1 / 12

Regional Trade Agreements: Challenges, Opportunities and the Development Dimension

Regional Trade Agreements: Challenges, Opportunities and the Development Dimension. CUTS/WTO Regional Outreach Workshop “The Multilateral Trading System: Opportunities and Challenged for East Africa” Nairobi, 29-30 April. Overview. Multilateralism and regionalism compared

said
Télécharger la présentation

Regional Trade Agreements: Challenges, Opportunities and the Development Dimension

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Regional Trade Agreements:Challenges, Opportunities and the Development Dimension CUTS/WTO Regional Outreach Workshop “The Multilateral Trading System: Opportunities and Challenged for East Africa” Nairobi, 29-30 April

  2. Overview • Multilateralism and regionalism compared • Motives for going regional • GATT/WTO law on regionalism • Developing countries and regionalism • Options for convergence

  3. Number of RTAs • Number of RTAs rising fast. • S-S is growing fastest (many not notified) • N-S also growing fast. • Most doable N-N have been done.

  4. Multilateralism and Regionalism Compared • Not substitutes, both supply unique attributes • Parallel universes needing better connections • Downsides of regionalism, although indeterminate welfare analytics and global governance considerations • Preferentialism and trade costs • Challenges for multilateralism progress, legitimacy and difficulties with reciprocity

  5. Why Do Countries Establish Regional Trade Agreements? • Wish to move further, faster • Deeper integration, especially of neighbours • Insurance • Credibility • Fear of exclusion • Domino effect • Identity politics

  6. Regionalism and Multilateralism • Trade diversion risks • Regulatory divergence and fragmentation • Incomplete integration (Agriculture, Subsidies) and same peaks, exclusions • Focus can mean neglect of multilateral interests • Multiple agreements means higher transactions costs – rules of origin etc.

  7. GATT/WTO Law and Practice The Law: • Loopholes and a lack of specificity • Contested interpretations • Limited influence on the design and content of RTAs • Sparse, permissive jurisprudence Practice: • Virtually no decisions on conformity • Confusion between law and politics

  8. GATT/WTO Law and Practice (cont) Gaps in the rules: • Nothing on preferential rules of origin • No provisions for agriculture-specific measures (e.g. TRQs) • Lack of clarity on application of contingency measures Definitional problems: • “Substantially all trade” • “No more trade restrictive” • Interim agreements

  9. GATT/WTO Law and Practice (cont) Arguments about role of dispute settlement: • Judicial review rather than dispute settlement for “balance” • Appeal to customary law • This is about politics not law • If GATT/WTO has not disapproved of RTAs they should be assumed to conform • Co-existence is the ticket for WTO survival

  10. From the Legal to the Procedural • Historic tension: information – political conversation – compliance imperative (substantive rules) • De facto a dysfunctional mix • The 2006 Transparency Mechanism • Early announcement • Factual only, no basis for dispute settlement • A “consideration” not an “examination”

  11. Developing Countries and Regionalism • Enabling Clause • No longer substantially all • Lighter surveillance and accountability • South-South agreements • Distinguish between CUs and FTAs • North-South agreements • Power asymmetries or alternative reciprocity • WTO-plus • Multilateralism versus regionalism

  12. Options for Convergence • Abandon regionalism • Multilateralize regionalism • Liberalize multilaterally • Fix the WTO law • Adopt soft WTO law

More Related