210 likes | 330 Vues
Date/Time Representation In Support Of Intelligence Analysis. David M. Cassel Sarah M. Taylor, PhD Gary J. Katz Lois C. Childs Raymond D. Rimey, PhD Lockheed Martin, IS&S Research Engineering. Outline. How timelines help analysts Requirements for Timelines Lockheed Martin’s research
E N D
Date/Time Representation In Support Of Intelligence Analysis David M. Cassel Sarah M. Taylor, PhD Gary J. Katz Lois C. Childs Raymond D. Rimey, PhD Lockheed Martin, IS&S Research Engineering
Outline • How timelines help analysts • Requirements for Timelines • Lockheed Martin’s research • Dachselt & Weiland critiques of standard timelines
How do timelines help analysis? • Timelines provide ordering and temporal context • Make it easier to see conflicts: • “On March 15th (2001 understood from previous context), Mr. Jones left London for Kabul, beginning a trip of several months to countries in South Asia and the Arabian Peninsula.” • “Mr. Smith arrived in London in 2000, establishing a close working relationship with Mr. Jones there during the late spring of the following year.”
Timeline Requirements • Represent various kinds of time expressions (absolute, relative, fuzzy, set) • Reflect ordering and spacing of events • Represent different levels of precision • Represent reliability of information sources • Be able to scale • Maintain user orientation during navigation
Aspect 1: Smooth Zooming • View changes slowly to allow continuity • Hash marks change with zoom level
Aspect 2: Fuzzy Dates and Times • “April ’98” • “until about September 2000”
Aspect 2: Fuzzy Times (continued) <timex val=“2006-06-01T20:15”> 8:15 tonight </timex> <timex2 set=“YES” val=“2006-05-WXX-4> Thursdays in <timex2 val=“2006-05”> May </timex2> </timex2> <timex2 val=“P3SU” anchor_dir=“BEFORE” anchor_val=“2006-06-01”> the past three summers </timex>
Aspect 3: Abstraction • Present different levels of detail • Reflect underlying information
Aspect 4: Context Bar • Shows temporal context • Thumb for slide, resize • Lines within bar
Aspect 5: Stacked Timelines • Shows patterns over time • Visually find approximate patterns • Based on • Week • Month • Year • User defined
Problems with traditional timelines • Dachselt & Weiland identified 6 problems with traditional timelines • Views are discrete and fixed, thus they are bound to one specific [level of detail] and have a static size. • High-level views hide too much data, whereas detailed views suffer from lack of context and orientation. • Scalability, e.g. for mobile devices is not supported.
Problems (continued) • Missing support for zooming lenses, i.e. high-detail views or focus areas within a coarser time view. • Requirement of additional cognitive efforts for reinterpretation and orientation due to missing smooth transition between views. • Display of absolute time is missing, i.e. scroll-bar based views (e.g. in e-mail applications) only show relative position within the collection.
Conclusion • Timelines are helpful for intelligence analysis • But there is room to improve prior tools • We have laid out the features we are developing and shown them to address Dachselt & Weiland’s criteria Thanks for listening! Questions?
References • Dachselt, R.; Weiland, M.:TimeZoom: A Flexible Detail and Context Timeline; Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI 2006) Extended Abstracts, April 22-27, 2006, Montréal (Québec, Canada), pp. 682-687 Dachselt & Weiland’s paper • ACE2005: http://www.nist.gov/speech/tests/ace/ace05/doc/ace05eval_official_results_20060110.htm • TERN 2004: http://timex2.mitre.org/tern.html • Ferro, Lisa. 2004. TIDES: 2003 Standard for the Annotation of Temporal Expressions. http://timex2.mitre.org/annotation_guidelines/2003_timex2_standard_v1_3.pdf
InXight Time Wall • Display: Icons, text • Lanes for multiple timelines • No manipulation of data • Overlapping events are visually blocked • Points in time only http://www.inxight.com/products/sdks/tw/features.php
TildenWoods Centrifuge • Display: text, colored bars • Modes: • Absolute duration • Relative duration • Point in time • Can present multiple timelines • One layer of depth • Must change underlying table http://www.tildenwoods.com/
Visual Analytics VisuaLinks • Display: icons, text • Can compare timelines • Points only • Change database to add/modify material • Icons merged for same type/same time http://www.visualanalytics.com/products/visuaLinks/index.cfm
PNNL ThemeRiver http://www.pnl.gov/infoviz/technologies.html#themeriver
I2 Analyst Notebook • Display: icons, text, links • Not specifically a timeline tool • Does not show time scale, duration http://www.i2.co.uk/Products/Analysts_Notebook/
TimeZoom • Smooth zooming • Good focus feature http://www-mmt.inf.tu-dresden.de/Projekte/Publikationen/details/0604.pdf