300 likes | 511 Vues
Activity 1. Take a cardFind the answer to the algorithm/problem(if you need a calculator move on)Create a question using the algorithm/problem. Purpose of the activity. Where any of the algorithms DIFFICULT?Would you expect your students to be able to do these?All from NAPLAN 2009 ? Did you r
 
                
                E N D
1. NAPLAN Numeracy 2009 Presented by
Bob Wellham
K-12 Mathematics Consultant, Swansea 
2. Activity 1 Take a card
Find the answer to the algorithm/problem
		(if you need a calculator move on)
Create a question using the algorithm/problem 
3. Purpose of the activity Where any of the algorithms DIFFICULT?
Would you expect your students to be able to do these?
All from NAPLAN 2009  Did you recognise them?
Why are they different?
 
4. Newmans Error Analysis Reading
    Can students read the words of the problem?
Comprehension
    Can students understand the meaning?
Transformation
    Can students determine a way to solve the problem?
Process Skills
    Can students do the mathematics?
Encoding
    Can students record and interpret their answer? 
5. Newmans Prompts Read the question.                read
What does it mean?              mean
What will I do to solve it?      do
Do the maths.                      maths
Write the answer.               answer
 
6. Common Practice Research carried out in Australia and Southeast Asia suggests that about 60% of students errors in responding to written numeracy questions occur before students reach the process and encoding skills level. (i.e. before Newman steps 4 & 5)
However 80% of remediation programs and common teaching practice is to focus students on revision of process skills. (Newman step 4) 
7. National Numeracy Review Report (2008) From the earliest years, greater emphasis needs to be given to providing students with 
frequent exposure to higher-level mathematical problems
rather than routine procedural tasks,
in contexts of relevance to them,
with increased opportunities for students to 
discuss alternative solutions
 and explain their thinking. 
8. What does this mean for us? If we continue to remediate ONLY algorithms (like the Activity 1 questions) there is little chance of student outcomes improving. 
9. So what do we do? Help students to 
		- read the questions
		- comprehend what they read
		- provide strategies that aid 			understanding
		- teach students to answer multiple 		choice questions  many guess 		or are mislead. 
10. How can we do this? Focus on worded problems
Increase the metalanguage used
Get students explaining how 			they get answers
Scaffold strategies
Assessment for learning
Explicit teaching of concepts 
11. Explicit teachingof mathematical terms & symbols Students need to say new words as well as hear and see them.
How do you verbalise 7- 5?
				7 minus 5 
	7 take away 5 
				take 5 from 7
  from 7 take 5
				subtract 5 from 7
 
12. Understanding the vocabulary Words that are only used in mathematics 
			eg. parallelogram
Words that have the same meaning in mathematics as in everyday language 		eg. equal
Words that have a different meaning in mathematics as in everyday language eg. volume 
13. Significance of context and positional terms in mathematics Instead of concentrating on key words, students need to look at the words in the context of the whole problem.
Five is how many more than three?
Five is three more than which number? 
Which number is three more than five?
Prepositions can change meaning and the choice of process-
What is half of 4? 		Four is half of what ?
Increase by 7, 	Increase from 7, 	Increase to 7 
14. Consider literacy strategies HERE  require literal comprehension of directly stated information 
          reading ON the lines
 HIDDEN  require interpretation of information 
          reading BETWEEN the lines
 HEAD  require inferences to be made and 
    information to be evaluated and applied
	      reading BEYOND the lines
 
15. A lack of concept knowledge An 11 year-old student explained this approach to solving written questions in numeracy: 
"Problem solving is easy. 
If there are more than two numbers, I always add; 
otherwise, I subtract. 
If I'm not sure if it's multiplication or division, I divide and, 
if there is a remainder, I multiply instead" 
							(Hope, 1987, p. 57).
 
16. Another light moment !!! 
17. Assessment for learning Mathematics is sequential  learnt work is the building blocks of new learning.
Find out what students know and program the learning to the next level. 
18. Using SMART data SMART data is a great tool to analyse where to start.
Using Item Analysis you can find where your students differ most from the state  this is usually a good starting point. 
19. Who is best to analyse the NAPLAN data? The teachers.
What should they look for?
Strengths & weaknesses
Individual performances
Find out what students know
Find out what has to be taught
Are the NAPLAN results a true indication
If NOT why?...... It is not the test, it is consistent acros the state, so it gives a good yard stick 
20. From my superficial analysis of schools in this Region Year 7 
-  Fractions, Decimals & Percentages
Patterns & Algebra  Number patterns
Measurement  Area
Space & Geometry  scale, Edges on 3D 					object, protractor.
Year 9
- Fractions, Decimals & Percentages
- Patterns & Algebra  Algebraic Techniques
 
21. Year 7 Number Patterns 
	- C8, C12, C24, C27, NC8, NC10 & NC13
Fractions, Decimals & Percentages
	- C19, C31 & NC30
Measurement
	- NC9 
Space & Geometry
	- C5, C13 & NC21 
22. Year 9 Algebraic Techniques
	- C19, C21, C24, NC20, NC30 & NC22
Fractions, decimals & percentages
	- C9, C12, C15, C29, NC14, NC17, NC27 & NC29
Measurement
	- C17, NC6 & NC8 
23. Tape Diagrams Students draw a tape to support their thinking during problem solving 
24. To get to work, I travelled on the train for 24 minutes and I walked for 7 minutes. How long did it take me to get to work?
 This is how a student represented the problem using a tape diagram.
Points to note:
Tape diagram enables us to represent all the relevant information
It is only a diagram to help us visualise the transformation of the problem, so being precisely accurate is not necessary
As a means of organising, I like to place above the tape information about the whole tape and below it information about its partsThis is how a student represented the problem using a tape diagram.
Points to note:
Tape diagram enables us to represent all the relevant information
It is only a diagram to help us visualise the transformation of the problem, so being precisely accurate is not necessary
As a means of organising, I like to place above the tape information about the whole tape and below it information about its parts 
25. There were some oranges in a box. Because we bought 14 more oranges, there are now 21 oranges in the box altogether. How many oranges were in the box at first?
 Reveal There were some.
Task Draw a tape diagram for this problem.
Reveal diagram. 
This is how a student represented the problem using a tape diagram. Questions where the answer is not the largest number create particular problems for many students.
Reveal There were some.
Task Draw a tape diagram for this problem.
Reveal diagram. 
This is how a student represented the problem using a tape diagram. Questions where the answer is not the largest number create particular problems for many students.
 
26. Questions where you could use Tape Diagrams in NAPLAN 2009 Year 7
			C17, C18, C31, NC18		
Year 9
			C15, C29, NC4, NC17, NC27
Remember, this is a process that can be applied in a variety of questions 
					 NOT just NAPLAN 
27. Multiple Choice Questions 
28. Multiple Choice Questions Worksheets adapted from website
www.thinkingblocks.com  
29. More information or assistance? Articles
Nine Ways to Catch Kids Up.
Singapore Math: Simple or Complex?
Learning from Singapore Math. 
	pdf copies of these can be found at 					www.hccweb2.org/bobsblog 
 as well as a copy of this PowerPoint
Email ME    robert.wellham@det.nsw.edu.au