1 / 18

Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data. Introduction to Engineering Systems Lecture 3 (9/4/2009). Prof. Andrés Tovar. Reading material and videos. LC1 – Measure: Concourse material LT1 – Introduction: Sec. 1.1, 1.2, and 1.4 LT2 – Models: Ch. 4

thyra
Télécharger la présentation

Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data Introduction to Engineering Systems Lecture 3 (9/4/2009) Prof. Andrés Tovar

  2. Reading material and videos LC1 – Measure: Concourse material LT1 – Introduction: Sec. 1.1, 1.2, and 1.4 LT2 – Models: Ch. 4 LC2 – Matlab: Ch. 9 and 10, videos 1 to 9 LT3 – Data analysis: Sec. 5.1 to 5.3, videos 13 and 14 For next week LT4 – Statistics: Sec. 5.4.1 and 5.4.2, video 10 LC3 – SAP Model: Concourse material LT5 – Probability: Sec. 5.4.3 and 5.4.4, videos 11 and 12 LT: lecture session LC: learning center session Using "Laws of Nature" to Model a System

  3. Announcements • Homework 1 • Available on Concourse http://concourse.nd.edu/ • Due next week at the beginning of the Learning Center session. • Learning Center • Do not bring earphones/headphones. • Do not bring your laptop. • Print and read the material before the session. Using "Laws of Nature" to Model a System

  4. From last class pool ball golf ball • The 4 M paradigm: measure, model, modify, and make. • Empirical models vs. Theoretical models • Models for a falling object • Aristotle (Greece, 384 BC – 322 BC) • Galileo (Italy, 1564 – 1642) • Newton (England, 1643 – 1727) • Leibniz (Germany, 1646 –1716) • Models for colliding objects • Descartes (France, 1596-1650) • Huygens (Deutschland, 1629 – 1695) • Newton (England, 1643 – 1727) • Prediction based on models Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  5. From last class pool ball golf ball • Given 2 pendulums with different masses, initially at rest • Say, a golf ball and a pool ball • Would you be willing to bet that you could figure out where to release the larger ball in order to knock the smaller ball to a given height? • How could you improve your chances? Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  6. Theoretical Model of Colliding Pendulums pool ball golf ball • Given 2 pendulum masses m1 and m2 • golf ball initially at h2i = 0 • pool ball released from h1i • golf ball bounces up to h2f • pool ball continues up to h1f • Galileo’s relationship between height and speed later developed by Newton and Leibniz. • Huygens’ principle of relative velocity • Newton’s “patched up” version of Descartes’ conservation of motion—conservation of momentum Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  7. Theoretical Model of Colliding Pendulums Collision model: Relative velocity Conservation of momentum Conservation of energy Conservation of energy Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  8. Theoretical Model of Colliding Pendulums 1) Conservation of energy 2) Collision model: relative velocity and conservation of momentum 3) Conservation of energy Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  9. Theoretical Model of Colliding Pendulums 4) Finally 4) In Matlab this is h1i = (h2f*(m1 + m2)^2)/(4*m1^2); Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  10. Matlab implementation % collision.m m1 = input('Mass of the first (moving) ball m1: '); m2 = input('Mass of the second (static) ball m2: '); h2f = input('Desired final height for the second ball h2f: '); disp('The initial height for the first ball h1i is:') h1i = (h2f*(m1 + m2)^2)/(4*m1^2) Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  11. Matlab implementation % collision1.m m1 = 0.165; % mass of pool ball, kg m2 = 0.048; % mass of golf ball, kg h2f = input('Desired final height for the second ball h2f: '); disp('The initial height for the first ball h1i is:') h1i = (h2f*(m1 + m2)^2)/(4*m1^2) plot(h2f,h1i,'o'); xlabel('h2f'); ylabel('h1i') hold on Let us compare the theoretical solution with the experimental result. What happened?!?! Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  12. Run the Pendulum Experiment Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  13. Experimental Results % collision2.m h1ie = 0:0.05:0.25; % heights for pool ball, m h2fe = []; % experimental results for golf ball, m plot(h1ie,h2fe,'*') Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  14. MATLAB GUI for Least Squares Fit Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  15. MATLAB commands for Least Squares Fit % collision2.m h1ie = 0:0.05:0.25; % heights for pool ball, m h2fe = []; % experimental results for golf ball, m plot(h1ie,h2fe,'*') c = polyfit(h1ie, h2fe, 1) m = c(1) % slope b = c(2) % intercept h2f = input('Desired final height for the second ball h2f: '); disp('The initial height for the first ball h1i is:') h1i = 1/m*(h2f-b) fit a line (not quadratic, etc) Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  16. What About Our Theory Is it wrong? Understanding the difference between theory and empirical data leads to a better theory Evolution of theory leads to a better model Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  17. Improved collision model Huygens’ principle of relative velocity Coefficient of restitution Improved collision model: COR and conservation of momentum The improved theoretical solution is hi1 = (h2f*(m1 + m2)^2)/(m1^2*(Cr + 1)^2) Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

  18. Matlab implementation % collision3.m m1 = 0.165; % mass of pool ball, kg m2 = 0.048; % mass of golf ball, kg Cr = input('Coefficient of restitution: '); h2f = input('Desired final height for the second ball h2f: '); disp('The initial height for the first ball h1i is:') hi1 = (h2f*(m1 + m2)^2)/(m1^2*(Cr + 1)^2) Let us compare the improved theoretical solution with the experimental result. What happened now? Empirical Models: Fitting a Line to Experimental Data

More Related