1 / 11

AfE Project Site Visits

AfE Project Site Visits. Current state, and future direction ... Amit Sharma Asha SV. Motivations. Assess the project and the organization Collect meaningful, quantitative, data Opportunity of understand subjective, qualitative, aspects of the project

galena-hull
Télécharger la présentation

AfE Project Site Visits

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. AfE Project Site Visits Current state, and future direction ... Amit Sharma Asha SV Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  2. Motivations • Assess the project and the organization • Collect meaningful, quantitative, data • Opportunity of understand subjective, qualitative, aspects of the project • To Verify or To Validate? Or Both? … Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  3. Current state of affairs • Site visits are prerequisite for new/renewal requests • Well enforced policy driven by projects/treasury team(s) • Mostly to verify the state of the project/organization • Projects are chapter approved post factum • Volunteer bottleneck • Not enough volunteers to conduct site visits • Coordination bottleneck • Which project needs site visit and when? Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  4. Afterthought … • We have general recommendations for site visits • Recommendations not guidelines! • http://www.ashanet.org/seattle/resources/general/sitevisitguide.htm • Do we differentiate between new project vs. renewal site visit evaluation? • Gauging organizational competency [for new projects] • Gauge project progress and impact [for renewals] • Limited or no mechanics to co-relate the project evaluation by funding chapter with the site visit assessment [?] Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  5. Afterthought … • Site visit is a learning mechanism in addition to being a funding requirement • Do we have sufficient measurable parameters for site visits? • Specialize the recommendations • Qualitative concerns/questions can be best addressed with a site visit • Do we document enough to guide the site visit? Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  6. Recommendations • Project steward with the chapter should define evaluation parameters for the project • recommendation is to create ~5 top assessment questions that the project would be measured against • Encourage NGO to participate in coming up with the evaluation questionnaire with the steward [and the chapter] • We should encourage the NGO to complete the self-assessment at the end of the funding cycle • Site visit volunteer should independently seek answers for the evaluations questions • Allows NGO to self evaluate and AfE to evaluate the project against common agreed measurement set which is not quantitatively restricted Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  7. Recommendations • Add the evaluation section to the proposals template • Should be completed at the time of approval • Should be added to the checklist requirement • Assessment questionnaire must be created afresh at the renewal and should be appended to the proposal document OR • Add a separate evaluation document for all new project • All the same rules above apply • A single chronological assessment document that captures perspective of both the NGO partner and Asha • Evaluation questionnaire should exist in-addendum to the existing project evaluation/approval process Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  8. Recommendations • Maintain a report of projects requiring site visit • Projects in need of site visit should be entered into the spreadsheet • Projects Coord team can coordinate with Asha-India to schedule site visits • We need to make timelines more realistic for Asha-India to conduct site visits • create a queue of site-visit requirements! • Complimentary to spreadsheet of volunteers available for site visits [Seattle is driving this?] Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  9. Recommendations • Eventually the renewal and site visit requests should come from the projects DB • Site Visit dates and approval dates should be explicitly recorded and reportable • Site Visit bottlenecks tend to negatively impact our SLA! • Spreadsheet is complementary to the Projects DB Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  10. Future Directions … • Asha Saathi • Asha-India is severely strained of volunteers who can conduct site visit • A handful of experienced Asha-India volunteers conduct most of the site visits • Asha Saathi proposal has been in the docks for a while and needs to be re-visited • Dedicated set of people for project monitoring, assessment, and evaluation • Some chapters have contemplated engaging with paid project evaluations separately • Ashawide discussion required! Asha West Coast Conference 2008

  11. Questions? Thank You! Asha West Coast Conference 2008

More Related