New countries, new taxes If Estonia, why not Scotland?

1. New countries, new taxesIf Estonia, why not Scotland? ALTER fringe 5th October 2014 Dr Tony Vickers

2. Land Value TaxationKEY PRINCIPLES • levy on land value only (not improvements) • based upon regular professional valuations • applies to all land • based upon the highest value approved use • no exemptions (though some zero-rating) • paid by owners of land

3. Land Value TaxationKEY BENEFITS • Brings under-used and vacant land into use • Penalises land banking • Stabilises the price of land at its economic use value • Progressive and fair • Promotes choice and transparency • Encourages investment in improvements

4. Scotland Act 2012 • Section 80b “Her Majesty may by Order in Council amend this Part so as to: (a) specify, as an additional devolved tax, a tax of any description, ….” • Opinion of Andy Wightman (email 21 Sep):- • “LVT is within existing devolved competence. It is a local property tax and as long as LVT is that, then it is within existing powers. There is no legal impediment to the implementation of LVT in Scotland now.” • Scottish Government has been able to vary income tax by 10% since 1999 • Tories unable to block LVT, without SNP/Labour help

5. Other parties on LVT • Conservatives • 2006 Bow Group submission to Tax Review √ • Nick Boles (2010-13 Planning Minister), Tim Montgomerie, David Curry (former LG Minister) √ • Global support from many ‘right libertarians’ • Labour • Enacted LVT in 1931 Finance Act (never implemented) • Andy Burnham (in 2010 Leadership campaign) √ • Labour Representation Committee (10-20 MPs) √ √ • Co-operative Party (30+ MPs) in 2010 manifesto √ √ • Green Party • Campaign platform in Scotland √ √ • Caroline Lucas (HoC) / Jenny Jones (HoL) Private Members Bill √ √ • Young Peoples Party – fought 4 by-elections on LVT this year √ √ √ • SNP – has strong support inc. among MSPs √

6. Public opinion • MORI Poll Nov 2012 • 1000 GB face-to-face interviews on property taxes • Most understand: • ‘location’ affects property values more than ‘bricks and mortar’ • Transport infrastructure investment enhances property values • But most think all property taxes are unfair • Very poor understanding of council tax • Very low awareness of LVT • Views on LVT strongly favoured over ‘property tax’ if people are at all aware of it (but only 1/8 know about it) • In countries which have popular choice between LVT and other property taxes, invariably LVT is chosen • Opposition from ‘usual suspects’: lenders, volume home-builders (land banks), speculators.

7. Coalition for Economic Justice (CEJ) • Formed 2008, in wake of global financial crisis • ALTER, Labour Land Campaign are members – also Christian Council for Monetary Justice, think-tanks • Tax Justice Network & Green Party ‘observers’ • Chris Huhne has been (and remains) Hon Pres of Professional Land Reform Group (PLRG) • Sponsored MORI Poll and film “Taxing Question of Land” –shown at 2013 Glasgow Conference

8. RICS Colloquium Sep 2014 • Attended by 40 senior figures from all sectors • Concluded of LVT:- • would be capable of producing potential [annual UK] revenue flows of £82 billion: sufficient to replace all existing property taxes. • Technical issues (valuation methodology and data compilation) “are capable of solution within a UK context” • Once these issues have been resolved, replacement of NNDR “would be relatively straightforward and should enable ‘proof of concept’”, with Council Tax the next stage.

9. Fairer Simpler Greener(policy paper 75, 2006) • Co-author Dr Vince Cable • 3.1.1 “It is one of the central principles of liberal economics … that land should be taxed in preference to labour and capital..” • 3.1.2. “…some genuine difficulties with establishing accurate current site values but … in the long term, this is how the tax base should be developed”. • 3.1.3 “Eventually the system for valuation of domestic land could be integrated with that for SVR of business properties…” • 3.2.2 “Local Income Tax … will leave the UK in the unique position internationally of having no direct taxation of property at all.” • Written before the global financial crisis of 2008

10. Fairer Simpler Greener(continued) • “Good reasons why taxation of [domestic] property should be retained if a better [than Council Tax] mechanism can be found: • ‘automatic stabiliser’ tending to damp down house prices [land comprised 60% in 2005, 13% in 1965] • Most important form of personal wealth otherwise mainly addressed through very unsatisfactory IHT • Particularly difficult to evade • Property market would suffer far fewer distortions and be less divisive socially • Taxes ‘economic rent’ which is unearned, hence allows taxes on productive enterprise and earnings to be reduced.”

11. Mansion Tax • Wasn’t introduced through FPC originally – Vince’s ‘baby step to [domestic] LVT’ (2009) [with £1m threshold in Sep - £2m in Nov] • Was in 2010 manifesto • Polls show it to be popular • Responds to regressive nature of Council Tax and failure to revalue since 1991 • Addresses inequities in housing market but.. • Doesn’t begin to tackle market failure, stimulate growth, or even raise significant amounts of revenue [max. £1.5bn/yr] • Is relatively expensive to implement, considering its fiscal limitations • Labour has ‘jumped on our bandwagon’ • Smacks of ‘politics of envy’, nevertheless… • It will carry through to 2015 manifesto! • Good politics but bad policy!

12. Tax Policy Working GroupRemit • included – • “An examination of the taxation of wealth (including land) and how the UK can go further in taxing wealth.” • “Reviewing local taxation … include an examination of local income tax and whether there is there a case for revisiting land taxes at a local level, in particular business taxes.” which wasn’t done • “build on policy papers 75 Fairer, Simpler, Greener (2006)…”

13. Tax Policy Paperoutcome on LVT • No section on local taxes – but hence Party policy is unchanged since 2010, except on timings • Commitment to “launch a full-scale review early in the next parliament to look how it might best be implemented” • Reasons: • Lack of high-profile LVT supporters in Group dominated by tax and policy advisers ignorant of property & local taxes • Fear of tabloid press • ‘unreadiness’ of Party campaigners • Strategy: to be able to negotiate LVT implementation into next Coalition Agreement without ‘frightening the horses’ during the election campaign! • More votes against Mansion Tax than against LVT in 2013 Conference debate

14. Pre-Manifesto Papersituation on LVT Hardly any mention of local taxes Makes much of need to “rebalance the tax system away from work and towards unearned wealth” and also to “return power from the stifling grip of Whitehall to the citizens and communities of our country” but then only proposes Mansion Tax (<1.5% of total taxes) Motion promises to “give more powers to cities, counties and councils on the economy and local services” but says nothing about increasing financial powers to councils in England Promises to let Scotland “raise the majority of the money it spends” and assign to Scotland corporation tax receipts from Scottish business

15. Three ‘LVT detox’ tools in Fairer Taxes • “Exemptions or deferrals for the limited number of ‘asset-rich, income-poor’ individuals (e.g. pensioners on low incomes); • “Exemptions for low value residential and business properties, (e.g. through a tax-free allowance); and • “Using income tax / corporation tax systems to collect LVT, thus avoiding separate billing.”

16. “Where’s the clamour for it?”