1 / 8

An introduction to peer review

An introduction to peer review Research Student Generic Skills Training Programme, College of Social Science May 2012 Jo Brewis, School of Management j.brewis@le.ac.uk. An introduction to peer review. Today’s session will:

creda
Télécharger la présentation

An introduction to peer review

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. An introduction to peer review Research Student Generic Skills Training Programme, College of Social Science May 2012 Jo Brewis, School of Management j.brewis@le.ac.uk

  2. An introduction to peer review Today’s session will: emphasize the range of peer review activities in academia and the consequent importance of peer review outline the concepts and practicalities of peer review, especially as these relate to academic journal articles introduce you to Manuscript Central in this regard identify some of the key ethical issues which relate to commenting on the work of others

  3. An introduction to peer review “Peer review is the practice by which the worth of research is evaluated by those with demonstrated competence to make a judgement. It is the traditional means by which research quality is guaranteed in academic studies.” (British Academy, 2007: 1) When is peer review used? Developmentally/ ‘in-house’ Journal papers Conference papers (abstracts)/ presentations (/ discussants) Book proposals Book manuscripts Book reviews in journals Bids to providers of competitive funding (eg ESRC, EU)

  4. An introduction to peer review When is peer review used? MPhil/ PhD applications MPhil/ PhD upgrade examinations/ APG reviews MPhil/ PhD vivas Academic job applications/ interviews (including external assessors) ‘Second-order’ reviews like the REF, ERA, PBRF Post-publication commentary/ ‘reply to’ Is all academic research in part peer review? Types of peer review vary in terms of anonymity, formality and how many people are involved So it is a vital process, and there is a lot of it to do

  5. An introduction to peer review Reviewing pointers Delivering on time Awareness of the function/ status of the text Restate purpose (as you interpret it)? Start with the positive Consider the text on its own merits Does/ could it make a contribution? Does it fit within its intended home? Does it start well? Identification of key omissions or deficiencies of interpretation (conceptual and/ or empirical) Does it evidence its claims? Identification of structural weaknesses

  6. An introduction to peer review Reviewing pointers Do the data ‘speak back’ to the conceptual framework where relevant? Major and minor? Does it end well? Are implications clearly stated? Is it clearly expressed? Constructive criticism Be specific ‘Own’ your review and address the author Conformity to house style/ format where relevant Don’t reveal your actual recommendation As a discussant, avoid focusing on small points and be succinct

  7. An introduction to peer review Also remember that for journals the usual recommendations would be: accept minor revisions major revisions reject not suitable for this journal (special issues) Confidential comments to the editor NB The advent of Manuscript Central For example: http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/gwo

  8. An introduction to peer review Overall ‘do as you would be done by’ Try and ensure your advice will make the text better Make it clear (to the editor) why you have made your recommendation Some examples of how not to do it Any questions?

More Related