1 / 22

USJFCOM JWFC

USJFCOM JWFC. Training Effectiveness Assessments and Feedback. Operations Group Plans Branch. UNCLASSIFIED. USJFCOM JWFC. Feed Back Analysis Trends. UNCLASSIFIED. Percentage of Questions by Category. 37 %. 56 %. 7 %. USJFCOM JWFC. Categories.

aloysius
Télécharger la présentation

USJFCOM JWFC

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. USJFCOM JWFC Training Effectiveness Assessments and Feedback Operations Group Plans Branch UNCLASSIFIED

  2. USJFCOM JWFC Feed Back Analysis Trends UNCLASSIFIED

  3. Percentage of Questions by Category 37 % 56 % 7 % USJFCOM JWFC Categories • Joint Exercise Development, Planning and Control Support • Joint Training and AAR Support • M&S and Communications Support UNCLASSIFIED 4

  4. USJFCOM JWFC Respondent Pool [1] CJTF HOA MRX 09-1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (AFRICOM) [2] Austere Challenge 09 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (EUCOM) [3] Turbo-Challenge / Ultimate Caduceus 09 . . . . . . . . . . . (TRANSCOM) [4] Judicious Response 09 (StaffEx) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (AFRICOM) [5] Terminal Fury 09 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (PACOM) [6] Ardent Sentry 09 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (NORTHCOM) [7] Global Thunder 09 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (STRATCOM) [8] Judicious Response 09 (CPX) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (AFRICOM) [9] Regional Cooperation 09 (PfP MAB) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (CENTCOM) [10] FA Panamax 09 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (SOUTHCOM) [11] Global Lightening 10 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (STRATCOM) [12] Vigilant Shield 10 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (NORTHCOM) Key: = Geographical COCOM =Functional COCOM UNCLASSIFIED

  5. Key: 5 (Outstanding) 4 (Excellent) 3 (Average) 1-2 (Below Average / Unsatisfactory) 0 (N/A or Text Response) USJFCOM JWFC Detailed Ratings By Category Joint Exercise Development, Planning and Control Support 4.007 Excellent [1] CJTF HOA MRX 09-1 (AFRICOM) 3.668 [2] Austere Challenge 09 (EUCOM) 4.055 [3] Turbo-Challenge / Ultimate Caduceus 09 (TRANSCOM) 4.125 [4] Judicious Response 09 (StaffEx) (AFRICOM) 4.647 [5] Terminal Fury 09 (PACOM) 2.952 [6] Ardent Sentry 09 (NORTHCOM) 4.238 [7] Global Thunder 09 (STRATCOM) 3.700 [8] Judicious Response 09 (CPX) (AFRICOM) 4.488 [9] Regional Cooperation 09 (PfP MAB) (CENTCOM) 3.937 [10] FA Panamax 09 (SOUTHCOM) 4.530 [11] Global Lightening 10 (STRATCOM) 4.333 [12] Vigilant Shield 10 (NORTHCOM) 3.416 UNCLASSIFIED 6

  6. 2 2 2 2 2 Key: 5 (Outstanding) 4 (Excellent) 3 (Average) 1-2 (Below Average / Unsatisfactory) 0 (N/A or Text Response) USJFCOM JWFC Joint Exercise Development, Planning and Control Support Trend:Questions Receiving Multiple1 or 2 Ratings Question # Exercise & COCOM Rating # 6. Did the Control Group’s distributed learning program prepare the role players for their participation? Austere Challenge 09 (EUCOM) Terminal Fury 09 (PACOM) 2 Terminal Fury 09 (PACOM) Global Thunder 09(STRATCOM) #13. Was there an Intelligence Plan of Action supported with associated products and training? Austere Challenge 09 (EUCOM) Terminal Fury 09 (PACOM) #17. Was there a STO Plan of Action in support of the exercise? Did it integrate capabilities and support STO objectives? UNCLASSIFIED 7

  7. USJFCOM JWFC Joint Exercise Development, Planning and Control Support Trend:Number of 1 or 2 Ratings by Exercise CJTF HOA MRX 09-1 (AFRICOM) 1 Judicious Response 09 (StaffEx) (AFRICOM) 0 Judicious Response 09 (CPX) (AFRICOM) 0 Regional Cooperation 09 (PfP MAB) (CENTCOM) 0 Austere Challenge 09 (EUCOM) 3 Ardent Sentry 09 (NORTHCOM) 0 Vigilant Shield 10 (NORTHCOM) 0 Terminal Fury 09 (PACOM) 5 FA Panamax 09 (SOUTHCOM)0 Global Thunder 09 (STRATCOM) 1 Global Lightening 10 (STRATCOM)0 Turbo-Challenge / Ultimate Caduceus 09 (TRANSCOM)0 UNCLASSIFIED 8

  8. USJFCOM JWFC Weighted Ratings By Category • Joint Exercise Development, Planning and Control Support 4.007 Excellent • Joint Training and AAR Support Excellent 4.498 • M&S and Communications Support Key: 5 (Outstanding) 4 (Excellent) 3 (Average) 1-2 (Below Average / Unsatisfactory) 0 (N/A or Text Response) UNCLASSIFIED 9

  9. Key: 5 (Outstanding) 4 (Excellent) 3 (Average) 1-2 (Below Average / Unsatisfactory) 0 (N/A or Text Response) USJFCOM JWFC Detailed Ratings By Categories 4.498 Excellent Joint Training and AAR Support [1] CJTF HOA MRX 09-1 (AFRICOM) 4.000 [2] Austere Challenge 09 (EUCOM) 4.666 [3] Turbo-Challenge / Ultimate Caduceus 09 (TRANSCOM) 5.000 [4] Judicious Response 09 (StaffEx) (AFRICOM) 4.500 [5] Terminal Fury 09 (PACOM) 4.666 [6] Ardent Sentry 09 (NORTHCOM) 4.666 [7] Global Thunder 09 (STRATCOM) 4.000 [8] Judicious Response 09 (CPX) (AFRICOM) 4.488 [9] Regional Cooperation 09 (PfP MAB) (CENTCOM) 4.000 [10] FA Panamax 09 (SOUTHCOM) 5.000 [11] Global Lightening 10 (STRATCOM) N/A [12] Vigilant Shield 10 (NORTHCOM) 4.500 UNCLASSIFIED 10

  10. USJFCOM JWFC Weighted Ratings By Category • Joint Exercise Development, Planning and Control Support 4.007 Excellent • Joint Training and AAR Support Excellent 4.498 • M&S and Communications Support Excellent 4.143 Key: 5 (Outstanding) 4 (Excellent) 3 (Average) 1-2 (Below Average / Unsatisfactory) 0 (N/A or Text Response) UNCLASSIFIED 11

  11. Key: 5 (Outstanding) 4 (Excellent) 3 (Average) 1-2 (Below Average / Unsatisfactory) 0 (N/A or Text Response) USJFCOM JWFC Detailed Ratings By Categories 4.143 Excellent M&S and Communications Support [1] CJTF HOA MRX 09-1 (AFRICOM) 3.928 [2] Austere Challenge 09 (EUCOM) 4.153 [3] Turbo-Challenge / Ultimate Caduceus 09 (TRANSCOM) 4.200 [4] Judicious Response 09 (StaffEx) (AFRICOM) 4.900 [5] Terminal Fury 09 (PACOM) 3.076 [6] Ardent Sentry 09 (NORTHCOM) 4.250 [7] Global Thunder 09 (STRATCOM) 4.100 [8] Judicious Response 09 (CPX) (AFRICOM) 4.515 [9] Regional Cooperation 09 (PfP MAB) (CENTCOM) 3.888 [10] FA Panamax 09 (SOUTHCOM) 5.000 [11] Global Lightening 10 (STRATCOM) 4.307 [12] Vigilant Shield 10 (NORTHCOM) 3.400 UNCLASSIFIED 12

  12. USJFCOM JWFC Weighted Ratings Summary By Categories • Joint Exercise Development, Planning and Control Support 4.007 Excellent Excellent 4.498 • Joint Training and AAR Support Excellent • M&S and Communications Support 4.143 Key: 5 (Outstanding) 4 (Excellent) 3 (Average) 1-2 (Below Average / Unsatisfactory) 0 (N/A or Text Response) UNCLASSIFIED 15

  13. Tailoring Future Questions to reduced 12 (28%) non response USJFCOM JWFC Non-Response To Survey Questions Trend:Incomplete Responses*Out of 43 Questions* CJTF HOA MRX 09-1 (AFRICOM) 13 (Avg.) Judicious Response 09 (StaffEx) (AFRICOM) 13 (Avg.) Judicious Response 09 (CPX) (AFRICOM) 9(Avg.) Regional Cooperation 09 (PfP MAB) (CENTCOM) 15 Austere Challenge 09 (EUCOM) 8 Ardent Sentry 09 (NORTHCOM) 11 Vigilant Shield 10 (NORTHCOM) 24 Terminal Fury 09 (PACOM) 6 FA Panamax 09 (SOUTHCOM)13 Global Thunder 09 (STRATCOM) 10 Global Lightening 10 (STRATCOM)8 Turbo-Challenge / Ultimate Caduceus 09 (TRANSCOM)9 *Excludes questions #27, #44 - 45, and #47 UNCLASSIFIED 16

  14. Training Capability/Resource Usage Results Based on FY 09-10 Baseline High Use/Optimized • JELC Event Conducted within Expectation (4.3) • WNN and Media Support Optimized (4.68) • JWFC Support for preparation of briefs, agenda, messages, etc (4.43) • Overall Satisfaction with JWFC Support (4.31) Under Used /Sub-optimized • Under Used - JECG Distributed Learning Program In Preparing Role Players • Intelligence Plan of Actions, Products and Training Sub-optimized (2.56) • Under Used - Design, Develop and Maintain Atypical Website to Support IO Training • Under Used - Special Technical Operations Support for Exercises • Portrayal of Training Environment on the COP Sub-optimized (3.25) • Under Used - Joint Force Trainer Tool Kit (JFIT) • Low Usages - Model and Sims Across FY 09 Joint Events • Function of COP During Joint Events Sub-optimized (3.5)

  15. Back-up Slides

  16. USJFCOM JWFC Historical Trends for Events / Exercises UNCLASSIFIED 19

  17. USJFCOM JWFC Historical Trends for Events / Exercises • COP Failures • A failure to plan ahead and conduct a Risk Assessment • Joint Knowledge Online (Pre-Ex) • JECG • Control Group • Classified • Comms / Mini-Ex (Pre-Ex) • Never happens or late in starting • Special Technical Operations (STO) Plan (Pre-Ex) • Integration issues • JMSEL Tool Training • JRU UNCLASSIFIED 20

  18. USJFCOM JWFC Historical Trends for Events / Exercises • DTT Feedback / Best Practice Sharing -- via JTIMS • Inconsistency by COCOMs; some want comments put in JTIMS and others do not • Some O/Ts hold their comments until preparation for the FAAR, when they could be sharing best practice corrections during the event / exercise • Scenario Changes or Incomplete • Objectives were not clear from the beginning • 24 / 7 Operations • Night Operations Battle Rhythm slows to a crawl. Is the level of manpower support worthwhile to have a night shift, if a sustained Battle Rhythm is supported? • Training Objectives • Training Objective Workshopsare now the command’s responsibility. They are not well thought-out or clearly established. UNCLASSIFIED 21

  19. USJFCOM JWFC Integrated AAR Trends UNCLASSIFIED 22

  20. USJFCOM JWFC Integrated AAR Trends • Planning • Inconsistency by COCOMs: the same people are not present throughout the JELC • Training objectives are briefed to commanders late during an event’s life cycle (JELC) • Insufficient time for event tests • Either not conducted or insufficient time spent on tests • Changes in Planners and Training Audience • Personnel changes from CDC through to Execution • SME – integration / education (Pre-Ex) • Interagency reps need better pre-event / exercise academic training • Trouble putting pieces together / analyzing • Challenges in analyzing what is strategically / tactically developing in the AOR UNCLASSIFIED 23

  21. USJFCOM JWFC Emerging AAR Assessment Results UNCLASSIFIED 24

  22. USJFCOM JWFC Emerging AAR Assessment Results • Follow the JELC process - each piece has a definite purpose. • Use Integrated AAR (IAAR) to fix responsibility and then follow through to resolve issues. • Re-focus event scheduling to prevent "watered down site surveys." UNCLASSIFIED 25

More Related