100 likes | 200 Vues
The Courage to Innovate. Rating Agencies, Indexes and Your Portfolio. Your portfolio is built on stale and unreliable credit ratings Even your S&P 500 index fund S&P and Moody ’ s use issuer pay business model. What We Hear. “ I hate S&P! Those guys are crooks!
E N D
Rating Agencies, Indexes and Your Portfolio Your portfolio is built on stale and unreliable credit ratings Even your S&P 500 index fund S&P and Moody’s use issuer pay business model
What We Hear “I hate S&P! Those guys are crooks! Have you read ‘The Big Short’?” -Premier Wealth Manager
Government Studies • Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission • Senate Permanent Committee on Investigations: Credit Ratings • SEC Credit Ratings Firms Summary Report - 2008
Academic and Industry Studies • CFA Institute • “Issuer Pays Ratings Model and Ratings Inflation • “Does the Bond Market Want Informative Credit Ratings?” • “Does Regulatory Certification Affect Information Content of Credit Ratings?” • “Credit Rating Firms Have Historically Been Harder on Sovereign Debt Than Corporate Debt”
Lehman Brothers - 2008 Lehman Files for Bankruptcy September 14th 2008
Lehman Brothers - 2008 AAA AA+ AA AA- A+ A BBB+ BBB BBB- BB+ BB BB- B+ B B- CCC+ CCC CCC- CC C D 5/28/08 9/23/08