170 likes | 258 Vues
Explore the abstract and concrete depictions of medicine in Christa Wolf's novella, reflecting on surgery, radiation poisoning, and the fragility of life itself. Delve into the intricate details of surgical procedures juxtaposed with the elusive nature of radiation spread, personified as "patient." Understand the nuanced portrayals of health, mortality, and control in the face of uncertainty.
E N D
A Presentation by Jill Danker Accident: A Day’s News
“Patient” • Literary work by Christa Wolf • East German author • Depicts in “real-time” a woman trying to understand aspects of health and medicine • Surgery • Radiation Poisoning • Life & Death itself
“Symptoms” • Medicine viewed as abstract and concrete in novella • Concrete: Narrator’s brother’s surgery • Abstract: Radiation poisoning; spread of radiation • Overarching: finite nature of life itself
Symptom 1: Concrete Medicine • Surgical procedures depicted within the work • Large, scientific words often used • Very specific and meticulous wording • Vivid imagery
Examples • “a metallic instrument…skirting your cerebral membrane, presumably pushing aside the brain matter” (10) • “peeling out from its healthy environment the tumor which was nestled very, very snugly up against the pituitary gland—root and branch, indeed down to the last cell” (25)
Symptom 2: Abstract Medicine • Personified in “patient” as radiation poisoning/radiation spread • Purposefully vague • Imprecise • Details withheld
Examples • Radiation often referred to as “invisible cloud” (9) • “how quickly does radioactivity spread, at best and worst?” (9) • “a new name for danger” (15)
Radiation • “energy that comes from a source and travels through space and may be able to penetrate various materials” (Health Physics Society) • Emission of excess energy of radioactive atoms (unstable) • Most dangerous form: Gamma radiation
Radiation Exposure • Single, high-level exposure to radiation may cause health problems • Increases occurrence of certain diseases • Cancer, some genetic diseases • Prolonged exposure at low levels can be detrimental to health as well • Working around medical radiation (X-rays, etc.) • Workers must keep track of how much radiation they are exposed to
Radiation Spread • Gamma rays • Move through air, water, and solid material • Radioactive material • Tough to contain • Can get blown by wind, rain, etc. • Can be absorbed in plants and animals
Chernobyl Disaster • Massive nuclear reactor disaster • Occurred in Ukraine in 1986 • Can be considered worst nuclear power plant accident in history • Major difficulties containing radioactive waste and radiation • Extent of the damage done to community and surrounding countries still unknown
What does this mean for the Patient? Concrete Medicine: • Shows a general and natural sense of unease • Helps reader understand narrator’s understanding of life & death • Small things make a big difference • “The Devil is in the details”
What this means for Patient (Cont’d) Abstract Medicine: • Shows shared sense of unknowing • Readers understand that narrator is highly concerned with knowing all parts of life • Subsequently controlling those aspects • Shows desperation and fear of narrator
“Diagnosis” • Abstract and concrete forms of medicine show to reader: • Narrator’s understanding of life and death • Narrator’s thought process while dealing with finite nature of life • Contrast between the two aspects themselves