470 likes | 576 Vues
This concise guide outlines a three-step protocol for Brief Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) developed by clinical psychologist Paul Rijnders. Focusing on shared problem definition, behavior change, and relapse prevention, this protocol aims to enhance patient commitment and self-directedness. It addresses the challenges faced by individuals with mental health issues, noting that only 25% to 55% receive treatment. The protocol emphasizes cognitive restructuring, behavior experiments, and decision-making, encouraging a proactive approach to mental well-being.
E N D
From Symptom to Solution:a brief, 3 step protocol for CBT Paul Rijnders Clinical Psychologist Indigo Zeeland, The Netherlands (www.kortdurendetherapie.nl) 2011
Brief CBT: motives • Unbalance demand and supply • Changing expectations • Costs • Negative image • High threshold
Brief CBT: requirements • Low threshold • Plain case concept • Easy to transfer / to learn • Enhancing commitment / Self-Directedness • Long lasting
Questions • How many people suffer from serious mental problems? 7 - 8 % • Which percentage of this group receives professional mental health treatment? between 25% and 55% (differs per country)
Question What works in CBT ?
What works in CBT? • Cognitive restructuring • Behaviour experiments / activation • Shared Decision Making (targets and pathways) (helping patients to become aware of their strenghts and weaknesses and to convert weaknesses into power)
3 Steps • Shared Problem Definition (S.P.D) (emphasis on coping style / (discouraging) habits) • Behaviour Change (B.Ch) (learning to improve coping style by observing, comparing, reflecting, imitating and experimenting) • Relapse Prevention (R.Pr) (what triggers? How to anticipate?)
3 steps, 8 sub-steps • SPD : - Restoring overview - Finding connection - Formulating targets / treatmentplan • BCh : - Habits + alternatives - Behaviour change by imitation / social learning - The power of thoughts - Challenging of thoughts • RPr : - Termination and relapse prevention
3 steps, 8 sub-steps, 4 measurements M. 0 • SPD:- Restoring overview - Finding connection - Formulating targets / treatmentplan M. 1 • BCh:- Habits + alternatives - Behaviour change by imitation / social learning - The power of thoughts - Challenging of thoughts M. 2 • RPr:- Termination and Relapse Prevention M.3 (after 4 months)
Questionaires: (OQ-45) • Gegevens van patiënteGeboortedatum: 1978 Geslacht: VrouwBehandellocatie: OosterschelderegioBehandelfase: nog geen of 1 gesprek gehadTestdatum: 23-02-2010------------------------------------OQ45-score: 75. Sub-schalesSymptom Distress: 51 This score is highInterpersonal relations: 10 This score is normal Sociale Rol: 14 This score is above averageCritical ItemsSuicide: Yes Substance abuse: No Violaence: YesEr is een hoge factorlading opDepression/anxiety: YesFeeling of Well-being: YesImpact of Stress: Yes
“the psychological thermometer” 180 • Gegevens van patiënteGeboortedatum: 1978 Geslacht: VrouwBehandellocatie: OosterschelderegioBehandelfase: nog geen of 1 gesprek gehadTestdatum: 23-02-2010------------------------------------OQ45-score: 75. .Sub-schalesSymptom distress: 51: H Interpersonal relations: 10 : N Social Roles: 14 :above ACritical ItemsSuicide: yes Substance abuse: No Violence: Yes Er is een hoge factorlading opDepression/anxiety: YesFeeling of Well-being: YesImpact of Stress: Yes 87 55 0
Your psychological temperature 180 • Gegevens van patiënteGeboortedatum: 1978 Geslacht: VrouwBehandellocatie: OosterschelderegioBehandelfase: nog geen of 1 gesprek gehadTestdatum: 23-02-2010------------------------------------OQ45-score: 75. Deze score is hoog.Sub-schalenSymptom distress: 51 H. Interpersonal relations: 10 N. Social Roles: 14 above ACritical ItemsSuicide: Yes Substnce abuse: No Violence: YesEr is een hoge factorlading opDepression/anxiety: YesFeeling of Well-being: YesImpact of Stress: Yes 87 75 55 0
Step I, Sub-step 1:Restoring overview • Dialogue • Patient’s report • Measurement Manageable bits
Step I, substep 2:connection Sd = Ci x Cs • Descriptive diagnosis • Emphasis on: Cs
Step I, Sub-step 2example Sd = Ci x Cs • Depression = (too) much burden x doom-mongering • Panic D = loss x doubtfulness • Panic D = > distress x extreme cautious
Step I, Sub-step 3:Targets; Pathway • Sd: self- control techniques; medication • Ci: support; relationship(s); sharing the burden • Cs: improving coping style; equilibrium; prototypes; metaphor
Step II: Behaviour Change • Social learning • Cognitive restructuring • Behaviour experiments
Step II, Sub-step 4: Habits and alternatives Sd = Ci x Cs
Step II, Sub-step 4: Habits and alternatives Sd = Ci x Cs
Coping style • Habits • Dimensional • Position on an equilibrium too little----------------------------------too much
Cs: equilibrium • Egoist-----------------------------------Altruist • Avoidant--------------------------------Impulsive • Pessimist------------------------------Optimist • Extravert-------------------------------Introvert
Cs: equilibrium: other examples • Richard-----------------------------------Hyacinth • Manuel------------------------------------Basil • Florance Nightingale------------------Madonna • Throwing in the towel ------- Man of action
Habits and alternatives: intermediates • Avoidant—cautious—steady—carefree—enthousiatic—Impulsive. • Shy—introvert—single—normal—cooperative—extravert—Sociable. • Obsessive—stubborn—serious—steady—flexible—Indolent.
Step II, sub step 5:Behaviour change by imitationThe use of prototypes and metaphors • Too much “Manuel – like” behaviour (Fawlty Towers) • Too much “Richard”, too little “Hyacinth or Onslow” • Too much Florance N, too little Madonna • From: “always yes, of course” to: “yes, but” • From Florance N. to: “in between” • From: “absolute single” to: “ a little cooperation” • From: throwing in the towel to: deliberated action • From: bull in China shop to: deliberated action
The power of metaphor / prototype • Multiple access (verbal; imaginative; interactive; activity) • Differs perception and reality (activates distance) • Humor (nonblaming) • Examples for change (perspective) • Speedy recall
Behaviour change by imitation:techniques • Equilibrium and sociogram “if you imagine……(family, friends, collegues, etc), how are they divided on...” • Equilibrium and prototypes “Who among your collegues, acts different than Florance Nightingale, without going overboard…?”
Equilibrium and techniques • Observing (oneself, other people, exceptions, effects) • Reflecting • Imitating • Experimenting / role playing • Cognitions
Step II, sub step 6:The interconnection between behaviour andCognitions / automatic ideas • Simple examples: (a sudden noise at night). • Burglar or cat? (action guided by perspective) • How would Florance N. react / think about that noise? How would Madonna do? Or …? • Simple role playing in the office.
Cognitions and your equilibrium • Stimulate meta cognitive activity: if it is your habit to act like, and you realise that …… what do you think that your habitual thoughts will be about ………. • Introduce The Beck outline
Step III, sub step 8Termination and relapse prevention • Reminders • Peers • Symptom = signal • Time out • Instruction booklet
Evidence 1.Van Orden et al (2009) Psychiatric Practice • 165 patients, different diagnoses • Brief therapy (BT) at GP’s office versus CAU in second line • Symptom reduction: No difference • Quality of life: No difference • Satisfaction: No difference • Needed amount of sessions: BT: 30% less. • % Relapse: not available yet
Evidence 2Van Straten et al. (2006, Br. Journ. Psych.; 2006, Acta Ps. Scandinavica) • 702 patients: Anxiety / mood disorders • Random: BT – CBT or CAU • Results: same as: Van Orden • Relapse (18-24 m): CAU >> CBT > BT
OQ-45.2-Total Means OQ_Total_group 100,00 low mild high very high 80,00 60,00 40,00 1 2 3 time
Conclusion • Guided/shared exploration and planning + • Guided SL, BE and CR + • Low threshold • (at least) same result but in shorter time