1 / 53

The Federal Judiciary and Civil Liberties and Civil Rights

The Federal Judiciary and Civil Liberties and Civil Rights. The Federal Court System. Role(s) of the Court in making policy Interpretation of laws & Constitution Extension of laws Designing remedies (how to fix problem). Judicial Review. Power to decide constitutionality

jonah
Télécharger la présentation

The Federal Judiciary and Civil Liberties and Civil Rights

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The Federal Judiciary and Civil Liberties and Civil Rights

  2. The Federal Court System • Role(s) of the Court in making policy • Interpretation of laws & Constitution • Extension of laws • Designing remedies (how to fix problem)

  3. Judicial Review • Power to decide constitutionality • Main judicial power in checks and balances • Marbury v. Madision

  4. Two views on application of judicial review • “strict constructionists” conservatives • Limited role of the Court in policy-making • Don’t like “interpretation” of Constitution • “activists” “legislativists” liberals • Courts role is to interpret the Constitution • Use their own experiences to make policy

  5. Selection of Judges/Justices • Appointment by President • Confirmation by Senate • “Senatorial Courtesy” • “Litmus Test”

  6. Jurisdiction of Federal Courts • Dual Court System (State and Federal) • Federal jurisdiction is in Article 3 and 11th Amendment • Supreme Court of the US: • Original Jurisdiction: • Diversity Cases (2+ States) • US v. State(s) • Reps of Foreign Gov’t v. US • States v. Citizen of other State • Appellate Jurisdiction: any case may be appealed from lower federal Court or State Supreme Court

  7. US Courts of Appeals • Only appellate jurisdiction • Hears cases from: • District Courts • Regulatory Agencies (OSHA, EPA, etc…) • Courts Martial • Etc…

  8. US District Courts • Only original jurisdiction • Federal crimes • Civil suits under federal law • Diversity of Citizenship cases (50,000+ per year) • Admiralty and Maritime Cases • Bankruptcy Cases • Actions of Administrative Agencies (IRS, Social Security, etc…)

  9. State cases that can be appealed to Federal Courts • Constitutional Questions • Death Penalty • Law Suits • Etc…

  10. Getting your case to the Supreme Court of the US • Court rejects 90-95% of applications for Writ of Certiorari • Costs of Appeal is high • In forma Pauperis • ACLU • Fee Shifting • Interest Group assistance (NRA, LULAC, NAACP, etc…) https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#inbox/15f9861bc89009c3?projector=1

  11. Standing • To have standing; must have real controversy with real adversaries • Must demonstrate actual harm/damages • Being a taxpayer is not enough to being a suit • Government has “sovereign immunity”

  12. Class Action Suits • Brought on behalf of all those who have same issue • Silicone breast implants • Firestone Tires • Asbestos • Etc… • Financially attractive to lawyers (million of “winners” rather than just one) • Every member of the “class” must be notified so they can participate in the suit if they wish

  13. The Supreme Court in Action • Most cases come of writs of cert • Rule of Four • Briefs submitted and studied • Oral Arguments: 30 minutes per side; 10 minutes for rebuttal • Judicial Conference; chief Justice polls members of the Court; case decided • Chief Justice assigns one of the Majority to write the Opinion of the Court • Majority Opinion (per curium– no author) • Concurring Opinion • Dissenting Opinion

  14. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VbvbTztDoho&feature=youtu.be

  15. Checks on the Judiciary • Public Opinion (limited) • President: nomination of judges/justices • No power to enforce rulings • Congress • Confirmation • Impeachment • Changing # on the Court(S) • Revising legislation declared unconstitutional • Changing jurisdiction of a Court (not Supremes) • Proposing Constitutional Amendment

  16. Protecting the Liberties of the Individual • Purpose of the Bill of Rights was to protect the individual by limiting the power of the federal government • Original constitution has few protections: • Habeas Corpus • No Bill of Attainder or Ex Post Facto Laws • Privileges and Immunities Clause • Full Faith and Credit Cause • Definition of Treason

  17. Bill of Rights Protects: • Personal Liberties: 1st Amendment • Personal Security: Amendments 2-4 • Rights of the Accused: Amendment 5-8 • Was not intended to restrict States • Incorporation to the States (except 7th amendment) through 14th Amendment’s Due Process Clause • Selective Incorporation

  18. Freedom of ExpressionSpeech, Press, Assembly, and Petition • Written, spoken, and symbolic • Purpose of 1st amendment is to protect unpopular speech/expression • Blackstone: no prior restraint, but can arrest for any “unpleasant” or “seditious” expression • 1917-1919: Congress outlaws any “expression advocating treason, insurrection, or forcible resistance to federal law”. • 1919 : US v. Schenck: “Clear and Present Danger” Rule used to balance freedom and national security. “Cry fire in a crowded theater”

  19. Expression • 1925: Gitlow v. NY: 14th amendment’s due process clause makes free speech apply to the States (Incorporation) • 1957: “Calculated to Incite” violence Test • 1969: Brandenburg v. Hayes: “Imminent Unlawful Act” Test • 1977: Nazi’s plan march in Skokie, IL. State outlaws. Nazi’s win in Court. Can’t prevent expression because you don’t like their political views

  20. Court Standards on Expression • Preferred Position: speech always most important • Prior Restraint: illegal • Imminent Danger: going to happen NOW! • Neutrality: all laws must treat all groups equally; can’t discriminate • Clarity: all laws must be understandable by the average person • Least Restrictive Means: gov’t regulation has to be as limited as possible in its interference with expression

  21. Not all expressions are legal: • Libel: false and damaging written expression • Slander: false and damaging verbal expression • Obscenity: Miller v. California; 3 part test! • False Advertising • Some symbolic expressions • Hate speech? • Etc…

  22. Freedom of Religion • Establishment Clause: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion” • 1789: no national religion • Jefferson: “created a wall of separation between Church and State” • Supreme Court has generally ruled in favor of the “wall”

  23. Supreme Court and Free Exercise • School Prayer : Unconstitutional! • Engle v. Vitale • Murray v. Curlette • Wallace v. Jaffree • Santa Fe v. Doe

  24. Legal School Prayer Guidelines • Must be student –initiated • Must be student –led • Must be open to all faiths • Must be non-disruptive of the educational process • Cannot be school sponsored • No adults may participate vocally!

  25. Released Time • Zorach v. Clauson • Students may be excused from class to attend required religious instruction or services • Religious instruction/services may not be held on campus • Students may not be punished for religious requirements

  26. State Aid to Religious Schools • Lemon v. Kurtzman “Lemon Test” or Child Benefit Test • States may provide aid to private schools as long as the aid neither promotes nor inhibits the religion and is of benefit to the child • Free lunch • School buses • Textbooks • Tax credits for tuition, uniforms, etc…

  27. Lemon Test • Secular Purpose • Neutral purpose (neither advances nor inhibits the religion) • No excessive entanglement

  28. The Court has allowed: • Nativity Scenes • House/Senate prayers • Military Chaplains • “In God We Trust” on $ • God in Pledge • God in Oath of Office • God in Oath in Court • Etc…

  29. Free Exercise Clause • “Congress shall make no law… prohibiting the free exercise of religion” • Meaning: You can believe anything you want! • No government interference in beliefs • Government may make reasonable restrictions on religious action to protect the health, safety, morals, and welfare of the community

  30. Free Exercise Clause • Religion is not an excuse for violating the laws of the US or of the States • Cases: • Conscientious Objection for Draft • Refusal to work on Sabbath • Unemployment Compensation • Compulsory Education Laws • Pledge of Allegiance • Snake Handling • Drug Use in Religious Ceremony • Medical Care • Blue Laws • Animal Sacrifice • Nudity • Etc…

  31. Right to Keep and Bear Arms • Two schools of thought: • Guarantee of individual right to own/possess • Guarantee that each State will have an armed militia for defense • Supreme Court has generally agreed w/ 2nd

  32. Cases • McDonald v. Chicago States • DC v. Heller Incorporation • 2nd Amendment protects individual right to have a handgun in the home for personal protection

  33. Texas Handgun Law • Possession of a handgun on or about your person in public is illegal • Ownership of a handgun is restricted (21+) • Permit to Carry • Game Wardens and Law Enforcement Officers are exempt from THGL

  34. 4th Amendment A legal search usually requires: 1. Probable Cause (reasonable suspicion) 2. Warrant (court order)

  35. Requirements for a Warrant • Probable Cause • Affidavit • Judge’s Signature • List of what is to be searched/seized (specific in scope) • Served in valid manner

  36. The Exclusionary Rule • Prohibits the use of illegally obtained evidence in criminal court • Weeks v. US (federal) • Mapp v. Ohio (States- incorporation case) • Exceptions: • Good Faith • Inevitable Discovery • Honest Mistake • Police questioning of juveniles • Over-riding considerations of public safety (terrorism!)

  37. Legal Warrantless Searches • Hot Pursuit • Plain View • Moveable Crime Scene • Emergency Search • Garbage • Inventory • Sobriety/Insurance Checkpoint • Airport Searches • Border Crossings • Student Searches • Nervousness/run from police • Consent • ETC…

  38. Due Process of Law (5th/14th Amendments) • Government may only take one’s life,, liberty, or property after following the correct rules, laws, and procedures • Procedural • Substantive • 5th: Federal • 14th: States (incorporation)

  39. Right to Privacy • Justice Brandeis defined it as “ the right to be left alone” • An implied right • Derived from • 1st Amendment’s freedom of religion • 3rd Amendment’s prohibition to quartering • 4th Amendment’s protection from unreasonable searches/seizures • 5th Amendment’s protections of private property • 9th Amendment’s unenumerated rights

  40. Privacy Cases • Griswold v. Connecticut, 1965 • Roe v. Wade, 1973 • Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 1992 • Loving v. Virginia 1961 • Obergfell v. Hodges 2015

  41. PrivacyIssues • Issues of Importance: • Birth Control • Abortion • Marriage • Medical Treatment/Information • Employee/Student Drug Testing • Wiretaps • Trespass • Invasion of Privacy/sale of personal information • Photography without consent (publication) • Electronic Data Collection • Etc…

  42. Rights of the Accused • Grand Jury Indictment for major felonies is required • Right to be informed of the charges • Plead the 5th: don’t have to self-incriminate • Miranda v. Arizona • Miranda Rights • Applies only to verbal testimony and confession

  43. Miranda Rights

  44. Rights of the Accused • Right to Counsel • Gideon v. Wainwright • Escobedo v. Illinois • Right to Compel Witnesses to Testify • Right to Confront Witnesses • Due Process of Law • Speedy Trial • Public Trial • Impartial Jury of Peers • No Excessive Bail • No Cruel and Unusual Punishments • Right to Appeal

  45. Death Penalty • Not considered cruel and unusual punishment as long as State follow guideline • Can only be given if convicted of Capital Murder • Two step trial • Immediate Appeal to States’ highest court required • Cannot be given death penalty if: • Were under 18 when crime was committed • Are currently insane • Were insane when the crime was committed • Are mentally retarded or incapacitated

More Related