250 likes | 390 Vues
Extension Education Anytime and Anywhere. The Business Case for Sustainable Extension e-learning. Stages of Implementation. Thinkin’ about it Pilot project(s) Special Enterprise Full Integration. Conclusions: Consider e-learning when:. Evidence of regional or national demand
E N D
Extension Education Anytime and Anywhere The Business Case for Sustainable Extension e-learning
Stages of Implementation • Thinkin’ about it • Pilot project(s) • Special Enterprise • Full Integration
Conclusions: Consider e-learning when: • Evidence of regional or national demand • Full certificate program • Competitive advantage • Enterprise approach • Field tested program
Online Courses Parents Forever TM
Study Questions • What is the business of e-learning? • What does it take to be successful? • Should Extension be in the e-learning “business”? • Why now?
“Education over the Internet is going to be so big that it is going to make e-mail usage look like a rounding error.” John Chambers, CEO Cisco Systems
The Second Bottom Line “In a business, goods and services have instrumental or secondary value; the primary value is making money. In a nonprofit, the service is the primary value; making money is a means to that end.” O’Neill and Fletcher (1998)
Geographic institution Just in case Isolated Brand name universities & celebrity professors Just in time Virtual Learning communities Old Economy / New Economy Source: Merrill Lynch 1999
Four year degree Distance education Correspondence & video One size fits all Forty-year degree Distributed learning High-tech multimedia Tailored programs Old Economy / New Economy Source: Merrill Lynch 1999
“The power of the Internet to transform the educational experience is awe-inspiring, but it is also fraught with risk.” Report of the Web-based Education Commission to the President and the Congress of the United States. 2000.
What is the business of e-learning? • Employee training • “Value-added” e-learning • Customized education / training
Pricing Price • 1-on-1 mentoring • Online degree programs • Instructor-led training $35-$50 per Course hour $75-$100 per Course hour • Tutor-Supported • E-Learning Interactivity/Intensity • Web Delivered • CD-ROM • Paper-based $5 - $15 per Course hour
Outsourced Cost Scale $65,000 / Course hour $10,000 / Course hour
What does it take to be successful? • Double-bottom line • Total cost analysis • Measures of financial performance
Cost Drivers • Existing condition of content • Required level of instructional design • Media richness • Types of media • Number of hours developed • Size of audience • Technology features • Registration, scoring, tracking • Collaboration • Mentors • Assessments
Fixed Costs • Intellectual property development • Instructional design • Production / programming • Infrastructure (equipment, facilities) establishment
Course-Variable or Stepped Costs • Instructor costs • Site rental costs • Some telecommunication costs
Learner-Variable Costs • Materials duplication • Mailing costs • Some telecommunication and software license costs • Learner travel & salary
Standard Measures of Financial Performance • Breakeven point • Return on investment • Critical minimum of aggregation
Total Cost Comparison Breakeven Incremental Fixed Cost (online)
Business Strategies • Superstore • Specialty Store • Boutique / “Mom & Pop • Cooperative • Corporate Alliances • Consultants
Conclusions: Consider e-learning when: • Evidence of regional or national demand • Full certificate program • Competitive advantage • Enterprise approach • Field tested program
References: Carr, S. 2001. Is Anyone Making Money on Distance Education? The Chronicle of Higher Education. Feb. 16,2001. Daniel, John S. 1996. Mega Universities and Knowledge Media: Technology Strategies for Higher Education. Kogan Page Limited. Effectiveness of Learning Technologies: The Costs and Effectiveness of Technology-Based Approaches to Teaching and Learning. 1998. Office of Learning Technologies. Ontario, Canada. http://olt-bta.hrdc-drhc.gc.ca/publicat/OPASexece.html Extension: On the Brink of Extinction or Distinction. King, David A. & Boehlje, Michael D. Journal of Extension. Vol. 38 No.5 Oct. 2000 Guidelines for the Evaluation of Electronically Offered Degree and Certificate Programs. Draft guidelines developed by eight regional higher education accrediting commissions. September 2000.
References: Institutional Restructuring: Is Distance Education Like Retailing?! Moore, Michael. American Journal of Distance Education. Vol. 13. No.1. 1999. O'Neill, Michael and Kathleen Fletcher. Nonprofit Management Education: U.S. and World Perspectives, Praeger, Westport, Conn 1998 The Power of the Internet for Learning: Moving from Promise to Practice. 2000. Report of the Web-based Education Commission to the President and the Congress of the United States. Whalen, T. and Wright, D. 1999. Methodology for Cost-Benefit Analysis of Web-Based Tele-Learning: Case Study of the Bell Online Institute. The American Journal of Distance Education. Vol. 13, No.1.