1 / 21

Sustainable and Healthy Diets: the policy problem Corinna Hawkes & Tim Lang c.hawkes@wcrf.org ; t.lang@city.ac.uk

Sustainable and Healthy Diets: the policy problem Corinna Hawkes & Tim Lang c.hawkes@wcrf.org ; t.lang@city.ac.uk. Talk to Wellcome seminar, London, April 22-23 2-14. Context. Policy problem raised by sustainable diets is one of competing analyses . The food system is fine Right economics

avon
Télécharger la présentation

Sustainable and Healthy Diets: the policy problem Corinna Hawkes & Tim Lang c.hawkes@wcrf.org ; t.lang@city.ac.uk

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Sustainable and Healthy Diets:the policy problemCorinna Hawkes & Tim Langc.hawkes@wcrf.org; t.lang@city.ac.uk Talk to Wellcome seminar, London, April 22-23 2-14

  2. Context

  3. Policy problem raised by sustainable diets is one of competing analyses The food system is fine • Right economics • Wrong consumers • Wrong mindsets • Wrong bodies Solutions: • Change behaviour • Personalisation • Some tech fixes to increase resource efficiency / for specific food products Food system is in crisis • Physiology is fixed • Wrong environment • Wrong €$£ signals • Distorted culture Solutions: • Multiple complex acts • Population-level food policy • Reframe conditions

  4. Northern EU Govts began to engage, 2006 ff

  5. EU: supply focus on resource efficiency • UN Sustainable Consumption and Production • Marrakech process (post Rio 1992  Johannesburg 2002 CSD) http://esa.un.org/marrakechprocess/index.shtml • Focus on products / LifeCycleAnalysis (LCA) / Sustainable lifestyles • CAP slowly changing (situation normal) • Shift from paying for production to environmental goods • Climate change adaptation SEC(2009) 417: http://ec.europa.eu/agriculture/sfs/index_en.htm • EU Platform for Action on Diet, PA & Health (parallel to SCP) • focus on NCDs / Consumer information/ But weak so far on Sust’lConsumption in food; Food Information regulation (2011) / focus on ingredients not impact / years arguing Nutrition labels 4. Commercial focus on products not health: • Integrated Product Policy (IPP) focus on enviro’teg waste • http://ec.europa.eu/environment/ipp/integratedpp.htm • Focus on Carbon and Waste reduction as efficiency • Sustainable Food Consultation 2013 & Communiqué 2014: - the focus narrows (??? under pressure???)

  6. Food Co.s: product focus + choice-edit? • International companies: • 2009: G30 top TNCs initiative Coca-Cola, Tesco, Unilever • 2002: SAI launched GroupeDanone, Nestlé, Unilever • 2010: World Economic Forum process (published 2011) • 2010: Barilla Centre’s double inverted pyramid • UK companies: • 2007: IGD Food Industry Sustainability Strategy Champions Group focus on low carbon + ethics • 3 retailers’ choice-edit M&S Plan A, Co-operative Group, Waitrose • Unilever, PepsiCo brand sustainability strategies • WRAP/BRC complex metric study 2013 • VERDICT: product-specific approach not overall diet

  7. The elephant in the room: consumers • Policy attention is weak on consumers • Need to reduce consumption....not just switch it • “we can lower CO2 up to a point but in 10 years consumers will have to change” (global retailer) • Consumer change raises tricky policy problems: • Rich/poor (within LDCs and LDCs/rich societies) • Few eat ideal healthy diet, let alone sustainable diet • Price issues: are sustainable diets more expensive? • Choice culture - assumption that consumers lead • So far, there aren’t even weak policies • UN (FAO=WHO) refusal to include Sust Diet Guidelines for ICN2 • No EU sustainability food label (expressly taken out of enviro labels: white goods, yes; food, no) • No UK follow-up (yet) to Food 2030 or Green Food Project Principles

  8. Food policy and behaviour change

  9. Policy problem raised by sustainable diets is one of competing analyses The food system is fine • Right economics • Wrong consumers • Wrong mindsets • Wrong bodies Solutions: • Individual behaviour change • Personalisation • Some tech fixes to specific food products Food system is in crisis • Physiology is fixed • Wrong environment • Wrong €$£ signals • Distorted culture Solutions: • Multiple complex acts • Population-level food policy • Reframe conditions

  10. Approach of public health-oriented food policy advocates • We all want individuals to eat diets consistent with healthy weights & good health • Consumer behaviour driven by • food environment • globalisation of food systems • Big Food • We need to “protect” people – especially kids, from onslaught • We need behaviour change for the food industry - there is evidence for comprehensive marketing restrictions, warning labels, taxes, school food restrictions • Individual-level approaches do not work • Behaviour change approaches are for wimps

  11. Policy solution raised by healthy, sustainable diets is one of complementary analyses The “consumer” is part of the food system • Right Wrong economics • Wrong consumersConsumer behaviour shapes the food system but is also shaped by it • Wrong Environment is all about choice • Wrong €$£ signals both wrong and right Solutions– • Population-level food policy which aims to change (or maintain) behaviour among individuals • Understanding both food system behaviour and why consumers behave as they do • Interdisciplinary reframing

  12. 1. Food policy framework for healthy diets

  13. NOURISHINGframework – POLICY ACTIONS FOR BEHAVIOUR CHANGE AT MULTIPLE LEVELS

  14. The evidence

  15. The evidence problem • There is plenty of evidence…. • of the “problem” • that behaviour change is possible • to design effective policy solutions • But there are barriers to effective design, implementation and evaluation • Economics – cost; viability • Politics – “nanny state”; food industry • Governance – multisectoral action • “Medical” approach to evaluation - short-termism; metrics of success unclear • Perceived lack of evidence of effectiveness • Very high bar set for evidence Where is the demonstrable evidence of effects?

  16. 2. An interdisciplinary approach to linking food system behaviour with consumer behaviour A preference lens – there are genetic preferences but we we learn most of preferences & habits from our environment, culture, choice architecture etc Implications for how policy works

  17. Interdisciplinary reframing

  18. Public policy must lead: the case for Sustainable Dietary Guidelines • Provide a rational basis to the general food policy framework which is good for public and supply • Bridge the gap between NCD and CO2e discourses • Provide C21st basis for public advice + supply chain • Shift policy debate from productionist approach • Recalibrate institutions around consumer needs • This is supposed to be a consumer society but consumers are not being helped

  19. Our key points Many problems • Yawning gap between evidence and practice • Policy attention is (s)low; it rose 2007-08, then fell • Attention segmented by disciplinary foci • Consumers seen as “separate” to food and social systems • “Behaviour change” seen as “personal” not “policy” • Fear among politicians of placing ‘choice culture’ within health & environmental frameworks; consumers = voters What we need • Coherence & integration between disciplines/sectors/depts (& incentives) • Population-approach to healthy sustainable diets based on understanding of consumer behaviour and how policy works • Behaviour change at multiple levels & actors for health & sustainability • A long term view with clear shorter-term metrics to measure “what works”

  20. THANK YOU For further information contact: Dr Corinna Hawkes Head of Policy and Public Affairs, WCRF International policy@wcrf.org and c.hawkes@wcrf.org @wcrfint @corinnahawkes facebook.com/wcrfint youtube.com/wcrfint wcrf.org/blog www.wcrf.org/policy_public_affairs

More Related