230 likes | 383 Vues
This report evaluates Ambac Financial Group, Inc.'s growth potential in the financial sector amidst current trends like low interest rates and state budget stress. It highlights Ambac's history of solid performance, with a double-digit ROE and earnings growth. The analysis suggests trading Fannie Mae for Ambac due to Fannie Mae's operational challenges, including regulatory uncertainties and leadership instability. Recommendations include purchasing Ambac for its competitive edge in financial guaranty services and favorable market position.
E N D
Ambac Financial Group, Inc. Adding diversity to our financial sector holdings
Current Finance Sector Holdings • Washington Mutual • Citigroup • Bank of America • Alliance Capital • Fannie Mae
Investment Thesis • Low interest rates • Flat yield curve • Infrastructure deficit • Continued stress on State and Local Budgets • Lead to continued strength in debt markets
Strategy for the Sector • Trade Fannie Mae for Ambac
Why Buy Ambac Financial Group? • A history of solid performance • Double digit ROE and EPS growth • Good valuations • International growth opportunities
Ambac Financials Business • Financial Guaranty • Public finance • Structured finance • International finance • Financial Services • Interest rate swaps • Total return swaps • Funding conduits
Financial Guaranty Business Net par in billions of dollars 12/2004
Financial Guaranty Revenue Billions of dollars 2004
Competition for Ambac • Only three players globally • High barriers to entry • Ambac is a strong competitor • 28% market share in 2003 • Highest gross par written for 2004 • History of consolidation if market crowds
Indicators of Success • Industry leading 15% ROE average over the last 10 years • Double digit earnings growth for 12 years running • Effective underwriting • Efficient operations
Income Projections by Business Historic CAGR = 19%
Valuation Methods Used • Price to book value • Price to earnings value • Excess return dividend model • Current Price $72.39
Recommendations • Purchase Ambac Financial Group • Sell Fannie Mae
What’s Wrong With Fannie • No audited financial statements • Effect of regulatory changes on future revenues is unknowable • Currently running without CEO and CFO • Too difficult to understand given high manager turnover And… • FNM does not meet our investment policy requirements.
Investment Objective 1 • “Security selection is to be made on the basis of a supportive fundamental analysis of a stock.” • Impossible to be thorough without financial statements
Investment Objective 2 • “Maintain a risk level comparable to the S&P 500” • Company specific risks are significantly greater than other members of the S&P 500.
Investment Objective 3 • “The investment guidelines are based on an investment horizon generally greater than 1 year and consistent with a normal market cycle of approximately 5 to 7 years.” • Market cycle has shifted