1 / 12

Responding to the counter-argument

Responding to the counter-argument. And other writing tips…. What is it?. Any position that contradicts your opinions (assertions/arguments) that you are presenting in essay. Why include C-A?. Effectively addressing counter-argument can bolster your case

tymon
Télécharger la présentation

Responding to the counter-argument

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Responding to the counter-argument And other writing tips…

  2. What is it? • Any position that contradicts your opinions (assertions/arguments) that you are presenting in essay

  3. Why include C-A? • Effectively addressing counter-argument can bolster your case • Don’t underestimate the intelligence of your readers • If you do not address their objections, the reader is not fully convinced • Can sharpen and clarify your point. • Alerts reader to potential confusion

  4. More reasons… • Enhances your credibility • Fair critic who can see both sides of the issue but advocates for the best position • More ways to argue • Your paper focuses on why your reasons are best; counter-argument allows possibility to explore negative reasons

  5. Tips • Deal with one counter-argument rather than a lot quickly (and superficially) • C-A gets own paragraph • Don’t attack harshly. Be fair in and explain fully the alternative ideas

  6. Last tip w/example • Pay attention to transitions • You are “shifting gears”. When introducing C-A, be explicit that this is the C-A. • Why might some disagree? • “I have just discussed awesome reasons suggesting XYZ. Some might point to ABC and believe EFG. HOWEVER, this interpretation is based on a mistaken reading…” Then explain! 

  7. Thesis Reminders • Requirements of a good thesis: • Must be authoritative (have a provable point, argumentative edge, or persuasive viewpoint) • Promotes the writer's attitude toward the subject • Uses specific, concrete language (this avoids 'wimpyness') • *Answers the HOW or WHY you intend to prove your argument • DEBRAS! (and T)

  8. Examples • Example of a poor thesis: • Cheating in high school is widespread, but doesn't work very well. • Example of a better thesis: • Students who cheat show no real gain in grade averages; therefore, this result should be voiced right along with the moral argument not to cheat. • Super hint: If unsure how to give a thesis an edge, try using since, although, or despite to start the thesis sentence.

  9. Brainstorming a Thesis Worksheet • Write the assigned subject area here: ___________________________________________ • Brainstorm several different viewpoints/areas about the subject: • 1. ___________________________________________________________________________ • 2. ___________________________________________________________________________ • 3. ___________________________________________________________________________ • 4. ___________________________________________________________________________

  10. Worksheet… • Choose the viewpoint/area you want to promote and write about. Remember a thesis is your opinion and understanding based on facts about a topic. It must be proven to be valid. Use the space below to write the facts or proof that supports your viewpoint. • _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ • Now, choose the two strongest points that you can elaborate on and incorporate those points into a statement. This is the working thesis. • _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

  11. Remember… • Avoid vague words (stuff, it, things) • Avoid 1st and second person (I, me, you, us, we) • Elaborations=why is that significant to proving your thesis. Develop thoroughly! (Answers the “so what” question a reader can say to your argument) 

More Related