1 / 12

How international migration redefined citizenship: Human rights & human trafficking in perspective

How international migration redefined citizenship: Human rights & human trafficking in perspective. Prof. A.B. Shamsul Deputy Chair The National Council of Professors Malaysia Presentation at UNESCO Paris, 5-6 May 2011. Of theories and tools.

violet
Télécharger la présentation

How international migration redefined citizenship: Human rights & human trafficking in perspective

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. How international migration redefined citizenship: Human rights & human trafficking in perspective Prof. A.B. Shamsul Deputy Chair The National Council of Professors Malaysia Presentation at UNESCO Paris, 5-6 May 2011

  2. Of theories and tools • Theorization on international migration is empirically rooted in empirical experience of North America and Europe • It is based on the assumption that ‘legal citizenship’ in North America & Europe is transparent & certain, well-documented & recorded • Prosecution, Protection & Prevention are conducted in relatively simple manner, in both regions

  3. Complex & Uncertain • In countries in Asia & Africa, “legal citizenship”- is far more complex & uncertain than commonly recognized, • It poses major challenges for how political governance, economic welfare, and national security should be pursued, domestically & internationally • Therefore, international migration from developing & under-developed countries to developing ones, needs new theories, concepts & analytical tools to make sense what it is and in formulating appropriate policies and actions to seek solutions

  4. Conflict & Confusion • Unthinking adoption of analytical categories that dominate explanation & research on international migration in the West has resulted in conflict & confusion, in the form of: • Public policies dilemmas • Continuous gripping stories of human tragedies • Conceptual confusion

  5. The Asian experience as a mirror • When one moves the lens to Asia, we begin to understand the need for a far broader range of categories. • Even more surprising is that the Asia’s experience illuminates features of the West that have not been recognized sufficiently by the West itself

  6. Fake papers, real citizens • The subterranean processes by which millions have acquired citizenship. • States don’t have comprehensive territorial sovereignty • Collusion of weak & erratic bureaucracies and the organized syndicates/crimes • how illegal immigrants acquire false papers & the consequences on global security & expansion international black economy

  7. Documentary citizenship • Most world's illegal immigrants not migrating directly to the West, but to countries in the vast developing world. • When they arrive in countries like Pakistan, India and Malaysia--which are often governed by weak and erratic bureaucracies--they are able to obtain citizenship papers fairly easily. • Creation of "documentary citizenship" : how paperwork--often falsely obtained--confers citizenship on illegal immigrants.

  8. Documentary citizenship prospers • Once immigrants obtain documents, it is a relatively simple matter for, say, an Indian or Bangladeshi with Malaysian papers to pass himself off as an Indian-Malaysian citizens, both in Malaysia and abroad. • Across the globe, there are literally tens of millions of such illegal immigrants who have assumed the guise of "citizens“ based on fake documents

  9. What happens to human rights & human trafficking? • “Documentary citizenship” becomes the legal canopy within which illegal human trafficking occurred in developing countries • by implication, their human rights are being violated, too, at the same time. • because respecting human rights for the legal citizens is not on the top agenda in these countries anyway, illegal migrants without documents are suffers the most

  10. Whereto from here? • The old framework of Prosecution, Protection & Prevention, relating to human rights & human trafficking, based on Western migration analytical tools, policy guide, & experienced has clearly shown to be not working • Figuring out what may work? • How to start?

  11. Never too late… • The need to launch a new set of research on international migration and the formation of ‘documentary citizenship’ in developed, developing and developed countries • The challenge for the researchers (i) to measure the unmeasurable & (ii) to make the invisible world more visible

  12. Re-booting • Sociology, political science & economics are the traditional disciplinary tools in international migration studies • The importance of anthropology & its inclusion to make the invisible visible, to provide ethnographies on the unmeasurable • Important reference: Kamal Sadiq, Paper Citizens (OUP, 2008)

More Related