Man fears Time. But Time fears the pyramids. -Old Arab proverb .

1. Man fears Time. But Time fears the pyramids.-Old Arab proverb.

3. Reconstructing Lost Civilizations Dr. Marco Meniketti marco.meniketti@sjsu.edu Course webpage : www.sjsu.edu/people/marco.meniketti/courses/LostCiv

4. Dr. Zawi Hawass transfers mummified body from burial crypt to lab. Modern forensic anthropology can reveal much about the past. New discoveries in the Great Pyramid suggest new puzzles to solve.

5. Prehistoric carved artifacts from Europe 25,000-40,000 years old. The very oldest “art” dates back more than 60,000 years.

6. Fresco of the Bull leaping ritual. Knossos, Crete ca.1400 BC. Reconstruction by Sir Arthur Evans. Was Crete and the Minoan civilization the origin of the Atlantis legend?

7. Neanderthal skeletons created a scientific controversy. Scientific Hoax. Was Piltdown man a hoax by a prankster or a case of scientific fraud?

8. The Basics • About the texts • Frauds Myths and Mysteries, Ken Feder • The Human Past, Chris Scarre • pdfs • About the lectures • Themes • Course structure

9. Specific required assignments • Instructional philosophy • Policies • No late assignments. • Who is the professor? Lotus collector. Fresco of woman; Akroteri, ca. 1500 BC.

10. Structure of Course • Major themes: Changing Paradigms, Scientific Methods and Human Interaction with Environment • Secondary theme: Pseudoscience and pseudoarchaeology: why it is harmful. • We will discuss archaeological findings in terms of perceptions and understandings at various points in history: the prevailing paradigm.

11. “I have found in my experience that it is considerably easier to fool someone than to convince someone they have been fooled.” ---Mark Twain

12. Why is it easier for people to imagine the end of the world [based on a pseudo-cryptic prophesy of a vanished civilization] than a new form of government, a new economic system, or the end of the Internet? --EvgenyMorozov (Paraphrasing Frederick Jameson) from: To Save Everything, CLICK Here

13. Keep up with the readings Hand in assignmentson time Ask questions Spend extra time on assigned papers… do more than one draft. Powerpoint lectures are intended only as an outline, fill in notes as we go. Strategies for Success

14. Note that I did not say “knowledge” of the past. Interpretation of findings is always colored by contemporary thought, biases, prejudice, and prior knowledge. Archaeologists are scientists, but they are also human, and not immune from the prejudices or paradigms of their day. Archaeology has not always been “scientific.” Factors influencing our understanding of the past…

15. Epistemology • How do we know what we know? • How do we know what we know to be correct? • Are there different ways of knowing? • Scientific “method” based on positivist philosophy: the world is knowable. The past is knowable. Who were the people of Ireland that built massive stone monuments centuries before the pyramids in Egypt?

16. Concept of Cognitive Dissonance • We believe what we want to believe. • When confronted with evidence that contradicts long held beliefs, even strong evidence, the typical person experiences cognitive dissonance, and will seek rationalizations to justify continuing to hold onto their belief rather than adjust or reject their cherished misconception.

17. Archaeology is an interdisciplinary science Ceramic vessel from the Aegean, ca. 1200 BC. Minoan themes and style. • Follows scientific methodology. • Uses multiple sources of evidence. • Interpretation must be based on convergence of evidence from multiple data sets. • As with all sciences, archaeological interpretations are subject to revision, questioning, and modification based on new data. Cycladic

18. Basic methodology in science • Make observations. • Collect data. • Questions and hypothesis based on data. • Test hypothesis through experiment. • Make new observations • Refinement of hypothesis or experiment. • Share and Repeat…

19. Interpretation • If data do not support the hypothesis, then the hypothesis must be refined, revised or rejected. Contrary findings can not be dismissed or ignored. • Even after a hypothesis has been shown to be valid, testing of the hypothesis must be an on-going process.

20. Beware pseudo-interpretative frameworks • post hoc, ergo propter hoc • “after it, therefore because of it” • The argument from ignorance • “That which is not proven false, must be true.” • The argument from self-doubt • “ I can think of no natural explanation so the explanation must be supernatural.”

21. Rhetorical tools • Occams razor • In most cases the simplest explanation for an observed phenomenon is usually the correct one. http://skeptic.com/posthoc.html Not a scientific law, just a guideline for analysis of outrageous statements.

22. About the term paper for this course • Basic research paper • Research and synthesis • Multiple sources • Citation standards • American Antiquity citation format. SAA • Required format and length. • 3000 words minimum

23. Brief history of the roots to archaeology Part 1

24. Private showrooms of stuff eventually give way to the creation of formal displays of stuff (museums) during 17th century. • People begin to ask questions about the stuff. • People start to organize and classify stuff into categories; patterns emerge. • Systematic categorization created typological paradigm.

25. Stuff becomes associated with particular peoples and time periods. • Antiquarianism 18th century to present. • Treasure hunting. • Academic inquiry…archaeology: from about 1825. • Combined with historical documents and scientific methods the past can be reconstructed, but will always be fragmented.

26. What can be learned about the past that has relevance to us today? Can we find insights that will help us with our modern problems? Can we find clues to human behaviors that have significance?