig. 15.10NVivo Create a Node dialog box

  45. NVivo Nodes Created – Fig. 15.11

  46. Coding documents - coding •  Switch to NVivo – procedures p. 306 to produce Figure 15.12

  47. NVivo – coded text

  48. Analysis • Processes covered here: • Searching • Searching and coding • Search Results • Selective searching • Models – conceptual frameworks

  49. SEARCHING • Searching for occurrences of specified Nodes •  Switch to NVivo – procedures pp. 307-308 to produce Figures 15.13 & 15.14

  50. Fig. 15.13NVivo Search Tool dialog box

More Related