1 / 19

Engagement and Frustration in Programming Projects

Engagement and Frustration in Programming Projects. Stuart Hansen Erica Eddy UW - Parkside. The Problem. Attracting and retaining quality students in Computer Science is an ongoing struggle Lots of potential reasons Bad press

orli
Télécharger la présentation

Engagement and Frustration in Programming Projects

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Engagement and Frustration in Programming Projects Stuart Hansen Erica Eddy UW - Parkside

  2. The Problem • Attracting and retaining quality students in Computer Science is an ongoing struggle • Lots of potential reasons • Bad press • The current generation expects something different (games, GUIs,???) • We work our students harder than many majors • CS actually requires math skills

  3. Programming is at the heart of what we do “… a strong correlation exists between programming ability and other computing skills, reflecting, as it does, skills in abstraction, conceptualization, design and evaluation.” McGettrick, et al., Grand Challenges in Computing: Education-A Summary

  4. We want our students to like programming • We want them to find programming fun and challenging (engaging). • We don’t want them to be overly frustrated by our programming assignments.

  5. Frustration is Endemic to Computing • My mother calls me up to get help sending an email message to me • I still struggle with … • We do not want to completely remove frustration from programming, just keep it under control

  6. What Do We Know?Not much • Margolis and Fisher discuss the relationship between confidence and interest by women studying CS. • Nifty assignments taps decades of expertise to decide what is a good assignment. • No studies found addressing our particular concern.

  7. Our Solution: Ask the students • Our intention is primarily formative • How to improve our assignments • Smaller 4 year campus • About 80 majors • Our student population is • 66% First generation college • 40% Lowest two quintiles of family income • 64% Receive financial aid

  8. The Survey • Semester long research project • Administered to CS1, CS2 and Algorithms • Given during class on due date of each assignment

  9. The Survey • Keep it short • Rank engagement on a scale of 1-10 • Rank frustration on a scale of 1-10 • Give opportunity for more extensive feedback • What would make the project more engaging? • What was the cause of the frustration?

  10. Frustration Causes What did you find most frustrating about the assignment (circle one answer)? • Understanding what was required by the assignment • Java language syntax and semantics • Required knowledge not yet covered in class • Designing the classes and methods • Working with the program development tools, e.g., BlueJ, netBeans, or emacs • Working with Linux • Other (please write a short description):

  11. Summary Statistics n = the total number of surveys collected

  12. Differences Among Courses • In more advanced courses students are more engaged by the projects (a = 0.01) • While it appears that more advanced students are more frustrated, too, this is not statistically significant • Clear shift in reasons for frustration • From Java to assignment requirements to designing classes and methods

  13. Scatterplot of Data Points

  14. The Outliers • First CS1 Assignment • - Type in this code, compile and run B. Frustrated to the point of not being engaged - CS1 String project - Algorithms project with bad data set

  15. The Outliers - continued C. CS2 Expression Trees Project - involved binary trees, recursion and polymorphism - still engaging, 7.42 is only slightly less than CS2 mean

  16. The Outliers - continued D. Most Engaging - Huffman encoding - Depth first Sudoku solver - Monte Carlo poker simulator - What makes them engaging? classic CS? real world problems?

  17. The Outliers - continued E. Fun and not frustrating - Use the ACM Graphics Library to draw a scene - Array based polynomials - both early in the semester projects

  18. Conclusions • CS is engaging • Students enjoy a challenge, but challenges also imply some frustration • Recognize our bad projects • Manage frustration and engagement incrementally • Students appreciate the chance to give feedback

  19. Questions?

More Related