1 / 29

Work Package 6: Integrated Care

InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 January 2011. Work Package 6: Integrated Care. Christian Krauth Volker Amelung Hannover Medical School. General Questions. What is specific to integrated care Which parameters do indicate good performance of integrated care

ayoka
Télécharger la présentation

Work Package 6: Integrated Care

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 January 2011 Work Package 6: Integrated Care Christian Krauth Volker Amelung Hannover Medical School

  2. General Questions • What is specific to integrated care • Which parameters do indicate good performance of integrated care • How should payment systems be designed • How can integrated care models be evaluated • Which contractional designs exist to guarantee longterm effectiveness of integrated care models InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  3. The need for integrated Care Consider deficiencies of existing systems … Optimization of interfaces Care delivery on adequate level Rehabilitation Ambulytory Care Acute Hospital Care Cooperation and commu- nication Standar- dization InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  4. Indication-specific IC InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  5. A model for population-orientated Integrated Care InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  6. Contracting parties AOK (20.11.2005) and LKK Baden-Wuerttemberg (01.10.2006) Population and budget 32000 AOK and LKK-insureds (appr. 50% of insured persons in the ZIP code area ) benefit spending appr. € 50 million p.a., Virtual budget of MMG Contract Scope total outpatient and inpatient care, all indications except dentistry Contract duration until 2014 Frames InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011 Quelle: Weatherly at al Leuchtturmprojekte 2007

  7. Integrated Care contracts Integrated Care in Germany InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  8. Sickness fund A Sickness fund B Sickness fund C Sickness fund D Sickness fund E budget ambulatory care budget acute care pool for integrated services (app. 680 mil. Euro) 99% 1% 1% 99% Contract A Contract B Contract C Contract D Contract E InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  9. Pay-for-Performance InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011 Definition „Pay for performance is not simply a mechanism to reward those who perform well or to reduce costs. Its purpose is to align payment incentives to encourage ongoing improvement in a way that will ensure high-quality care for all.“ The Institue of Medicine, Rewarding Provider Performance, 2006

  10. Pay-for-Performance • What is measured - performance factors - clinical outcomes - patient satisfaction - process parameters - cost efficiency and savings - utilisation of information technologies • How will be measured - performance targets - absolute achievement - relative performance (compared to other providers) - improvement - (combination of perfomance targets) InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  11. InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011 Performance-orientation in the NHS

  12. InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011 Performance orientation in the NHS

  13. P4P Measurement Set Evolution InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011 Quelle: IHA IHA

  14. Pay-for-Performance • (Expected) advantages and disadvantages + improving health care quality + patient and provider interests hamonized - problems measuring performance - high control costs (e.g. avoiding patient selection) • Vital factors - part of a two-stage payment system - valid performance parameters - risk-adjustment to socio-demografic and regional parameters - combined with non-monetary incentives - utilisation of modern information technologies - evaluation and quality assurance InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  15. 6.1 Integrated Care and Pay-for-Performance Objectives • Understand the need for integrated care • Identify central problems in financing integrated care (e.g. motivation problem, problem of measuring performance, specialisation problem) • Find solutions to contractional problems in integrated care • Identify central performance factors for P4P • Highlight vital factors for successful designing and implementing P4P InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  16. 6.1 Integrated Care and Pay-for-Performance Methods • Theoretical analysis of integrated care (new institutional economics) - principal-agent theory (asymmetric information) - transaction cost economics (transaction costs) - property rights theory (incentives) • Identification and assessment of P4P projects in Europe - Review of empirical literature (on P4P projects in Europe) - Expert interviews on success and obstacles of (and satisfaction with) P4P projects in Europe - UK, Germany, Belgium … Deliverables • Review of P4P and integrated care projects in Europe InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  17. Principle-Agent-Theory • Central problem: asymmetric information • Conflicting interests • Opportunistic behaviour InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  18. 6.2 Criteria Development: Risk-Adjustment Objectives • Identification of relevant determinants influencing the performance (besides providers' services) – such as socio-economic parameters, co-morbidities, and regional differences • Developing and testing risk-adjustments (depending on level of influencing determinants) for P4P InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  19. 6.2 Criteria Development: Risk-Adjustment Methods • Literature Review • Evaluation of empirical P4P projects in Europe Deliverables • Analysis of vital performance parameters from provider and payer perspective • Review of guidelines for outcome parameters and risk-adjustment weights vital for quality-oriented payment InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  20. 6.3 Development of an Evaluation Model Objectives • Developing a transparent evaluation model for measuring provider performance and cost-effectiveness of outcome-based payment • Definition of multiple outcome parameters (e.g. based on IQWiG parameter definitions) • Definition of health care cost parameters • Testing the model using routine health insurance data InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  21. 6.3 Development of an Evaluation Model Methods • Literature Review • Health economic evaluation and decision analysis methods • Empirical analysis of integrated care models based on health insurance data - AOK Rheinland/Hamburg (2.8 millions insured) - AOK Lower Saxony (2.1 millions insured) Deliverables • Recommended financing models – a model to measure provider performance for quality-based payment in integrated care InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  22. Populationn-oriented Palliativmedizin Rheinland Vollversorgungsverträge SG/WES Gynäkologische Operationen D/DU/KR Internal medicine Beatmungs- und Wachkomapatienten SG/RS PflegeheimeRheinland Diabetischer Fuß D/K/BN/E/A/HH Neurology Schlaganfall Rheinland Multiple Sklerose Rheinland Chronischer Kopfschmerz/MigräneRheinland Chronischer SchwindelRheinland Verbesserung der onkologischen Versorgung durch angeleitetes Training Aa/Kr Aa Oncology Familiäre Belastung - Brust-/Ovarial CA Rheinland Maligne Lymphome Rheinland CIO – Integrierte Onkologie K Ovarial-CA BN/D/KR/LEV/K Psychiatry Seelische Gesundheit Depression AA/DÜ/HS SchizophrenieK/AA Krisenintervention DemenzRheinland Cardiology Akuter HerzinfarktRheinland Herzinsuffizienz/TelemedizinK/E/HH Kardiologie/Diabetes HH AOK Rheinland: 33 IC contracts in 7 Indication-areas • Orthopaedics • OsteoporoseRheinland • Paediatrics • AD(H)S bei Kindern und JugendlichenRheinland • Adipöse KinderRheinland • Asthma bei KleinkindernRheinland • Auf die BeineK • Mukoviszidose (CF-Cystic Fibrosis) Rheinland • Kinder und Jugendliche mit NeurodermitisRheinland • Übergewichtige Kinder und JugendlicheAa/Kr.A • Willkommen im Leben(Start 1. Halbjahr 2011) Rheinland InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  23. Which data are available for evaluation? Inscription Patient satisfaction Process quality BQS IC quality data Report für das Netz Routine data Cost and health care services! KV-No IC cost data Ambulante Daten H&H Daten Stationäre Daten Reha Daten InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  24. 6.4 Longterm Contract Design Objectives • Idenfication of population-based and healthcare service related longterm risks of providers and payers • Analysis of strategies in longterm contracts (ex post opportunistic behaviour to exploit specific investments of the contract partner) • Determining a longterm framework for contracts in integrated care (relational contract) InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  25. Longterm contracts (Hold-up) Problem • Changing environment • Incomplete contracts • Prohibitive transaction costs • ex-post opportunistic behaviour (hold-up) exploitation of contract-specific investments Solutions • Vertical integration • Specific investments • Transfer payments as security • Gain- and risk-sharing InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  26. 6.4 Contract Design Methods • Theoretical analysis based on contract theory • Review of empirical literature • Evaluation of the identified P4P projects in Europe Deliverables • Recommended framework for longterm relational contracts InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  27. 6.5 Effectiveness of Patient Education Programs Objectives • Evaluation of patient education programs considering - quality, - efficiency, and - access to programs • Examples of diabetes and depression • Comparative evaluation of selected metropolitan areas (London, Warsaw, Berlin) InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  28. 6.5 Effectiveness of Patient Education Programs Methods • Literature Review • Expert interviews • Evaluation of patient education programs in three metropolitan areas: Warsaw, London, and Berlin Deliverables • Analysis of effectiveness of patient education programs under everyday conditions InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

  29. Thank you for your attention! PD Dr. Christian Krauth Institute of Epidemiology, Social Medicine, and Health System Research Hannover Medical School D-30625 Hannover Germany krauth.christian@mh-hannover.de www.mh-hannover.de/epi.html InterQuality Kick-off Meeting Warsaw, 18-19 january 2011

More Related