1 / 24

Improving the Ability of Engineering Students to Communicate Their Technical Discoveries to Non-Technical Audiences

Improving the Ability of Engineering Students to Communicate Their Technical Discoveries to Non-Technical Audiences. Deborah M. Sinnreich-Levi Susan Staffin Metz David Silverstein. Everyone agrees…. Communication skills are crucial for engineering students. NAE ABET AAAS NSF Employers

sarila
Télécharger la présentation

Improving the Ability of Engineering Students to Communicate Their Technical Discoveries to Non-Technical Audiences

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Improving the Ability of Engineering Students to Communicate Their Technical Discoveries to Non-Technical Audiences Deborah M. Sinnreich-Levi Susan Staffin Metz David Silverstein

  2. Everyone agrees… • Communication skills are crucial for engineering students. • NAE • ABET • AAAS • NSF • Employers • The public • Faculty advisors • And sometimes students. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  3. Stevens’ curriculum • Writing intensive classes in Humanities • Six 2-3 page papers • 1 or more oral reports • Engineering design spine • Runs through entire curriculum • Now includes communications workshops in semesters 6, 7, 8 Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  4. EIF grant period:Workshops Fall 2009-Spring 2010 • Spring 2009: • biomedical (4) • electrical (2) • computer engineering (2). • Fall 2009: • biomedical (2) • electrical (1) • computer (2) • mechanical (1) • civil (1) • chemical engineering (1). Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  5. Workshops consider Audience Rhetorical appeal Technical writing concerns Formal report structures Transmitting data using visual aids Other presentation considerations Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  6. Audience • Why are you giving this presentation? • What is your goal? • Who is your audience? • How technically informed are the audience members? • Are you speaking to colleagues, superiors or people from an entirely different area? • How large is your audience? Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  7. Aristotelian Rhetorical Appeals ETHOS stems from the moral character of the speaker rhetorical triangle LOGOS PATHOS based in emotional appeal derived from logical argument Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  8. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  9. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  10. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  11. Students’ pre- and post-intervention self evaluation showed they were better able to: • Write a document that effectively explains a complex technical topic. • 30% rose to 42%. • Describe a technical design so that a non-technical person can describe it to someone else. • 22% rose to 38 %. • Develop a speech or paper effectively for a specific audience. • 7% rose to 33%. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  12. Room for improvement • Students who began with especially poor self-confidence actually reported less confidence after the intervention. • “Some or no ability” • To develop a speech or paper effectively for a specific audience (23%28%), • Keep an audience engaged in a speech that they give (30%  35%). Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  13. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  14. Three areas students want to improve in. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  15. What abilities students want from the workshops Make engineering interesting 16% Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  16. Changes in the workshop series • Original workshops: • Presentation Techniques • Technical Writing Considerations • Revised workshop list: • Introduction to Technical Writing Considerations • Advanced Technical Writing Strategies • Introduction to Presentation Skills • Advanced Presentation Skills and MS PowerPoint Features Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  17. Additional workshops developed Spring 2010 • The Writing Process: How to Organize Your Thoughts • Writing Abstracts, Introductions, and Conclusions • Business English for ESL Students • Citing and Summarizing Outside Sources for ESL Students Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  18. Specific additions to the content of Communication Workshops • How To Tell A Story With Your Information • How will the audience apply these ideas, use this item, or buy this service? • How To Alter Your Message for Various Audiences • How must the story be different for different audiences? Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  19. Slide 2 Slide 3 Slide 1 Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  20. Other points added to presentation workshops… • How various companies rephrase or reposition similar information for less and more technically minded cohorts: • Using less or more technical detail • Using different graphics • Choosing different levels • Greater use of familiar images and keywords for lay-audiences • Higher level of diction as well as appropriate use of jargon, acronyms, footnotes, embedded links, and references for technical audiences. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  21. What did students learn? Preparing a PowerPoint Slide Show: • Use professional templates. • Proofread documents. • Have less clutter on slides. • Be direct and clear when writing and creating slides. • Keep audience in mind. Giving an Oral Presentation: • Practice the presentation with some friends prior to the presentation. • Test the PowerPoint on a projector prior to the presentation. • Interact with the audience. • Slow down when speaking. • Explain technical terms. • Focus on different ways to communicate with different audiences. • Avoid note cards. • Know slides well enough to speak from them. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  22. What do students suggest? • Give the workshop to freshmen engineering students. • Focus on how to practice giving a presentation. • Have groups give presentations and get critiques from different audiences. • Provide more practical advice or tactics on how to get yourself out trouble during a presentation (recollect yourself). • Make the workshop a full course on professional communications for engineers. Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  23. Teams judged on: • Organization and development • Delivery • Use of slides (5 max) • Content • Judges: • Writing Director • Dean of Student Life • Director of Coop Program Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

  24. Not the end… Sinnreich-Levi ASEE 2010

More Related