1 / 26

Writing Research Papers

Writing Research Papers. Andreas Paepcke adapting and augmenting notes by Jennifer Widom. Decision Dynamics. Decision Dynamics. Outline It!. Title Abstract Intro [Related Work] System Experiment Discussion [Related Work] Conclusion. Outlining: Not Just For High School.

ramirop
Télécharger la présentation

Writing Research Papers

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Writing Research Papers Andreas Paepcke adapting and augmenting notes by Jennifer Widom

  2. Decision Dynamics

  3. Decision Dynamics

  4. Outline It! • Title • Abstract • Intro • [Related Work] • System • Experiment • Discussion • [Related Work] • Conclusion

  5. Outlining: Not Just For High School • What do you want to communicate? • What goes where? • Figures

  6. Title Options: • Descriptive: “A Tool for Measuring Interaction Speeds on Small Devices Under Varying Lighting Conditions” • Snappy: “Interaction Speeds on Small Devices” • With hook: “Floosy: Twofold Increase in PDA Reading Speeds”

  7. Abstract • Don’t just grab text from paper • State problem • Your approach/solution • Main contribution • Very little background/motivation • Include the main numbers/results

  8. Introduction: Five Elements • What is the problem? • Why is it interesting and important? • Why is it hard? (e.g., why do naive approaches fail?) • Why hasn't it been solved before? (Or, what's wrong with previous proposed solutions? How does yours differ?) • What are the key components of your approach and results? Include any specific limitations.

  9. Example Intro: Cursor Trails • People lose sight of cursor • Efficiency cost; confusion • Large cursors are found, but disrupt work • Problem worse on new large displays • Cursor leaves visual echo while movedSignificant gain in re-acquisition performance. What?Why bad?Why hard?Why now?How solved?

  10. Other Intro Pitfalls • Don’t start with Adam and Eve • No cliché in first sentence:V1: “With the explosion of the Web...”V2: “Forty-five million news pages are read online every weekday.” • Don’t rile the reviewer • Be interesting

  11. Related Work • Pro Early: • Critical to be defensive • Short enough • (Do mention most significant in Intro) • Pro Late: • Want reader to reach meat • Comparison understood only w/ body of paper

  12. Related Work (cont) • Group similar approaches: “Several approaches animate the cursor continuously or on demand [5,6,7,8,9]. Others do away with cursors and magnify selected targets [10,11,12].” • Good rel work section contrasts with your work. Often: no space. • Check coverage of program committee

  13. Main Body • Briefly introduce required foreign material • Introduce a running example • Organize around figures • Guide reader smoothly across thoughts; reader should want each new section.“These initial results suggested the need to verify that the red color does not harm...” EXPERIMENT ...

  14. Experiments: What to Measure? Options: • Completion times • Latency • Sensitivity to important parameters • Scalability for: • screen size, • #of collaborators, ... • Subjective preference • Others?

  15. Experiments: What to Show Options: • Performance usable? • Relative performance to naive approaches • Relative performance to previous approaches • Relative performance among different proposed approaches • Others?

  16. Experiment Setup Section • Goal (should be mostly clear by now) • What did you do? • Type of experiment (within/between) • Task • Data/Equipment used: How big, how fast, how much, preprocessing/cold-start? • People: how many, age range, gender, social distribution,... • Don't mention IRB unless relevant

  17. Example Experimental Section GoalWhat?EquipmentParticipants • “We compared cursor trails against blinkies...” • “In a within-participants design we had participants...” • “On a 2560×1600 30” display participants acquired...” • “Ten women and twelve menranging in age from ...”

  18. Results • Only facts • The numbers • Failure cases • Statistics • Active vs. Passive Voice

  19. Discussion • No new facts • Implications • Describe • How convincing? More studies needed?

  20. Conclusion • Short summary • Drive home your main results • Future work • Say what you’re planning next • List promising directions

  21. Bibliography • Use a tool for consistency • Check result carefully

  22. Selected Challenges • That and Which: • That defines:The experiment that failed was well designed. • Which elaborates: The experiment, which failed, was well designed. • And others  Et aliter  Et al. • Use etc. only when blatantly clear • Avoid: for various reasons...

  23. Selected Challenges Continued • Vary your non-technical words:“We see that the row that differs most from the other rows is the third one.” “The third row maximally differs from others in the table.” • Avoid thing and other globalities:“The thing we notice is that ...” “Observe that...”

  24. Selected Challenges Continued • Avoid far-referential use of this, that, these.“All participants committed many errors. That shows how fragile cognitive...” Those errors show... This fact shows... We conclude from this outcome that... • Try it!

  25. Finally... Don’t start the paper too late

  26. References • The Elements of Style. Strunk and White(Grammar; sentence-level) • Made to Stick—Why Some Ideas Survive and Others Die. Chip Heath & Dan Heath.(Presentation level)http://www.madetostick.com/ • Jennifer Widom’s paper writing page:http://infolab.stanford.edu/~widom/paper-writing.html

More Related