Towards an Enhanced Telluric Compensation Methodology

1. Towards an Enhanced Telluric Compensation Methodology Chijioke Ukiwe & Shamus McDonnell Hunter McDonnell Pipelines Services Inc. Presented at AUCSC 2011 by Gord Parker, C.E.T., CP2 Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

2. This Work This paper is a progress report of an ongoing R&D project to develop an enhanced Telluric and AC interference compensation methodology. Research commissioned by Spectrum XLI Partial funding from the Government of Canada This presentation was previously delivered at the NACE Northern AreaWestern Conference.

3. Telluric Current • A telluric current (from Latin tellūs, "earth") is an electric current which moves underground or through the sea. • The currents are extremely low frequency and travel over large areas at or near the surface of Earth. • Telluric currents are also observed in the Earth's crust and mantle.

4. Telluric currents are primarily induced by changes in the outer part of the Earth's magnetic field, usually caused by interactions between the solar wind and the magnetosphere or solar radiation effects on the ionosphere.

5. Some Telluric Current Facts • The magnitude varies, but can be in the order of 100's to 1000's of Amperes. • Local variations in the conductivity of the Earth's crust affect the density of these currents as they follow the path of least resistance.   • This effect can be used to detect the presence of low-conductivity ore bodies beneath the crust in geological surveys. • Along with the currents induced in the Earth's crust, any man-made conducting objects on or beneath the Earth's surface will also have large currents induced in them.   • This can cause power grid systems to trip from the overload. • High sun-spot activities can buffet the Earth's magnetic field, causing fluctuations which in turn induces telluric currents on earth conductors, increasing the likelihood of such interruptions.

6. How do telluric currents affect pipelines? Magnetic field Earth’s geo-magnetic field The sun emits energy & Particles Voltage swings in CP systems during close interval survey CIS Induced electric field Induced electric currents on pipelines Source: space weather Canada

7. Telluric currents: economic importance Voltage Time V Test Post CSE • Difficulty to pipeline integrity assessment – if uncorrected could result in incorrect interpretation and improper adjustment of CP system Pipeline = Possibility of Corrosion Pipe-to-soil potential measurement

8. 5 Seconds grid 2 Seconds CP Interruption Cycle 40 Second Telluric Current Cycle Low frequency Temporal Voltage swing = DV at t for any pipeline location Telluric current frequency varies; cycle times of a few seconds to minutes. Telluric on pipe-to-soil potentials: practical example

9. 4 second grid 2 second CP Interruption Cycle Multiple Voltage swings superimposed on the pipe-to-soil Potential: High frequency AC 50/60 Hz Low Frequency telluric 1/40th Hz AC Interference on pipe-to-soil potentials

10. Telluric characteristics: Temporal AND Regional effects PIPELINE DISTANCE At the same moment in time Telluric Magnitude 500mV 400mV 300mV 100mV C D A B Regional Effects on pipeline structures on telluric variation: Valves, bends, rectifiers, anodes, insulating flanges Telluric Potential Variation up to ~100 mV/Km at same moment

11. Telluric characteristics: Temporal effects 2. Space weather effects At a given location along the pipeline, PSP changes with time 20+ mV/sec > 100mV / cycle telluric effect has been recorded!

12. What is “Telluric Compensation”? Voltage Time Exclusion of “Noise” on PSP Data during CIS Voltage Time

13. Basis for Telluric Compensation Stationary PSP data (from stationary data logger (SDL)) summed over time yields “stable” average PSP Comparable regional effects of telluric on PSP within several kms SDL PSP data can be used to correct for any PSP variation in close proximity PSP PSP

14. Average PSP? Use statistics carefully, considering duration of temporal effects, and size of data pool. Using data from a short time period, other than the actual survey period can result in error. There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics. Benjamin Disraeli (1804 - 1881)

15. Current Field Practices for Telluric Compensation Real-time telluric compensation; based on stationary reference electrode placed at start of survey. Data Logger + - V V SRE Telluric Pipe-to-soil potential variations are corrected real-time

16. Current Field Practices for Telluric Compensation 1. Real-Time Compensation: pit-falls Unreliable representative average PSP Difference in regional telluric effects on pipe can render correction useless X High Telluric magnitude at A Error in compensation increases away from Stationary electrode SRE Suppressed Telluric magnitude at B A B

17. Current Field Practices for Telluric Compensation Single Stationary Data Logger Compensation Post Processing For Compensation Reliable representative average PSP during survey Difference in regional telluric effects on pipe can render correction useless SRE + SDL B A X Differences in regional telluric currents at A & B affect correction method Suppression of Telluric magnitude at B

18. A B Current Field Practices for Telluric Compensation 3. Multiple SDL Telluric Correction C Approximately linear telluric profile at any Given time, “t” within pipe section, AB

19. Multiple SDL Telluric Correction: Underlying Assumptions • Based on Distributed Source Transmission Line • (DSTL) Theory • SDL placement spacing ~ 6 – 8 km • Electrical continuity of telluric currents = • uniformity of soil and pipeline characteristics • Statistical average PSP is calculated from pool of readings that span entire survey period.

20. Multiple SDL Telluric Correction SDL-B SDL-A

21. Multiple SDL Telluric Correction Enhancements Field work Enhancements Easier and faster Data Post-processing = And more reliable results! 3-4 SDLs Waveform Log Strategic SDL Positioning

22. Enhanced Telluric Compensation: unique advantage ~ capturing FULL telluric variation trend along pipeline A B C D Pipeline Telluric Magnitude

23. 4 SDL Telluric Compensation Method: example

24. 4 SDL Telluric Compensation Method: Practical safeguard against error! PSP Variation (mV) 496.1 500.0 502.3 503.5 SDL Placement (miles)

25. Enhanced Telluric Compensation: Fast Interruption cycle Telluric Variation can exceed 50 mV per second times cycle length = significant! • Use of Fast Interruption • Cycle of about ~1 second = ON:OFF (~3:1) = <50mV per cycle (simple 1 potential / cycle correction) • Longer cycle makes it necessary for independent Telluric correction for ON and Instant Off PSP; different magnitude at start of cycle and end of cycle!

26. Multiple SDL Telluric Correction Enhancements: (2) Post-processing (a) Continuous waveform logging of the PSP Need to ensure the same readings are selected from both survey data and SDL – if different technologies used, errors can result

27. Multiple SDL Telluric Correction Enhancements: (2) Post-processing (b) Simple moving average system on SDL data before telluric compensation Careful and thorough Choice of each ON and OFF PSP data before Telluric correction using Simple moving averages Of telluric and high Frequency AC interferences

28. Multiple SDL Telluric Correction Enhancements: Final Post-processed data

29. … Even further telluric enhancements Recent advances in research holds promise for the use of telluric trends to forecast telluric magnitude over longer sections of pipelines = more strategic SDL placements and time of survey. Ability to compensate for high frequency interference; 50/60 Hz AC using high frequency stationary data loggers.

30. Conclusions • The use of 3 ~ 4 Stationary data loggers to track telluric pattern • and ensure accurate compensation • Fast cycles are preferred to avoid under/over-compensation • to either ON or OFF pipe-to-soil potential data • Continuous waveform logging can enhance data accuracy • Advanced statistical approaches can enhance post-processing • and hence, overall pipeline integrity

31. Acknowledgement The Authors are grateful to the National Research Council of Canada for financial support through an Industrial Research Assistantship fund

32. Questions?