Download
can medicare uncouple from the health spending gravy train n.
Skip this Video
Loading SlideShow in 5 Seconds..
Can Medicare Uncouple from the Health Spending Gravy Train? PowerPoint Presentation
Download Presentation
Can Medicare Uncouple from the Health Spending Gravy Train?

Can Medicare Uncouple from the Health Spending Gravy Train?

87 Vues Download Presentation
Télécharger la présentation

Can Medicare Uncouple from the Health Spending Gravy Train?

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - E N D - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Presentation Transcript

  1. Can Medicare Uncouple from the Health Spending Gravy Train? Mark Pauly Comments on Trustees’ Report June 3, 2013

  2. Trends and breaks • For as far back as we have data medical care spending (not “cost”) has grown faster than almost any other economic aggregate, with only a few blips at times of health reform debates. • Medicare spending growth is a little below but linked to private and total (versus Medicaid). • It is the growth in Medicare spending per enrolled that is the problem, not aging or numbers. • Can the link of overall spending to time, and of Medicare to private spending be broken?

  3. From ALTARUM INSTITUTE Labor Brief #13-02: January 2013 Data, p. 1.

  4. From ALTARUM INSTITUTE Labor Brief #13-02: January 2013 Data, p. 2.

  5. The crucial unknowns • Price growth may be making up the difference between employment and spending growth in the recession, though data on this is mixed and best bet is 50-50 between price (as measured by medical CPI) and “use.” Has price growth fallen? • May be growth in non-(direct)-labor component—machines and pills? • Or something else?

  6. The 2013 Trustees Report (from a non-insider) • Part A looks better; the key is lower growth in spending per beneficiary (though MA is dicey). • Part B still roaring ahead, share of GDP to double. • Overall share will do about the same so it is still not whether but when the tax burden doubles. • Which all depends on the path of future spending.

  7. Some theories of spending growth

  8. Other empirical regularities • Medical care “cost” per unit is not like the cost of oil; within broad limits it can be whatever we want. • Spending growth is largely driven by beneficial but costly new technology and excess growth in “prices” (really wages). • No proven model of either of these. • Other cost containment devices are intrinsically “one time”—but maybe not.

  9. Thinking about spending growth in two parts • What determines the desired rate of spending growth (for individuals, private sector, public sector)? When does this change? • How is the system configured or reconfigured to achieve what is desired (tactics)?

  10. Endogenous Tactics (not sustainable on their own) • Higher cost sharing (or more uninsured) • Removal of “waste” • Predetermined payment: “Here is all the money you can have (per person per year, per illness). Do the best you can!” • Only the last one is more than “one shot.”

  11. A grab bag of theories on desired spending growth • Driven by growth in real income (Fuchs) • Driven by technological discoveries (Hall/Jones) • Public (not private) spending driven by excess burden of tax/deficit financing (Pauly and Baicker/Skinner). • Implies Medicare becomes Medicaid Lite (or vice versa).

  12. My current favorite whiz-bang theory • Medical spending has grown faster than income; it is a “luxury” good. • Logically, no good can be a luxury good forever or it will eat up 100% + of income • So the share “automatically” has to stop growing. • When this will happen depends on preferences—but could it be happening now?