40 likes | 116 Vues
Dive into the differing perspectives of Emma Goldman and Frick on the violent turn of the Homestead Strike. Explore their claims, evaluate believability, and understand how viewpoints shape historical reporting.
E N D
U. S. HistorySeptember 12, 2013 Warm Up: Explain the difference between horizontal consolidation and vertical consolidation. OBJ: TLW analyze sources for point of view. LT: TLW explain how the point of view of the author impacts how events are remembered/reported. S: 1; DOK: 2-3 1
Why did the Homestead Strike turn violent? Take notes… • Why did workers form labor unions? • Why did business owners see labor unions as unfair? • Look at the timeline while you review the story…about sweet little Mr. Carnegie… • Emma Goldman document together…write on your notebook paper…then Frick (whose perspective is missing…) • OBJ: TLW analyze sources for point of view. LT: TLW explain how the point of view of the author impacts how events are remembered/reported. S: 1; DOK: 2-3 2
Discussion • How are Goldman and Frick’s claims about the Homestead strike different? • Whose claim is more believable? Why? 3
Exit • How do Goldman and Frick’s point of views about the Homestead Strike impact what story they share? • Whose claim is more believable? Why? OBJ: TLW analyze sources for point of view. LT: TLW explain how the point of view of the author impacts how events are remembered/reported. S: 1; DOK: 2-3 4