90 likes | 188 Vues
This paper analyzes reasons for the GB Queue issues, discussing incentives, system upgrades, and market rules, proposing solutions and sparking further discussion on necessary actions.
E N D
The GB Queue – Problems and possible solutions Mark Copley
Purpose • To provide background to the GB Queue • To discuss the reasons for the queue • To assess the undesirable incentives that may exist • To question whether proposals on the table will address any of these incentives • To prompt discussion on what else needs to be done
The Queue • NGET issued 13.2GW of offers • To over 165 projects • A series of sequential reinforcements are needed • Connection is not possible in some locations until 2016 and beyond
The problem – At a high level • Unprecedented demand for network capacity in areas of the system with relatively little transmission. • Need for significant system upgrades before this generation can connect • Upgrades take time to receive planning consents and be completed • Offers were made on a first come first served basis which doesn’t reflect the viability of projects • Significant risk that efficient projects cannot connect • Risk that transmission licensees invest inefficiently.
The causes – In more detail • Poor information for transmission licensees • No information from existing parties • A place in the queue is frequently a costless option • Inability for the most viable projects to identify themselves • Either by trading with existing parties, • Buying a less firm/ restricted right style access product, • Advancing their connection date if capacity becomes available
The causes (2) • Inflexible market rules • Arrangements do not promote flexibility. Incentive not to reveal information as it’ll lead to a new offer with a post 2016 connection date. • An overly lenient approach to managing contracts? • Should NGET take a more hands-on role in managing contracts? • Increasing volumes of distributed generation? • Is there a discrepancy in treatment?
Questions for discussion • Have we correctly characterised the problems? • Are any recent developments likely to address them? • Are there any other issues to address? • What role should Ofgem/ transmission licensees/ industry play in this process?
Promoting choice and value for all gas and electricity customers