1 / 33

Epigraphy

Epigraphy. Optional Course MA/MPhil Ancient History Leiden University 2013-2014 2nd semester Instructor: Dr F.G. Naerebout f.g.naerebout@hum.leidenuniv.nl. 1 Schedule February 3 – May 12, Mondays 9:00-11:00, Room: Huizinga 007 please note: no classes on March 24, April 21 and May 5.

elsa
Télécharger la présentation

Epigraphy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Epigraphy Optional Course MA/MPhil Ancient History Leiden University 2013-2014 2nd semester Instructor: Dr F.G. Naerebout f.g.naerebout@hum.leidenuniv.nl

  2. 1 ScheduleFebruary 3 – May 12, Mondays 9:00-11:00, Room: Huizinga 007please note: no classes on March 24, April 21 and May 5 2 Assessment by way of individual assignments – which include the writing of weekly reports (50%) and a short essay on some epigraphic issue (50%) 3 Website A dedicated web address: www.epigraphy.eu (or www.ancient-history-online.info / www.oudegeschiedenis.info and choose ‘Syllabi’ from menu) 4 Literature Recommended: François Bérard et al., Guide de l’épigraphiste. Bibliographiechoisie des épigraphies antiques et médiévales, Paris 2010 Editions Rue d’Ulm [4th ed] ISBN 978-2-7288-0443-6

  3. 1. Summary Epigraphy = the study of intaglio texts in hard, non-organic material & more or less related stuff [for a full view of textual evidence from archaeological sources you have look beyond epigraphy] Epigraphy = any text that answers to the formalist criteria [the contents of inscriptions show a very wide range – with some focal points, such as epitaphs, but these points cannot double as criteria to decide which text is an inscription or not] Epigraphy = Greek & Latin epigraphy, inscribed alphabetic texts 8th c BC-7th c AD [there are many other epigraphies] Our purpose is to know and understand what epigraphers do in order to be able to critically use the published texts that epigraphers provide us with

  4. 2. What epigraphers do • Find inscriptions [hunting for inscriptions  chance finds] • Collect inscriptions [unpublished (to be established) or from whatever source] • Document inscriptions [photographs, squeezes, rubbings, drawings, exact description of object and of (original) location, measurements, bibliography] • Contextualize inscriptions [‘mettre en série’] • Read inscriptions [palaeography, language, expand abbreviations & symbols, make conjectures] • Categorize inscriptions [conventional categorizations, e.g. dedications, epitaphs, building inscriptions, military diploma’s, defixiones…] • Date inscriptions [from exterior characteristics or from dating in the text] • Edit and (re-)publish inscriptions • Translate inscriptions • (Re-)interpret inscriptions • Write the history of inscribing texts • Write history on the basis of inscribed texts

  5. So if they write history, where do epigraphers stand vis-à-vis other students of the ancient world? Divergence Epigraphers are specialized in working with epigraphic sources, including unpublished ones. Convergence The nature of the epigrapher’s work ranges from the purely empirical (publishing texts), considered by ancient historians, classical philologists or classical archaeologists to be an auxiliary science (Hilfswissenschaft, hulpwetenschap, disciplinaeditoriale), to the interpretative, which can hardly be distinguished from the work of the ‘ordinary’ ancient historian, etc.

  6. 3. Some issues for the epigraphist • Paleography (letter shapes, direction, punctuation) • Non-standard language (Dialektinschriftenetc) • Ancient abbreviations • Damage to the carrier: incomplete texts • Chronology (ancient dating systems: eponyms, eras etc) • Find comparable texts • Support: • Specialist reference works • Petrology • Digital enhancement • New technologies… • Data mining

  7. Paleography

  8. Dating

  9. Lacunae and conjectures

  10. 4. Issues for the user of epigraphic publications • FIND, UNDERSTAND and USE the appropriate texts • Bibliography  • NB: modern abbreviations  ibid. and several other tools • Geography / toponomy Barrington Atlas • Typology • Editorial sigla • Translation • Mettreen série, contextualize Guide de l’épigraphiste

  11. 4.1 Bibliography: the (re-)publishing of inscriptions • Individual or grouped in journals and in monographs • As part of some corpus of inscriptions • comprehensive • florilegium • regional • thematic [Other: reference to or paraphrase of an inscription, possibly of interpretative importance]

  12. 4.2 Bibliography: how to find a published inscription • Texts quoted or referred to by others (“I want to see for myself what X refers to”) • establish source and trace the text(s) • find older/newer publications, commentaries, translations etc • Texts as yet unknown (to you) (“is there any epigraphic evidence for…?”) • by provenance • by date • by material characteristics • by subject

  13. 4.3 LCC Subclass CN • CN1-1355 Inscriptions. Epigraphy • CN120-740 Ancient inscriptions • CN750-753 Early Christian inscriptions • CN755 Medieval inscriptions (General) • CN760 Modern inscriptions (General) • CN805-865 By language • CN870-1355 By region or country and scattered across the A-Z classes in the reading rooms…

  14. 4.4 Websites • see portal at www.epigraphy.eu • for latest developments, see: http://www.trismegistos.org/index2.php

  15. 5. Publishing conventions • The ideal edition: components • The editorial sigla

  16. Example: C.M. Lehmann & K.G. Holum, The Greek and Latin inscriptions of Caesarea Maritima, Boston 2000 ASOR (The Joint Expedition to Caesarea Maritima Excavation Reports vol. 5)

  17. Nr, title, image Date Measurements & description Provenance Bibliography Transcribed text with abbrevs expanded Translation Comments

  18. Editorial conventions, editorial sigla • The 1931 Leiden System adapted Krummrey & Panciera 1980/Panciera 1991 adopted by the l’AnnéeÉpigraphique since 1991, and by the current editors of IG and CIL

  19. Reading uncertain Letter damaged too badly for restoration Older editions have ? Letters that can be read, but do not make sense Letters that have been seen by a previous editor, but are no longer visible Ligatures Letters missing and supplied by the editor (conjecture) An expanded abbreviation ( ) abbreviation impossible to expand

  20. Letters or symbols represented differently on the stone e.g. reversed letters symbols like 7 or > for centurio, centuria |_ for Greek etos, etous etc Correction by the editor Older editions may have [ ] Letters included by mistake and removed by the editor Older editions may have < > Letters ommitted by mistake and added by the editor Older editions may have ( ) Letters erased on purpose in Antiquity Letters inscribed in an erasure Letters added in Antiquity to correct or supplement a text Approximately 5 letters missing A space of approximately 5 letters purposively left blank in Antiquity

  21. [------] Lacuna of unknown length ------] (also indicated with an unbroken line) [------  Indicates the direction of the original  text | Indicates the division of lines in the |5 |10 original text; with a superscript line || number for every 5th line (or a bold bar); a double bar for a major break in the original text

  22. (ds = disegno etc)

  23. Lacunae and conjectures

More Related