80 likes | 97 Vues
This paper explores using XML Schema to define content exchanged between NETCONF client and server, emphasizing modularity and data modeling considerations. The approach enables abundant tool usage and immediate implementation.
E N D
Using XML Schema to define NETCONF Content Sharon Chisholm schishol@nortel.com December 2007 IETF 70
Background • Draft created to capture offline discussions about requirements and potential solutions for how to define NETCONF content • Current Version • http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-chisholm-netconf-model-07.txt
The approach • Requirements • Solution to define content to be exchanged between NETCONF client and NETCONF server. • Similar to what we required to define standard MIBs • Minus some things that don’t seem necessary anymore • Plus some additional meta data • Uses XML Schema, plus defines appInfo tags to fill in gaps • Enables use of abundant off the shelf tools • Allowed us to get started right away
Areas of Requirements • Conformance • Fine Grain Conformance • Operations on managed objects . • Element Status • Additional Conformance Information • Backwards Compatibility • Versioning • Keys • Defining Relationships • Association Relationship • Defining Notification Event Messages • Considerations for Parse-ability • Well-formed XML • Naming • Error Messages • Schema Documentation • Specifying Statistics, Status and Configuration Information
Modeling Considerations • Modularity • Data Types • Elements and Attributes • Naming implications of using XPATH • Proper Tag Names • Granularity of Data Model • Avoid Mixed Content
Updates in -07 • Explained a few more benefits of the approach • Updated notification definition to align with Notification ID • Cleaned up examples to be more consistent and correct • Deleted the section which outlined specific NETCONF operations against the data model since it didn't seem to have much to do with this document. • General cleanup • Added an appendix talking about the potential for a mapping to Yang
Requirements This list is not complete, but demonstrative of the analysis we should probably do