P802.17D2.3 CRG Report August 2003 Summary
70 likes | 174 Vues
Comprehensive summary of technical and editorial comments addressed in Clause 7, Annex B, and Annex C, highlighting accepted, modified, withdrawn, and superseded responses. Editorial comment handling included.
P802.17D2.3 CRG Report August 2003 Summary
E N D
Presentation Transcript
PHY CRG ReportAugust 2003@ San Jose, CA Harry Peng: technical editorRhett Brikovskis: section editor P802.17D2.3 CRG
D2.4 Comment Summary • Total • 60 technical binding • 1 technical non-binding • 6 editorial • Clause 7: total 15 • 8 technical binding • 1 technical non-binding • 6 editorial • Annex B: total 20 • 20 technical binding • 0 technical non-binding • 0 editorial • Annex C: total 32 • 32 technical binding • 0 technical non-binding • 0 editorial P802.17D2.3 CRG
CRG result • Clause 7: total 15 • 8 technical binding Addressed • 1 technical non-binding Addressed • 6 editorial -- • Annex B: total 20 • 20 technical binding Addressed • 0 technical non-binding -- • 0 editorial -- • Annex C: total 32 • 32 technical binding Addressed • 0 technical non-binding -- • 0 editorial -- P802.17D2.3 CRG
Highlight and Summary • Clause 7 • All technical comments are addressed: • accepted ( 260, 261, ), • accepted-modified ( 262, 264, 267, 259), • accepted-duplicate (258 dup of 4, 265 dup of #264) • Superseded (263) P802.17D2.3 CRG
Highlight and Summary • Clause B • All technical comments are addressed: • withdrawn ( 635, 644, 649, 652 ), • accepted-modified ( 645, 651), • accepted-duplicate ( 634 ) • All other accepted P802.17D2.3 CRG
Highlight and Summary • Clause C • All technical comments are addressed: • withdrawn ( 660, 661, 665, 667, 669, 668, 672, 673, 674, 675, 676, 677, 678, 679, 680 ) • Mostly SPI description • accepted-modified ( 666, 658, 663, 662, 664, 670, 682, 684), • accepted-duplicate ( 683, 654 ) • Superseded ( 671, 685) • All other accepted P802.17D2.3 CRG
Editorial Comments • Will request for Editorial license to address editorial comments P802.17D2.3 CRG