1 / 37

Key Issue

DEVELOPING A SENSE OF IDENTITY IN A MULTICULTURAL FRAMEWORK by Mary C. Sengstock, Ph.D., C.C.S. Professor of Sociology Wayne State University Detroit, MI . Key Issue. Developing a Sense of Identity … In a “Mixed” Environment: Mixed Races Mixed Nationalities Mixed Religions

hazel
Télécharger la présentation

Key Issue

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. DEVELOPING A SENSE OF IDENTITY IN A MULTICULTURAL FRAMEWORKbyMary C. Sengstock, Ph.D., C.C.S.Professor of SociologyWayne State UniversityDetroit, MI

  2. Key Issue Developing a Sense of Identity … In a “Mixed” Environment: • Mixed Races • Mixed Nationalities • Mixed Religions No Unified Definition: From Family … Community … Society

  3. U.S. a “Diverse Nation” • Multiple Religions, Races, National Origins • Colonial Times, Revolutionary, Early 19th Century (Several “Minority” Protestants) • Late 19th & Early 20th Centuries: Irish (Catholic!); Jews; Italians; E. Europe; Mexico • Increased Racial, Religious, & National Diversity with 1965 Immigration Law

  4. Divergent Meanings of “Diversity” Models of Multi-Culturalism/Diversity • Anglo-Conformity: All Can Come – Must Adopt Culture of Anglo Founders • Melting Pot: All Can Come – Must Merge Into a Broader Picture: Mixture of Cultures • Assimilation”: The Process By Which Groups Form into One – May Be Different Patterns • Multi-Culturalism: Many Different Cultures Co-Exist Harmoniously Together

  5. Variation in Views of “Diversity” Across Nations • Canada: Official Multi-Culturalism: “Integration” • Australia: “White Australia”  2-Way Acculturation • France: “Defined Mono-Culturalism” • Trinidad & Tobago: “Tossed Salad” • Race Not Necessarily a Divider • Divisions Economic & Cultural

  6. Multi-Culturalism v. Assimilation Group A Group B Group C

  7. Individuals in Diversity: 2 Types • Cultural “Retainers”: • Identified With the Ethnic Group • Stayed Within the Ethnic Group • “Hyphenated Americans” • Cultural “Assimilators”: • Joined the “Larger Community” • Preferred to be Known as “Just Americans”

  8. 2 Foci for Ethnic Research • “Retainers”: • The “Hyphenated-Americans” – The “PROBLEM” • Why do Some People Want to Retain Their Ethnic Culture & Identity? • “Assimilators”: • People Who Moved Into the Larger Community • Considered to Be the “Normal” Ones • Not a “PROBLEM”!

  9. Past Ethnic Research • Ignored the “Assimilators” – WHY? • Considered to Be the “Normal Ones” • Wanted to be “American” – Like US! • Not the “ODDBALLS”! • Not the “Problem” – the SOLUTION! • Would Produce a “Unified Society” 1 Culture – 1 Language – 1 Religion – 1 People • “Melting Pot”  “Anglo-Conformity”

  10. Key Question – Long Ignored • What Is It Like To Be an “Assimilator”? • Ignored Until 1990s: Inter-RACIAL Issues Arose • Why Do THESE People Want In? • However – the Issues Are Very Similar: • Inter- RACIAL Identity & Boundaries • Inter-CULTURAL Identity & Boundaries • What Is It Like to Grow Up @ the Boundaries?

  11. The Diversity Study • “Qualitative” (Informal) Interviews • 30 Respondents from “Mixed” Families • S.E. Michigan & Washington, DC Areas • Aged 18 Through 70 (Raised In Different Eras) • Major Categories: • Inter-Racial – 10 • Inter-Nationality – 14 (Some Also Multi-Religion) • Inter-Religion – 3 (All Christian-Jewish) • “Other”– 3 (Immigration; Social Class; Stepparent)

  12. Historical Cultural Boundaries • Colonial America: Scots-Irish – “Dumb Bums” • R.C. Irish – “Papists”! • Italians – Also “Papists”! • Jews – Not Christian! • Papists – Not “Really” Christian (Idolators) • All Seen as DIFFERENT RACES In Their Time!

  13. 20th Century: Impact of Race • Skin Color Was the One Similarity • At Least These People Had “White” Skin • Many White Ethnic Groups Capitalized on Their “White” Skin • Eventually They “Assimilated” – With Difficulty • Charles H. Anderson, 1970. White Protestant Americans: From National Origins to Religious Group. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

  14. Life at the Group “Boundaries” • What’s It Like to “Assimilate” – Either Type? • What’s It Like Growing Up at the Boundaries? • The Subject of the Book: Voices of Diversity • Anderson Described It – No One Listened! • People Assume It Must Be Hard to Be Multi-RACIAL – Why Assume It Would Be Easy to Be Multi-CULTURAL?

  15. Diverse Socialization: Painful! • Being “Different” (Like Any Ethnic Group): • Physical Differences (Skin Color Issues) • Cultural (Large Households; Religion; Education) • Issues Specifically Related to Family Diversity • Misunderstanding Family Cultures & Diversity • Self/Group Identification (Who Are These People?) • Perceived Non-Acceptance by Larger Community • Non-Acceptance Even by Own Communities

  16. Race v. Culture: Differences • Traits Obvious – Impossible to Ignore • Outsiders Comfortable Inserting Their Views • “Hiding” or “Passing” Is Impossible/Difficult • Distinction for Exclusion, Not Inclusion (Karen) • Problems Persist, Never Left Behind (Jeanette) • Cannot Escape – Even When Alone or With Close Friends and Family – Constant Topic • Affects Some “Whites” (Italians, Middle East)

  17. Race & Culture Similarities Some Impacts Are Similar Between Race & Culture Varies With the Level of Social Structure • MACRO: Larger Society (Government, Economy) • MESO: Local Community (School, Neighbors) • MICRO: Interpersonal Relations (Family, Friendships)

  18. Developing a Sense of Identity • Sense of Self: “Who Am I?” • Sense of Group: “Who Are WE?” • Issues: • Skin Color; Surname; Religion; Language • Loss of the Mother’s Culture • Loss of Subtle Cultural Differences : • “Hispanics” – “Asians”  • “Mixed” Families – Different Responses: • From Different Family/Community Members

  19. Self Identity: Choices People Make(Are Forced to Make?) • Often Forced to “Choose One”: • Very Much Resented (Teresa) • Mixed Race Identity: Psychological “Misfits”! • Results: • Single Identity Choices : • 1 Parent Absent; Personal Choice (Adam, Vickie, Jeff) • Mixed Identity Worth the Effort! • “Dual Identity” People ; “Heinz 57” (Peggy, Grace) • “Mixed” People Comfortable with “Mixed” (Deanna)

  20. Community Influences • U.S. Culture & Bureaucracy (“Choose One!)  • Local Communities:   • “Choose One” – Schools; Ethnic Communities! • Identity Based on Outward Appearances • Presumed Black (v. Hispanic, Asian) (Anita; Deanna) • Surname or Foreign Accent (Sam; Sarah) • Looks & Surname Do Not “Match” (Jeanette; Vickie) • Cultural Differences More Critical (Evelyn; Deanna) • Determine Ways Family Members Behave

  21. Community Impact on Individuals • Multi-Racial Persons (Some Multi-Cultural): • Experienced Community Exclusion • Often By One or Another of Their Own Groups! • Mixed Culture Individuals: • Expected to Identify as “Just White” • Special Problem in Schools: Critical for Identity • Not Hospitable to “Mixed” Children • “Pick One” Ridicule  Rejection (Anita; Regina) • Primary School through College!

  22. Macro Level • Census Bureau – Racial Categories • Most Questionnaires, School Forms • Pressure to “Pick One Box” • Leslie: Filipino/White • Anita: “NOT Hispanic!” • Teresa: Mixed v. Black • Worst with Racial Categories • True with Some Others as Well • EX: Middle East = Arab

  23. Meso Level • Community Involvement in Decisions • “Community Told Us Who We Were!” • Community Discrimination • “Don’t Belong Here!” “Not One of Us!” • Ethnic Group Pressure to Identify … • “Girl, You’re Black!” • Concurrent with Rejection • “Well, Not Really Black!”

  24. Influence of Society, Institutions • U.S. Culture & Bureaucracy (“Choose One!”)  • Local Institutions:   • “Choose One” – Schools; Ethnic Communities! • Identity Based on Outward Appearances • Presumed Black (v. Mexican, Korean) (Anita; Deanna) • Surname or Foreign Accent (Sam; Sarah) • Looks & Surname Do Not “Match” (Jeanette; Vickie) • Cultural Differences More Critical (Evelyn; Deanna) • Determine Ways Family Members Behave

  25. Special Problem for Women • Constant Change of Surnames for Women • Impact on Women’s “Sense of Identity”? • 1st 20 Years – Identified With Father • Marriage – 2nd Identity Change to Husband • Divorce/Remarriage – 3rd Identity Change • Subsequent Changes? How Many? • Impact on Woman’s Sense of Self? • Does She Ever Have a Constant Sense of Self?

  26. Influence of Community • Community Involvement in Decisions • “Community Told Us Who We Were!” • Community Discrimination • “Don’t Belong Here!” “Not One of Us!” • Ethnic Group Pressure to Identify … • “Girl, You’re Black!” • Concurrent with Rejection • “Well, Not Really Black!”

  27. Micro Level:Influence of Family • Lack of Family Input/Assistance • “Just Say You’re Irish.” • “Skin Color is Like Having Big Ears.” • Family Conflicts • Leslie: Family “Took Sides” on Racial Lines • “Won’t Go to Thanksgiving Anymore!” • Sarah: “Religion Goes with the Mother” … “No! Father!”

  28. Summary: Impact on Individuals • Multi-Racial Persons (Some Multi-Cultural): • Experienced Community Exclusion • Often By One or Another of Their Own Groups! • Mixed Culture Individuals: • Expected to Identify as “Just White” • Special Problem in Schools: Critical for Identity • Not Hospitable to “Mixed” Children • “Pick One” – Ridicule – Rejection (Anita; Regina) • Primary School through College!

  29. Stresses of Being the “Assimilator” • Identity Questions: Individual; Group • Mixed Messages About Identity • Not Totally Accepted as "American” • Not Totally Accepted By Ethnic Communities • Not Totally Accepted By Own Family • Constantly Reminded of the “Other Side” • Solution: Seek Others Who Are Mixed

  30. Assets of Diverse Families • Value of a Positive & Supportive Social Setting • Talk About the Differences! (Jeanette; Karen) • Focus on Shared Similarities: • Language (s) (Anita) • Religion (or Importance of Religion) (Vickie) • Political/Educational Goals (Sarah; Jeff) • Emphasize Family Ties – Not Culture (Anita)

  31. Lessons from Diverse Families • Distinguish Important & Unimportant Issues • Siblings Adopt Different Family Patterns • Divergent Patterns Among Siblings • Acceptance of Different Choices (Vickie; Anita) • Multi-Cultural/Racial More Acceptable Today • Better Than Being Part of an Non-Favored Group • Hope for the Future! (Karen)

  32. Continuity Over Time …Similarity of Culture & Race • Nationality & Religious Differences – 1940s Through 1970s • Racial Differences – 1980s – 1990s • Similarities in Communal Experiences

  33. A New Dimension/Problem:New Level Global • Growth in Inter-National Contacts • Similarities and Differences in Managing Diversity Across Nations (B. Marshall, Chap. 11) • Increased Contact Between Immigrants (& Their Children) & Nation of Origin • Increased International Contact Generally • Increasingly an International Community • Impact on U.S. Assimilation? On Individuals?

  34. Applied Chapters • Advice for Families: How to Provide Support for Children from Diverse Backgrounds • Dr. MC Sengstock, Chapter 8 • Effectiveness of a Diversity Program in Middle School • Dr. Sonya Berkley, Chapter 9 • A Program for Assisting Families Coping with Diversity • Dr. Arifa Javed, Chapter 10 • Comparison of Diversity in Canada, Australia, France, and Trinidad and Tobago to U.S. • Dr. Brenda Marshall, Chapter 11

  35. QUESTION? WILL WE LEARN ANYTHING NEW FOR TOMORROW?

  36. Conclusions • U.S. Has Not Really Come Up with Anything New • Practiced Discrimination Against People from Different Nationalities, Religions & Races for Over 400 Years • Often Defined Nationalities As Races • “Different” Christians Once Treated Like Jews & Muslims At Later Periods

  37. Voices of Diversity: Multi-Culturalism in America by Mary C. Sengstock, Ph.D., C.C.S. with contributions by Arifa K. Javed, Ph.D., C.S.P. Sonya Berkley, Ph.D., Brenda I. Marshall, Ph.D. New York: Springer, Spring, 2009.

More Related