
How To Value Your Business Presented to the 43rd Annual Business Administration Conference NRMCA October 24,2001 New Orleans
How To Value Your Business • What is Value? “Everything is worth what its purchaser will pay for it” Publius, 1st century BC • Appraised Value • Market Value • These are two different numbers - affected by timing and the nature of the transaction • The “house next door” story
How To Value Your Business Why are Businesses Valued? • Financing • Internal sale • Divorce/Stockholder suit • Estate-planning purposes • Tax purposes • Property/Estate taxes • Loss of management • Buy-sell agreements • ESOP • Condemnation
How To Value Your Business Appraised Valuation Methods • Multiples of Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation & Amortization (EBITDA) • Discounted Free Cash Flow Method • Cost to Recreate (asset value approach) • Price per annual production yard
How To Value Your Business Appraised Valuation Methods: Multiples of EBITDA • EBITDA is defined as Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization • It defines, in any single period, the amount of cash the business generates to pay principle, interest, taxes, and capital expenditures • It is the single most reliable tool used today to measure the performance of a business
How To Value Your Business Appraised Valuation Methods: Multiples of EBITDA • What period? • Last 12 months? • Average of the last three years? • Two ways to examine EBITDA • Actual • Recast • The results will be in a high-low range
How To Value Your Business Appraised Valuation Methods: Multiples of EBITDA • Recast EBITDA will translate into these values: • 3.5 to 5 times for ready mixed and concrete products operations • 5 to 9 times aggregate operations (maybe more?)
How To Value Your Business Appraised Valuation Methods: Discounted Free Cash Flow Method • Defined as the future cash flows earned by the Company’s assets, discounted to present value • Or, “the cash that is left after all expenses to service principle and interest”.
How To Value Your Business Appraised Valuation Methods: Discounted Free Cash Flow Method Approaches: • Free Cash Flows - defined as earnings before interest and after taxes (EBIAT), plus depreciation, less capital expenditures and changes in working capital. • This is calculated over ten years...or as long as possible • Add the terminal value at the end of the projection period
How To Value Your Business Appraised Valuation Methods: Discounted Free Cash Flow Method • Results are then discounted • A discount rate range is applied, based on current market conditions (inflation rates are key) • The net numbers based on these discount rates establishes a range of values called the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (“WACC”) • This determines the total enterprise value - after deducting debt, it established the equity value to the owners.
How To Value Your Business Appraised Valuation Methods: Cost to Recreate (asset value approach) • Examine price of both new and used equipment, in place: • cost of land/cost of erection • working capital • permitting period (and impact of opportunity cost) • start-up losses • Compare to actual market value of existing assets • Not looking at appraised values (orderly/forced liquidation approaches.) Looking strictly at the market
How To Value Your Business Appraised Valuation Methods: Price Per Production Yard • All methods combined lead to a range of “appraised value” • This is compared to a rule of thumb value approach: price per annual production yard • This may range from $25 - $50
How To Value Your Business Market Valuation Methods • Always just a variation on appraisal methods, but with a much more subjective approach • Variables include: • the Purchaser’s perception of the market • the financial condition of the Seller • cost of greenfielding as an option to a purchase
How To Value Your Business Market Valuation Methods • Discounted Free Cash Flow Method -may be affected in the same ways • Value can be manipulated by the Purchaser: • steeper discount rates for calculated Net Present Value • Accelerating plant/truck demand schedules, affecting capex rates • Adjustments in projected market growth
How To Value Your Business Market Valuation Methods
How To Value Your Business Market Valuation Methods • Cost to Recreate (asset value approach) - • May only be considered as an option to “greenfielding”, in the case of a new market entrant • Often simply a comparative value analysis as a “bolt-on acquisition” in the case of an existing market player
How To Value Your Business Market Valuation Methods Other Approaches • Platform Opportunity - If the Seller is a larger player in the market, value can vary widely if the Purchaser is motivated enough to seek an entry into the market (remember the “house next door” story) • Bolt-On Acquisition - If that is the perception, value is usually less than a Platform Opportunity
How To Value Your Business Summary • There is a difference between appraisal and market value methods • Each has its own purpose and place in establishing how a business is valued • The two approaches do not always produce the same value equation, particularly in changing market conditions