80 likes | 221 Vues
This document outlines the key outcomes from the ALMA-WIDAR face-to-face meeting that took place on December 11-12, 2007. The meeting focused on joint data formats and included discussions on formal agreements, version control, and project responsibilities. Key topics included the BDF, CalDM, SDM, and PDM formats, all incorporating XML schemas and UML through MagicDraw. The team is poised for reviews in early 2008, with hopes for a formal version release by April. Overall, positive impressions emerged around collaboration, though some concerns about project prioritization and documentation quality were noted.
E N D
Interactions with ALMA Michael P. Rupen WIDAR Face-to-Face Meeting December 11-12, 2007
Joint Data Formats • Formal agreement almost finished (this week?) • Joint definition documents for BDF, CalDM, SDM, PDM (including XML schema or UML) • Under version control • Telescope-specific items called out explicitly • UML through MagicDraw • ALMA will produced typed, valid XML schema from UML: Q1 2008 for SDM, CalDM • One author from each project, responsible for the project details WIDAR Face-to-Face Meeting December 11-12, 2007
Joint Data Formats • BDF: Pokorny/Pisano • Currently sent to ALMA for comments (this week or next) • Joint review by Feb08 • Version 1.0 by Apr08 (?) • CalDM: Rupen/Lucas • EVLA revision in Jan08 • Joint review in Mar08 • Version 1.0 by May08 WIDAR Face-to-Face Meeting December 11-12, 2007
Joint Data Formats • SDM: Rupen/Viallefond • Initial version from ALMA: Apr08 ??? • EVLA revisions: May08 ??? • Joint review: Jun08 • Version 1.0: Sep08 • PDM: Butler/Bridger • Initial joint version: Apr08 • ALMA & EVLA revisions: Jun08 • Version 1.0: Sep08 WIDAR Face-to-Face Meeting December 11-12, 2007
Joint Version Control • ALMA FBT in progress • EVLA representative: Moeser • Supposed to have an initial proposal this month WIDAR Face-to-Face Meeting December 11-12, 2007
Impressions • Individuals are wonderful • Receptive • Responsive • Interested • Very good working relationship currently • Lucas, Glendenning, Viallefond, Pisano, Raffi, … WIDAR Face-to-Face Meeting December 11-12, 2007
Impressions • Still some concerns • Slippage continues -- we are not the top priority (e.g., Viallefond recently) • SDM is s l o w • WIDAR slippage is known and can lead to problems • E.g., PTC WIDAR Face-to-Face Meeting December 11-12, 2007
Impressions • Requires a LOT of work on our side • Documentation is generally a mess • We wind up effectively doing some of their work, to match our timescales • Cf. Martin P. and the BDF WIDAR Face-to-Face Meeting December 11-12, 2007