220 likes | 340 Vues
Alcohol-related data collection in emergency departments: The Wirral model. Zara Quigg: Violence and TIIG Research Manager Centre for Public Health WHO Collaborating Centre for Violence Prevention. Objectives. Trauma and Injury Intelligence Group (TIIG) The Wirral Model
E N D
Alcohol-related data collection in emergency departments: The Wirral model Zara Quigg: Violence and TIIG Research Manager Centre for Public Health WHO Collaborating Centre for Violence Prevention
Objectives • Trauma and Injury Intelligence Group (TIIG) • The Wirral Model • Alcohol-related attendances • Reporting mechanisms • Interventions • Outcome • TIIG development across the North West
TIIG • Funding: local partners • Injury surveillance system • Intentional / unintentional • Informing injury prevention strategies • Brings together a variety of data sources • Focus: ED data sharing Childhood injuries Falls Violence / alcohol 4/4 5/5 12/12 6/6 4/4
ED data • Expansion of existing fields - Injury group: Fall / burns • Location: where in the home • e.g. Kitchen / stairs Existing data items • Injury group Assault, sports injury, RTC, self harm • Patient demographics Gender, age, area of residence • Date / time of attendance • Location of incident e.g. public place / home • Arrival / referral method • Disposal method (e.g. admitted) • Additional fields • Violence • Core • Time / date • Location assault (e.g. pub name) • Assault type (e.g. weapon used) • Enhanced • Relationship with attacker • Number of attackers • Gender of attackers • Reported to the police • Attacker consumed alcohol • Motive • Additional fields • Alcohol • Had you been drinking alcohol within three hours prior to the incident occurring? • Where did you consume / purchase your last drink?
The Wirral Model • ED data collection 02/03 (baseline 03/04) • PCT / CSP strategies Figure 1: Proportion of injury attendances that are alcohol-related by year, Arrowe Park ED Target: reduce alcohol-related assault attendees by 15% over three years
The Wirral Model Figure 2: Assault attendances by time and day of attendance, Arrowe Park ED 2008/09 • 40% of assault cases have been drinking • 74% between 2am and 4am weekend nights
The Wirral Model Figure 3: Proportion of attendances to Arrowe Park ED identified as alcohol-related, under 18s only by age, Arrowe Park ED, 2007/08
The Wirral Model • Two week alcohol audit • Electronic data collection identified 13 alcohol-related attendees (<18) • 1.6% of all attendees • Audit identified 5 • Female • Cider / Lambrini • Drank in street / park • Purchased from shop • 3/5 admitted to hospital Table 1: Alcohol-related attendances by demography, alcohol consumed, circumstances surrounding consumption and outcome, Arrowe Park ED
Tackling Knives Action Programme (TKAP) project to Enhance Violence Prevention through ED Data Sharing [Wirral BCU (Arrowe Park data only)]
Overview of ED Data [10/05/10 to 23/05/10]
Violence occurs in Town and City Centres yet perpetrators and victims live elsewhere Reports Assault Presentation to Accident & Emergency by Deprivation of Residence
Intervention • Development, implementation and monitoring of local alcohol and violence prevention strategies / prevention initiatives • Targeted policing and licensing enforcement • AMEC / TCVP / TKAP • Pubwatch • Best Bar None / Think 21 campaign • Targeted social marketing campaigns CCTV Licensing Street Lighting Alleygates
England match days (EMD) • 33% increase assault attendances • Saturday / Thursday • 50% • No increase during World Cup period only (accounting for EMD) Prevention Event Planning
Operation Xchange • Partnership approach • ED, police, primary care • 14th to 23rd Dec 2009 • ED data used to guide police operation • Targeted policing / licensing enforcement • Outcomes • 3 knives recovered • 21% reduction in wounding offences within the city centre • 57% reduction in ED assault attendances
Prevention Marketing Campaigns
Licensing Act and Alcohol Misuse Enforcement Campaign AMEC 2005/06 Rate of assault attendances/week 2002/03 2003/04 2004/05 2005/06 Financial Year Non-AMEC weeks AMEC weeks for 2005/06 Evaluation
Arrowe Park, Wirral: 03/04 - 09/10 03/04 = 3,299 / 1,485 09/10 = 2,035 / 975 (38% / 34% reduction) Est. £40,800 saved (PCT) through reduction in ED alcohol-related assault attendances Est. £24,000 saved (provider) through reduction in alcohol-related assault admissions Trends
North West data collection / sharing Number of EDs collecting and sharing alcohol and violence data with TIIG, by area
Contact details For and more information please contact: Zara Quigg, Violence and TIIG Research Manager 0151 231 4359, z.a.anderson@ljmu.ac.uk www.tiig.info Centre For Public Health Liverpool John Moores University WHO Collaborating Centre for Violence Prevention 5th Floor, Kingsway House, Hatton Garden, Liverpool, L3 2AY