150 likes | 282 Vues
This presentation outlines a comparison between the Community Alternative and Caltrans plans for the Cabrillo/Hot Springs Interchange. Key objectives include minimizing construction time, reducing disruptions to local businesses and roads, ensuring fiscal responsibility, and addressing congestion issues more effectively. The analysis highlights safety advantages of the community coalition's approach, with a focus on local usage patterns. Unresolved safety and congestion concerns in Caltrans' plan are emphasized, urging a comprehensive evaluation of alternatives in the Draft Environmental Impact Report.
E N D
101 HOV Project Community Coalition Alternative October 18, 2012
Presentation Outline • Compare - Community Alternative and Caltrans plans for two time periods: • Construction Phase • Final Product
Community Coalition Goals • Minimize time required for construction • Minimize disruption to local roads & regional businesses • Spend the money wisely • Solve the Congestion Problem
Community Alternative Cabrillo/Hot Springs Interchange Caltrans Reconstruction Cabrillo/Hot Springs Interchange
Community Coalition Alternative Sheffield Drive Caltrans ReconstructionSheffield Drive
Left Side Ramp Safety • Accident data shows superior safety compared to 5 right hand ramps –Milpas, Garden, Castillo, Carrillo, Mission • Familiarity & virtually exclusive local use keep it safe
Caltrans HOV (Carpool) Lanes • STARTS at the most constrained point • Requires a forced merge and lane elimination in less than ½ mile on a curve going into a narrow underpass
Caltrans Reconstruction Cabrillo/Hot Springs Interchange Community Coalition Alternative Cabrillo/Hot Springs Interchange
Unaddressed Safety and Congestion Issues • Olive Mill southbound on ramp short merge • San Ysidro southbound off ramp congestion • San Ysidro/Posilipo southbound on ramp safety
Community Coalition Questions – Does it: • Minimize time required for construction? • Minimize disruption to local roads & regional businesses? • Spend the money wisely? • Solve the congestion problem?
Next Steps • Caltrans plan has significant and unanswered questions – cannot go forward as presented • Request Caltrans include a full analysis of the alternative in a recirculated Draft EIR • If justified, support design exceptions for: • Retention of southbound left side ramps • Relocation of the start of the HOV lane