Download
comment resolution summary letter ballot 1 category tpc n.
Skip this Video
Loading SlideShow in 5 Seconds..
Comment Resolution Summary Letter Ballot 1 Category: TPC PowerPoint Presentation
Download Presentation
Comment Resolution Summary Letter Ballot 1 Category: TPC

Comment Resolution Summary Letter Ballot 1 Category: TPC

79 Vues Download Presentation
Télécharger la présentation

Comment Resolution Summary Letter Ballot 1 Category: TPC

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript

  1. Comment Resolution SummaryLetter Ballot 1Category: TPC John Klein Symbol Technologies, Inc. jklein@sj.symbol.com John Klein - Symbol

  2. TPC Comment Summary • Total Number of Comments: 28 • Number of Unique Comments: 22 • Classifications: • Accept: 13, 19, 24, 37, 273, 379, 786, 787, 821, 825 • Fixing #13 also fixes 19, 273 • Decline: 41, 280, 281, 740, 941 • Discuss: 56, 93, 276, 929, 969 • Assign to Editor: 309 • Duplicate: 40, 102, 278, 826, 951, 968 • Mis-categorized: 185, 379 • 04/1120 (Author: Simon Black) normative text resolves 13, 19, 24, 37, 40, 273, 278, 786, 787, 821, 825, 826 John Klein - Symbol

  3. TPC Comment ClassificationAccept • Comment 13, 19, 273 – TPC Power Adaptation • Changed TPC Request / Report to Link Margin Request / Report. De-couples TPC from RRM. • Comment 24 – Add Elements to BSSDescription table. • Comment 37 – Fixes bullet item that was missing • Comment 786 – Section can be deleted cause Table 5 not used by 11k • Comment 787 – Change “Table 5” to “Table k12” • Comment 821 – Now Link Margin. New Frame Definitions added. • Comment 825 – Now Link Margin. New Frame Definitions added. John Klein - Symbol

  4. TPC Comment ClassificationDecline • Comment 41 – Since TPC becomes Link Margin, this comment no longer applies or makes sense. • Comment 280 – Since TPC becomes Link Margin, this no longer needs to be changed in 11h – 2003 standard. The original text in 11h should not be modified. • Comment 281 – Since TPC becomes Link Margin, this no longer needs to be changed in 11h – 2003 standard. The original text in 11h should not be modified. John Klein - Symbol

  5. TPC Comment Classification DeclineContinued… • Comment 740 – The Neighbor Report is advisory to the STA and does not allow the STA to violate the regulatory domain based on the information in the Neighbor Report. • Comment 941 – The Neighbor Report is advisory to the STA and does not allow the STA to violate the regulatory domain based on the information in the Neighbor Report. The information in the Neighbor Report coupled with definitive information collected directly from the AP may optimize the algorithm the STA uses to select the next AP in the BSS transition. Adding a do not probe element does not help because the Neighbor Report information is to be considered 'stale' by nature. A channel that you may not have been able to probe earlier may be available now, and that information would not be current, thus limiting the STA's ability to locate neighbors on that channel John Klein - Symbol

  6. TPC Comment Classification Discuss • Comment 56 – Replace the paragraph with the following: "All stations are responsible for maintaining an association or membership with the BSS or IBSS respectively, on the serving channel while performing measurements on non-serving channels." Also recommend changing 11.7.6, line 30 with the same information as quoted above. • Comment 93 – TGk needs some mechanism to preserve the 11h measurement that is required for regulatory. It may be possible for the STA to return "Refused" in the event an 11k measurement is received while an 11h measurement is queued, pending, or executing. • Comment 276 – Remove Link Margin from 2.4 Ghz Band because Link Margin doesn’t work for 2.4 Ghz. Use Frame Error Rate instead in 2.4 Ghz. • Comment 929 – What’s the need for Autonomous Reporting? Please Remove. • Comment 969 – Make Autonomous Reporting Default Disabled. John Klein - Symbol

  7. Motion to Resolve TPC Comments • Move to accept resolutions for: Decline Comment 40, Decline Comment 280, Decline Comment 281, Decline Comment 740, Decline Comment 941 TGk Movers: Result: John Klein - Symbol