90 likes | 229 Vues
Handpicking Students by Mark Peltz Luther College Academic Student Services Cases. EDH 5630- Capstone in Higher Education Kelvin Rutledge and Marlynn Lopez. General Overview of Case. Central State University- larger public research institution
E N D
Handpicking Students by Mark PeltzLuther CollegeAcademic Student Services Cases EDH 5630- Capstone in Higher Education Kelvin Rutledge and Marlynn Lopez
General Overview of Case • Central State University- larger public research institution • Career Development Office out of the School of Business • Working with 400 Graduate students • Professionals- Jim (Associate Director), Shawn, Lindsey, Sarah, Mike (Director) • Mike, who was a former tied to the fortune 500 company, is in his first month of the position and wants to increase the number of employers on campus • The fortune 500 company is looking to interview 5 graduating MBA students in New York • Mike’s decision is to internally choose the five candidates for the fortune 500 company to interview What should Jim do and why?
Identify Relevant Situational Characteristics • Main and supporting characters • Relevant relationships in the case • Specific characteristics of importance
Analyze the Situation • Office relationships and supervisory relationships • Team dynamics and group morale • Business model approach • Equal Employment Opportunity Act
Consult Ethical Principles • IT DOES NOT: • Act to benefit others • Promote justice • Respect autonomy • Establish faith • Provide help
Identify & Consult Relevant Ethical Standards • ACPA Ethical Principles & Standards • CAS Standards for Career Services • NASPA Standards of Professional Practice • NACE Principles for Professional Practice • Equal Employment Opportunity Act
Recommendations • Initiate a private conversation on the issue and culture • HR Mediation • Ethical Decision Made
Appraise the Decision • The promotion of autonomy, justice, faithfulness, and no harm • The evaluation of office culture and climate • The building of clear, effective practices for the future
References • http://www.naspa.org/images/uploads/main/CASethicsstatement.pdf • http://www.naceweb.org/principles/#careerservices • https://campus.fsu.edu/bbcswebdav/pid-6359953-dt-content-rid-12448908_2/courses/EDH5630-01.sp12/ACPA-%20Ethical_Principles_Standards.pdf • http://www.naspa.org/images/uploads/main/CASethicsstatement.pdf • https://www.uwp.edu/hlc.resource/documents/Chapter-3/05-new/111-NASPAs-Standards-of-Professional-Practice.pdf • http://www.dol.gov/ofccp/regs/compliance/posters/pdf/eeopost.pdf