1 / 13

‘E-Learning and e-communities- asymmetries and dilemmas’

‘E-Learning and e-communities- asymmetries and dilemmas’ Mike Hart Professor of Business and Informatics University College Winchester Winchester, UK Roz Graham Senior Lecturer in Marketing University College Winchester Winchester, UK Hampshire, England.

Télécharger la présentation

‘E-Learning and e-communities- asymmetries and dilemmas’

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.


Presentation Transcript

  1. ‘E-Learning and e-communities- asymmetries and dilemmas’ Mike Hart Professor of Business and InformaticsUniversity College WinchesterWinchester, UK Roz GrahamSenior Lecturer in MarketingUniversity College WinchesterWinchester, UK

  2. Hampshire, England. [Winchester is the ancient capital of Anglo-Saxon England] Winchester Cathedral King Alfred’s statue

  3. Traditional v. e-learning stages of learning

  4. Emergent problems with e-learning modes of learning Despite meta-analysis of 300 studies which shows no significant differences between traditional and distributed learning approaches … • Massification of higher education (4% [1961] 40%[2004] 50%[2010] ) • The ‘electronic shovel’ encourages uncritical trawling of the ‘superficial’ rather than the deep web • Plagiarism almost certainly on the increase(Dordoy’s 2002 survey shows over 70% students and staff regard copying of paragraphs uncited to be ‘common’) • Suggested solutions demand new approaches to assessment (e.g. suggestion that original contributions be written in ‘green ink’)

  5. Communities of practice engage in e-learning Case study – Cascading Style Sheets Bulletin Board It is evident from an examination of the dialogues involved that: • E-Learning is taking place (‘the wool has been lifted from my eyes’) • Discussants appreciated the new knowledge because as experienced web-designers they could see the potential and applicability of new techniques • certain amount of instruction and practical help is evident • there is evidence of some reflection (‘now I come to think about it..’)

  6. Characteristics of e-learning in communities of practice We can induce certain characteristics of communities of practice (from the case-study) • Active participants will become learners • Some observers (but not participants) will learn in either: a positive fashion (good practice to be followed)a negative fashion (bad practice to be avoided) • Some observers will not be learners • The ‘silent learner’ is interesting. Non-participating observers may belearning nothing (because they cannot follow the discussion) or learning a great deal (but this is not being manifested)

  7. Modes of learning and participation Non-participating Observers/Learners Observing non-learners Participant Learners Non-Participant non-learners

  8. Can we measures the processes of e-learning? It is conventional to measure educational attainment by the demonstration of learning outcomes BUT • Do we need to concentrate upon processes of learning as well as outcomes? • How do we capture process apart from crude measures of participation (e.g. log-ons, contributions to a message board) • Exact boundary lines between the non-participating observers/learners and the observing non-learners needs exploration(active v. passive learning, deep v. surface learning) • The case study indicates that much more vibrant learning may well be taking place • Outside the normal academic community • When assessment and certification are no longer salient issues

  9. How do communities of practice foster e-learning? Communities of practice are social groups in which the ‘normal’ social dynamics of groups apply i.e. • A sharing of some common values and beliefs • Group norms are enforced by a graduated series of sanctions • A norm of reciprocity is needed in the long run • As in studies of the scientific community (Hagstrom, 1965), it isinteresting to observe the processes in which information is proffered in exchange for recognition i.e.motivation and rewards are symbolic rather than pecuniary • How does e-learning take place across group boundaries (varying degrees of participation)

  10. Action learning and the e-community • Initially we examined traditional v e-learning modes of learning in the undergraduate community who may well use learning in a highly instrumental way • However mature students often display a manifestly different pattern and display excellent patterns of collaboration • Past experiences of group members helps participants to learn and apply new insights

  11. Action learning and the education/work interface • Action learning has been most prominent in the Corporate Virtual University (CVU) • Universities have needed to confront (painfully!) their re-conceptualisation of what constitutes academic attainment • The nature of the e-learning experience requires emphasising for: • Post-graduate • Part-time • Work-experience modes of education • We might note the importance of techniques such as learning logs and diaries of reflective practice

  12. Conclusions Two broad conclusions are: • E-Learning might have greater salience outside rather than inside the undergraduate programmes in higher education institutions • E-Learning activities are much more likely to bear fruit outside the comventional 18+ intakes into higher education And so… • Is the rapid introduction of VLEs more a strategy to cope with problems of massification rather than the development of a new pedagogy? • Is there a way in which we can extend the characteristics exhibited by communities of practice into the undergraduate curriculum?

  13. And finally…. Any questions?

More Related