Lokesh Agarwal
CABLE TV BUSINESS
Lokesh Agarwal
E N D
Presentation Transcript
Who we are Cable TV Distribution Company MSO - Multi System Operator MRMPL (Multi Reach Media Private Limited)
Services CABLE TV SERVICES THROUGH SET TOP BOX (STB)
Block Chain MSO BROADCASTER MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR LCO LOCAL CABLE OPERATOR END CUSTOMERS
REGULATORY BODIES TRAI TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL
TRANSCATION MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR TRAI MRMPL SIGNED JOINT VENTURE AGREEMENT THRU "MOU" (Memorandum of Understanding) on dated 14.10.2016 With 3 PERSONS FOR DISTRIBUTION OF CABLE TV SIGNALS AT KANTHI - EAST MIDNAPORE TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA TDSAT TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL END CUSTOMERS
TRANSCATION MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR MRMPL & 3 LOCAL PARTNERS CREATED FORMERLY LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. (LLP) in 2018 JOINT VENTURE COMPANY NAMELY "KANTHI CABLE LLP" WITH PROFIT SHARE OF 51:49 on dated 14.10.2016 TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL END CUSTOMERS
TRANSCATION MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL END CUSTOMERS
DISPUTE Arosed in Sep' 2022 (After 6.5 YRS of Business) THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR THE LOCAL PARTNER'S STARTED MIGRATING BUSINESS TO COMPETITION (GTPL/KCBP) and within a span of 15 days migrated approx 9000 SET TOP Boxes END CUSTOMERS
SERIES OF EVENTS MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR MRMPL APPROACHED Honb'le TDSAT New Delhi for Justice and obtained Stay Order on 14.10.2022 TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS END CUSTOMERS
SERIES OF EVENTS MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR JV PARTERS OF KANTHI AS A OUTBURST FILED CRIMINAL CASE GR No. 2651 of 2022 against MRMPL at KANTHI PS (with Stringent Section such as (406,420,409,120B, 467,477,403,471 etc) on 06.12.2022 SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN END CUSTOMERS
ALLEGATION RAISED ON MRMPL MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR 1. SET TOP BOXES WERE SOLD TO OPERATORS, WHEREAS MRMPL HAS TREATED THE SAME AS SECURITY DEPOSIT in BOOKS. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. 2. EVASION OF GST SINCE SET TOP BOXES WERE NOT SOLD. 3. SET TOP BOX SINCE WERE SOLD, SHOULD BE PROPERTY OF LLP COMPANY AND NOT MRMPL END CUSTOMERS
SERIES OF EVENTS MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR MRMPL approached Hon'ble High Court - Kolkata with CRR no. 261 of 2023 Application for Quashing on 24.01.2023. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. "The Court directed the investigation agency to carry out the investigation of the case and also asked to issue Section 41A notice of CRPC. Also directed if custody required to pray before the court". Next Date " 03.03.2023" END CUSTOMERS
SERIES OF EVENTS MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR KANTHI Police issued Section 41 A notice to MRMPL and others. THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL MRMPL submitted all replies and submitted all documents. END CUSTOMERS
REPLY FOR ALLEGATIONS MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR SET TOP BOXES were PURCHASED by MRMPL only and issued to Local Cable Operators (LCO's) against Security Deposit receipt as per TRAI regulation 2013 and 2017. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. The SET TOP Boxes were issued against security deposit only, the same is reflected in audited book of MRMPL year on year. The Money received by the Operators / LCO's were directly deposited in the bank account of MRMPL and JV Partners have not invested single penny while purchasing the STB's The JV Partners been entrusted 52000 STB's on there representations & warranties vide LLP Supplementary Agreement dated 10.09.2020 clause no. X page no. 11 END CUSTOMERS
REPLY FOR ALLEGATIONS MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR SET TOP BOXES were PURCHASED by MRMPL only and issued to Local Cable Operators (LCO's) against Security Deposit with GST payment and year on year GST returns have been filed and yearly returns also have been filed from 2016 to 2022. SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED END CUSTOMERS
FACTS OF THE CASE MSO MULTI SYSTEM OPERATOR All LLP Agreements , Memorandum of Agreement (MOU) have clauses of Arbitration under Aribitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP CO. TERMS WERE AGAIN CHANGED SUPPLEMENTARY LLP AGREEMENT in 2020 PROFIT SHARE CHANGED FROM 51:49 to FIXED PER POINT BASIS DUE TO DROP IN SUBCRIBERS/BUSINESS TDSAT TELCOM DISPUTE APPELAT TRIBUNAL The JV Partner Mr. Subhashish Mahapatra, while filing reply petition in Honb'le TDSAT through an affadavit that the case does not lie within the jurisdiction of TDSAT as Arbitration Clause , whereas he has only filed a criminal case against MRMPL. END CUSTOMERS