210 likes | 292 Vues
Open Access Legal Resources in the United States 26 September 2013 Brian Detweiler Faculty Services Librarian Sarita Kenedy East Law Library St. Mary’s University School of Law, San Antonio, Texas. wikipedia.org. Overview of the U.S. Legal System. Legislative Branch Statutory Law
E N D
Open Access Legal Resources in the United States 26 September 2013 Brian Detweiler Faculty Services Librarian Sarita Kenedy East Law Library St. Mary’s University School of Law, San Antonio, Texas wikipedia.org
Overview of the U.S. Legal System • Legislative Branch • Statutory Law • Statutes at Large • United States Code • Legislative Pr0cess • Executive Branch • Administrative Law • Federal Register • Code of Federal Regulations • Rulemaking Process • Judicial Branch • Caselaw • Case Reporters • (U.S.; F.3d; F. Supp. 2d) uscourts.gov
Common Law commons.wikimedia.org
Judicial Authority Sloan, A.E. (2012), Basic Legal Research: Tools and Strategies, 5th ed., WoltersKluwer Law & Business, New York, NY. commons.wikimedia.org
Federal Statutory Resources tvguide.com
LII’s U.S. Code • Comprehensive Website • Browse by Title • Basic Search Only • www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text • Improved Search Engine
LII’s U.S. Code • 26 U.S.C. § 74 • Notice of Currency • Hyperlinked Table of Contents
OLRC’s U.S. Code Beta • Advanced Search: • Search by Title • Boolean • Field Searching • http://uscodebeta.house.gov/browse.xhtml • Sort by Relevance (?)
OLRC’s U.S. Code Beta • 26 U.S.C. § 74 • Notice of Currency • Most Current Version Anywhere • Easy Access to Previous Editions
26 USC § 74 on WestlawNext • The Value of Annotations
Federal Regulatory Resources flickr.com NBCUniversal
Searching the e-CFR • Boolean Search • www.ecfr.gov • Simple Search • Proximity Search
Navigating the e-CFR shirtoid.com
Updating the e-CFR • CFR Parts Affected • http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/browse/collectionCfrFR.action?collectionCode=CFRPARTS • Updates CFR sections to current day
Looking Back in Time • CFR Annual Edition • http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/browse/collectionCfr.action?collectionCode=CFR • No apparent search capability • Clunky—Best for browsing with citation located elsewhere Universal
State Law Resources Legal Information Institute Washlaw • www.law.cornell.edu/states/listing • www.washlaw.edu/
Municipal Law Resources Municode General Code
Caselaw Resources • ...is Galloway still “good law”?
Google Scholar’s Citator • Comparing “How cited” to KeyCite on WestlawNext !!! • “Negative Treatment” References: • Ranked by type of treatment • Red/yellow flags indicate potential issues • Headnotes show areas discussed • References grant of certiorari • “Cited by” References: • Ranked by relevance • No indication of positive/negative treatment • Both negative cases listed…
Bridging the Gap Between Open Access and theDynamic Duopoly • Lack of comprehensive research tools currently limits access and verification • OA secondary materials for attorneys would help democratize legal profession • More basic materials geared towards public would improve overall access to law saltlakecomiccon.com
Contact Information Brian Detweiler • Sarita Kenedy East Law Library • St. Mary’s University School of Law • One Camino Santa Maria • San Antonio, Texas 78228 • bdetweiler@stmarytx.edu • (210) 436-3435 ext. 1374