Vanishing Civil Jury Trial

Vanishing Civil Jury Trial
Judge Xavier Rodriguez

Proportion of cases tried to jury trial

Percentage of civil trials to jury trial 1.2%

What are we to do with these statistics? Panic Ignore Celebrate

De Tocqueville

Juries “gratuitous public school ever open, in which every juror learns to exercise his rights, enters into daily communication with the most learned and enlightened members of the upper classes, and becomes practically acquainted with the laws of his country, which are brought within the reach of his capacity by the efforts of the bar, the advice of the judge, and even by the passions of the parties.”

Juries “I do not know whether the jury is useful to those who are in litigation; but I am certain it is highly beneficial to those who decide the litigation; and I look upon it as one of the most efficacious means for the education of the people which society can employ.”

what type of cases were being tried in the 1960s when the jury trial percentage was between 10% -11%? What types of cases are being tried today?

Jury Trials as a percentage of total dispositions by type of case 1962 2002 Torts 11.6% 1.6% Torts, diversity 14.8% 2.3% Contracts 2.0% 1.0% Contracts, diversity 6.2% 1.5% Prisoner 0.0% 0.5% Civil rights 3.5% 3.0% Labor 1.3% 0.4% I.P. 0.4% 2.4%

Potential Contributing Factors to the Decline of Jury Trials Tort reform and caps on compensatory and punitive damages (Likelihood of establishing liability x probable damages) – expenses not recoverable = monetary value of case Jury nullification In a criminal case, future Justice Hugo Black represented a Klan member accused of killing a Catholic priest, who had married the Defendant’s daughter to a Puerto Rican. Quoting from a Klan prayer, Black asked the jury to absolve the defendant by reason of insanity. “In an act of irreversible nullification, [the jury] substituted its own verdict of not guilty by reason of self-defense.”

Potential Contributing Factors to the Decline of Jury Trials Judges as Case Managers Trial by paper Motions to dismiss (Twombly/Iqbal) Motions for summary judgment Daubert motions to exclude experts

Potential Contributing Factors to the Decline of Jury Trials Reversal rate on appeals Lynne Liberato & Kent Rutter, Reasons for Reversal in the Texas Courts 34% of jury verdicts reversed Kevin Clermont, Employment Discrimination Plaintiffs in Federal Court 41% of Plaintiff verdicts reversed

Potential Contributing Factors to the Decline of Jury Trials Mediation

Potential Contributing Factors to the Decline of Jury Trials Jury Waivers Arbitration By the way, early forms of arbitration existed during Stephen F. Austin’s colony. See Michael Ariens, Lone Star Law Discovery Costs proportionality Corporate Counsel, Corporate representatives and Financial Incentives Hourly rates and staffing

Potential Remedies Timeliness Discovery Duty to Preserve Proportionality Privilege Review Modification of Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) Arbitration Early Merits Evaluation J. Maria Glover, The Federal Rules of Civil Settlement

What does this trend mean for law schools? Legal Research and Writing Mediation and Negotiation skills Discovery and E-Discovery skills Law Practice Management Trial Advocacy and Evidence classes

Vanishing Civil Jury Trial

Vanishing Civil Jury Trial

Presentation Transcript

Vanishing Civil Jury Trial

Vanishing Point

THE RIGHT TO A JURY TRIAL

American Civil Litigation Day Two The Jury

Advantages and disadvantage of Trial By Jury

CALIFORNIA CIVIL LITIGATION TRIAL PREPARATION

Trial by Jury in Australian Courts

Vanishing points

JURY

Vanishing Species

Vanishing cats.

VANISHING POINT

Civil Trial Procedures

Vanishing VOCABULARY

Vanishing Squares

Steps in a Jury Trial

Vanishing Energy

Trial by Jury

Civil Law: Trial Procedures

CRIMINAL JURY TRIAL PROCEEDINGS

THE TRIAL OF A FAMILY LAW JURY CASE

The Right to Jury Trial

Vanishing Point