慢性房颤 机制及导管消融策略中的哲学
慢性房颤 机制及导管消融策略中的哲学. 董建增 首都医科大学北京安贞医院. PVI 是房颤导管消融的基石是否已经动摇?. CL 210ms 210ms 238ms 248ms 258ms. Earlist LA. exist. Perfect PPI. Possible Macro-Reentrant Substrates. CTI. Schematic of Common Lesion Sets Employed in AF Ablation. CH Sang , CS Ma.
慢性房颤 机制及导管消融策略中的哲学
E N D
Presentation Transcript
慢性房颤机制及导管消融策略中的哲学 董建增 首都医科大学北京安贞医院
CL 210ms 210ms 238ms 248ms 258ms Earlist LA exist Perfect PPI
Schematic of Common Lesion Sets Employed in AF Ablation CH Sang ,CS Ma. Heart Rhythm, 2010, 7: S332 Europace 2012:14: 528–606
Proven Isolation Of The PV Versus Extended PV Antrum And Posterior Wall Isolation In Patients With Long Standing Persistent Atrial Fibrillation --- Rong Bai,HRS 2012 全部患者3 次操作 消融内容完全相同 无房颤生存率 72% 60% 广泛消融 42% 34% 28% 18% 10% 12%
再次消融房速机制 Mechanisms of ATs During Re-do Jais Chae 基础资料 N 128 78 ATs 246 155 平均AT数 1.92 1.99 房颤类型 PAF 20% 73% Persistent 80% 27% 初始消融策略 segmental+ Circ.+ 规律房速机制 折返83% 88% 大折返 44% 75% 局部折返 39% 13% 局灶 14% 12% Jais P, et al. JCE 2009; 20: 480 Chae S, et al. JACC 2007;50:1781
慢性房颤术后复发OAT主要原因 消融径线未实现阻滞或传导恢复 MI+CTI+ROOF= 78% (91/116) JACC 2007;50:1781
长程持续性房颤导管消融 方法 PVI + SVCI + CS + Defrag + CTI,ROOF,MI(60pts.) 结果 房颤中止 87%(52/60) 直接中止11.7%(7/60)经房扑中止75%(45/60) 38个局灶房速平均2个规律房速 49个大折返 CAF成功率 : 95% Haissaguerre M, et al. J CE. 2005;16: 1125-1137
Mechanisms of ATs during CAF Abl. by Stepwise Approach • CAF 86 • Turned to sinus rhythm through 179ATs (average 2) in 80% (69/86) pts. • Mechanism of AT • - Macroreentry 81%(145/179) • perimitral 65, CTI 48, roof 32 • - Localized reentry 12%(21/179) • - Focal 7%(13/179) Ning M, Ma CS. CMJ 2010
慢性房颤线性消融的必要性 消融过程中经过 > 2个房速(多为大折返) 复发的心动过速类似机制 80% 需要多线消融 PVI + 直接线性消融 减少标测 减少增加食管瘘风险的消融 减少不必要而且可能影响心房功能的消融
PVI基础上三线(MI、CTI、Roof)消融(2C3L)是否有效?PVI基础上三线(MI、CTI、Roof)消融(2C3L)是否有效?
动物实验研究对慢性房颤消融策略的启示 Implications of former experiences • 动物实验研究(1912年) • 心脏颤动与心肌组织体积直接相关 • 心肌内在环路是颤动的基础 • 内在环路存在于大容积心肌,在较小容积的心肌不足以形成 • Physiology,Washington University in St. Louis • Garrey WE , Journal of Physiology 1914
MAZE III术式对慢性房颤消融策略的启示 Implications of former experiences First MAZE on Sep 25, 1987 Cox JL, Surgery Depart,Washington University in St. Louis J ThoracCardiovascSurg 1995;110:473 & 2007;133:389
MAZEIII 术式对慢性房颤消融策略的启示 Implications of former experiences • 1988~2001年 • lone(n=112 ) : PAF/PTAF=72/40 • Concomitant( n=86 ) : PAF/PTAF=45/41 • 平均随访:5.4±2.9 年 • 无房颤:96.6% (172/178) • lone : 95.9%(79.6%+16.3%AAD) • concomitant :97.5%(73.4%+24%AAD) Prasad SM, J ThoracCardiovascSurg 2003;126:1822-8
“2C3L” Approach for CAF • PVIs -------------------------- “2C” • Roof、MI、CTI ----------- “3L” • DC (whether afib. or organized AT) • Ensure PVI & linear block during sinus • Iso、Burst stimulation at ≥180ms • Mapping & abl. of the induced ATs (SVC isolation if afib. induced) • CAFÉ abl. limit to sinus couldn’t maintain Sang CH,Ma CS, Heart Rhythm, 2010, 7: S332
2C3L病例 60M CAF 5 years Activation Mapping Only After Endpoints/203L Achieved
“2C3L” Is Physiologic Roof PVI MI CTI
病例6 心衰房颤(房颤导致心衰) 55F CAF 4年, CHF 6 月, 无高血压、无糖尿病、无瓣膜病 LVED:58mm EF:28% 203L策略: PVIs 、 Roof、MI、CTI
病例6 心衰房颤(房颤导致心衰) 消融后 E A 99cm/s 77cm/s
6 months post ablation 3 days post ablation
“2C3L” VS. Stepwise • “2C3L” approach • 1.Initial abl : PVI + ROOF + MI + CTI • 2. Cardioversion ( routinely ) • 3. Ensure the endpoints of 2C3L • 4. Inducement, mapping and abl. of the induced ones (SVC) • “ Stepwise” approach • 1. Initial abl. : PVI + ROOF + MI + CTI • 2. Try best to terminate afib. by aggressive abl. at CFAE • 3. Try best to terminate ATs by detailed mapping and abl. • 4. Cardioversion ( selectively) • 5. Ensure the endpoints of 2C3L • 6. Inducement, mapping and abl. of the induced ones (SVC)
持续性房颤的导管消融 成功率% Heart Rhythm 2010;7:835
左房间隔部过度消融的危害 (间隔线、CFAE、FIRM)
LAA Delay Incidence :26% ------ 11% ----- 0% 2006 2007 2009
LAA Delay P QRS A V Jiang CX , Ma CS. PACE 2010; 33:652
LAA Delay: ECG Narrow P, Pseudo △, Pseudo ε
In the editorial, Dr. Chugh and Oral says: …………stepwise ablation represents a major advance in the treatment of patients with persistent AF, the timely contribution by Jiang et al. reminds us that there may be unintended consequences of extensive ablation………… Jiang CX , Ma CS . PACE 2010; 33:652
导管消融 下壁导联 P 波后半部分负向波
关于FIRM Sanjiv M. Narayan, UC, San Diego
“环形运动” ≠ 折返 CS CS
pro-arythmia or bridge to sinus rhythm
Relationship Between the Histological traits and Local Electrogram (CX43×200) LA Antrum